State muscles grocers over plastic bags

August 21, 2012 - By admin

Aug. 21, 2012

Katy Grimes: The plastic bag activists are at it again, and they are nothing, if not persistent. With the eleventh bill regulating plastic bags in less than 10 years, grocery stores don’t have a chance in California.

Passed today by the Assembly, SB 1219, the latest plastic bag regulation bill, by Sen. Lois Wolk, D-Davis, will require grocery stores to implement, manage, and report on the “At-Store Recycling Program” to the Cal Recycle state agency.

Besides imposing more rules and regulations on privately-owned grocery stores, SB 1219 which appears to be aimed at large grocers like WalMart, Target and other large supermarket chains, will require that stores “place recycling bins in a readily accessible location for consumers, assure the collected bags are recycled, and provide reusable bags. Additionally, stores track the collection, transport, and recycling of plastic carryout bags and regulated manufacturers provide educational materials to assist in recycling (see requirements).”

This could be the work of a full-time employee in some large stores.

“This bill is a really, really bad idea,” Assemblyman Tim Donnelly, R-Hesperia, said on the Assembly floor during debate Tuesday. “Plastics manufacturers are leaving the state. And we’re telling grocery stores, ‘you must take back this product.’”

Assemblyman Brian Jones found irony in a bill specifying what stores must do to recycle, given that much of the purchased food and products put inside of the bags is packaged in plastic. “Is this the best use of our time?” Jones asked.

Specifically, SB 1219 will:

1)Requires stores, defined as supermarkets and stores over 10,000 square feet that include a pharmacy, to establish an at-store recycling program for plastic carryout bags. The
Program requires that:

a) Plastic bags provided by the store must have a label that encourages customers to return the bag for recycling;

b) Stores provide clearly labeled and easily accessible recycling bins;

c) All bags collected be recycled in a manner consistent with the local jurisdiction’s recycling plan;

d) Stores must maintain records relating to the Program for at least three years and make the records available to the local jurisdiction or the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) upon request; and,

e) Stores must make reusable bags available.

2)Requires bag manufacturers to develop educational materials to encourage source reduction and recycling and to make the materials available to stores.

3)Preempts local governments from requiring stores that are complying with the Program to implement separate bag recycling programs, additional auditing or reporting requirements, or
imposing a bag fee.

4)Authorizes a local government or the state to levy fines for stores that violate these requirements.

All of this was set to sunset on January 1, 2013, but SB 1219 will extend that sunset date until 2020.

This is the eleventh bill regulating plastic bags since passage of the first plastic bag law in California in 2006.

Should I reuse or litter?

The rap on plastic bags is that they end up lining street gutters, or in the oceans, rivers and lakes, or just flying around neighborhoods on windy days. The bill analysis states that 60-80 percent of all marine debris and 90 percent of floating debris is plastic. But several studies I’ve read say that while plastic shopping bags entering the marine environment represent a threat  to marine life along with other packaging and other littered items, it has not been quantified.

Who litters?

Who throws their garbage into rivers, lakes, oceans or on the street? I don’t know anyone who tosses the bags onto the street. But when I visit my neighborhood park, there are always plastic bags, food containers, wrappers, and plastic bottles discarded on the grass and around seating areas. In many of Sacramento’s low-income neighborhoods, and public schools, trash is strewn about, including plastic bags and bottles.

So who does the littering? Why go after the plastic bag manufacturers instead of the litterers?

My friends, neighbors and I reuse our plastic bags for garbage, changing kitty litter, for doggie-do bags, or a second time at the store. I used to use them as diaper discard bags when my son was a baby. There are numerous reuses for plastic bags, which most people take advantage of.

Donnelly said that he and his wife reuse plastic bags as garbage bags at home. The fact is that most consumers reuse the bags for something.

While numerous studies focus almost entirely on the cost to the consumer, they forget about the cost to the business, which is significant.

Jones was right when he said, “We should ask ourselves, are we really being efficient by forcing grocery stores to recycle plastic bags?”

“I think we ought to allow the free market to finally be free!” Donnelly said. “Grocery stores run on a thin margin, and can’t afford any more regulations.”

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments(0)
  1. us citizen says:

    I love plastic bags. Its not the bags that are escaping and running loose and wild in the neighborhood! Its the slobs that are using them. Sorry but lower class neighborhoods have no PRIDE where they live, so they dont care that they live in a mess.

  2. larry 62 says:

    They can come up with all these rules and regulations for plastic bag disposal but it is to much to ask a voter for a picture I.D. Besides that, I already have a recycle container that is picked up every other week. Why can’t people use them, I do.

  3. Bob says:

    God, I hate DemoNcrats.

    Everything they do makes my life more difficult and expensive.

    And it turns out platic bags are less of a hazard to the environment than their cherished “reusable” bags.

    http://www.ncpa.org/pdfs/st340.pdf

    But really, their primary motivation is not the environment, it’s control.

    They think they know what is best for everyone so they want to mandate as much as possible how we will be allowed to live our lives.

  4. Gerald Caskey says:

    Its much ado about nothing.They must not have anything to do up there.

  5. Ulysses Uhaul says:

    And those who fear control….GPS in your car or dumb phone are huge invasions of privacy you actually…gladly….pay for….dah!!!!

    Do you want the world to know “everything” you do, where you visit in a public domain data base?

