LA council attack on San Onofre might bring blackouts to Orange County, San Diego

San_Onofre_Nuclear PlantApril 29, 2013

By Joseph Perkins

After giving a speech in which he refused to bail out New York City from impending bankruptcy, Gerald Ford prompted the famously pithy headline in the New York Daily News:  FORD TO CITY:  DROP DEAD.

The Los Angeles City Council this week did not exactly tell San Diego and Orange County to drop dead, but it did send them a message that LA is perfectly sanguine with the prospect that the state’s second- and third-largest counties spend the upcoming summer in the dark.

In a unanimous vote, the 15-member council passed a resolution urging federal regulators not to allow the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station to restart either of its two reactors, both of which have been offline since January 2012, owing to premature wear on steam generator tubes.

Essentially, the council wants the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission to reverse its finding earlier this month that allowing Southern California Edison to fire up one of the nuclear plant’s reactors would pose no threat to public safety. SCE has a 78 percent ownership stake in San Onofre, San Diego Gas & Electric 20 percent and the city of Riverside 2 percent.

The council is following the advice of S. David Freeman, a former head of the Los Angeles Department of Water, who is now a “consultant” with the extremist environmental group Friends of the Earth, which is crusading to permanently shutter San Onofre.

Freeman and anti-nuke Friends demand that the NRC require Edison to obtain a full-blown license amendment to restart San Onofre. That may sound reasonable, but it entails courtroom-like proceedings at which Edison would be on public trial.

All Edison wants to do is get San Onofre operating at reduced capacity by this upcoming summer, the peak season for electricity demand in the Southern California region.

When San Onofre is operating at full capacity, it accounts for a fifth of the electricity both Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric deliver to their business and residential customers.

Rolling blackouts

Now, if L.A. businesses and residences faced the prospect of a summer with 20 percent less electricity than normal, and the resultant possibility of rolling blackouts, there’s no way the City Council would urge that San Onofre remain idle.

But because San Onofre generally doesn’t supply atoms to the L.A. Department of Water and Power, the City Council felt free to dump on the nuclear plant, no matter the consequence to Edison’s Orange County customers and SDG&E’s San Diego County customers.

In fact, a report last month by the California Independent System Operator (CaISO), which oversees the electrical grid for 80 percent of the state, warns that the combination of the continued shutdown of San Onofre and the significant drought-related reduction of hydroelectric generation — which helped replace the nuclear plant’s electrons last summer — could cause “Enron-style” power shortages this summer.

While the power shortages would affect all of Southern California, they would fall hardest on southern Orange County and San Diego County.

That suits the L.A. City Council just fine. After all, who cares if the bumpkins to the South have to deal with rolling blackouts this summer?


Write a comment
  1. Bill - San Jose
    Bill - San Jose 29 April, 2013, 09:36

    We won’t see that up in NoCal … yet …

    I love it. You have to have this type of mayhem before change occurs.

    Reply this comment
  2. jimmydeeoc
    jimmydeeoc 29 April, 2013, 09:39

    Orange and San Diego County to City: Pound sand.

    (If only…..there are far too many in both counties who think power can be harnessed from herds of Pegasus as they fly throw the sky…..)

    Reply this comment
  3. Ted Steele, The Decider
    Ted Steele, The Decider 29 April, 2013, 13:21

    Nuke power is safe, clean (except for the huge waste issue) and efficient, although expensive. The problem with SONGS is that the