  6. jimmydeeoc says:

    ………..meanwhile, the state deficit is $16 billion (That’s $16,000,000,000 for the numerically-inclined). Insert Nero reference here.

    I have but one quibble, Ms Grimes. While it is true that bag-fee laws are being dreamed up by busybody city councils everywhere, with the effect of literally nickle-and-diming us at the checkout, the “cost to business” will eventually be borne by consumers as well. Someone’s gotta pay for that Hydrocarbon Product Recycling Coordinator Level II.

    Essentially we can look forward to paying for bags both directly AND indirectly!

    If we are lucky, cooler heads and legislative laziness will prevail. (Remember the dire predictions in the mid 1990s which suggested that by 2010 the planet would be covered in a sea of discarded compact disk packaging? Somehow we averted that crisis.)

  7. CalWatchdog says:

    Of course some of the costs will be passed on to consumers. Studies have calculated that it will be approximately $3 – $4 per year. Meanwhile, grocery stores will be required to manage a new recycling program, and doing formal reporting to the state. This takes another employee, and accounting department time, which costs far more than $3-$4 per year.

    Katy

  8. Bob says:

    And if plastic grocery bags were outlawed it would cost me a lot more than 3 or 4 dollars a year.

    First, I will have to buy a set of re-usable bags that will then need to be washed every few weeks. Or I can pay twenty cents per paper bag (what the city council wants to tax us for paper bags when they outlaw plastic bags). Assuming the later, that would be at least a dollar a week.

    Next, I will need to buy plastic bags for what I use the free grocery bags for.

    I estimate that all this would cost me at least $75 to $100 per year.

  9. This sucks says:

    Larger chain stores would probably resort to just paying the fine than jump through all those hoops.

  10. pj says:

    Why don’t the stores man up and sue?!

  11. Kristin says:

    Okay. These liberal fools are the reason we got plastic bags in the first place. Because the environmentalist wackos didn’t want us to cut down trees for paper bags, we had to have plastic. Now they get their panties in a twist because plastic isn’t biodegradable. NO DUH. We tried to fight you back then, probably 25 years ago now or longer. Now we’re having the same STUPID fight.

    We need to smack ourselves upside our collective foreheads for letting the commies con us into such idiocy. Will we never learn?

  12. James Li says:

    “c) All bags collected be recycled in a manner consistent with the local jurisdiction’s recycling plan”

    So, if the local recycling center doesn’t take plastic bags (and most don’t), does this mean that “manner consistent” means the stores can just dump them in the trash?

    Some branches of larger stores (e.g., Safeway) already collect bags for recycling. However, given the transportation costs, it appears to be more for public relations purposes than, say, reducing the emission of greenhouse gases.

  13. JoeS says:

    LA Times delivers their newspapers in plastic bags. Shouldn’t they pay $.10

Know Your Bloggers

Joseph Perkins
Joseph Perkins, now assistant editor of the Orange County Register Opinion Pages, started his career as an editorial writer for the Wall Street Journal. After serving on the White House Staff of former Vice President Dan Quayle he wrote for the San Diego Union-Tribune where he authored a nationally-syndicated column. Before writing for CalWatchdog.com, Mr. Perkins was also Business Editor for San Diego Magazine.
Chris Reed
Chris Reed is a regular contributor to Cal Watchdog. Reed is an editorial writer for U-T San Diego. Before joining the U-T in July 2005, he was the opinion-page columns editor and wrote the featured weekly Unspin column for The Orange County Register. Reed was on the national board of the Association of Opinion Page Editors from 2003-2005. From 2000 to 2005, Reed made more than 100 appearances as a featured news analyst on Los Angeles-area National Public Radio affiliate KPCC-FM. From 1990 to 1998, Reed was an editor, metro columnist and film critic at the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin in Ontario. Reed has a political science degree from the University of Hawaii (Hilo campus), where he edited the student newspaper, the Vulcan News, his senior year. He is on Twitter: @chrisreed99.
Brian Calle
Brian Calle is Editor-in-Chief of CalWatchdog.com and the Opinion Editor for the Orange County Register. His work has appeared in Bloomberg, Fox News, Forbes, Real Clear Politics, Human Events, Real Clear Markets and City Journal, among other websites and publications. Find him on Twitter: @briancalle
John Seiler
John Seiler has been writing about California for 25 years. That includes 22 years as an editorial writer for the Orange County Register and two years for CalWatchDog.com, where he is managing editor. He attended the University of Michigan and graduated from Hillsdale College. He was a Russian linguist in U.S. Army military intelligence from 1978 to 1982. He was an editor and writer for Phillips Publishing Company from 1983 to 1986. He has written for Policy Review, Chronicles, LewRockwell.com, Flash Report and numerous other publications. His email: writejohnseiler@gmail.com

Blog Archive

Archive By Categories
  • California economy
  • Corruption
  • Demographics
  • Education
  • Fracking
  • Health Care
  • Income inequality
  • Infrastructure
  • Inside Government
  • Law enforcement
  • Media
  • Obamacare
  • Obamacare implementation
  • Pension Reform
  • Politics and Elections
  • Regulations
  • Rights and Liberties
  • Seen at the Capitol
  • Taxes
  • Technology
  • Thought police
  • Waste, Fraud and Abuse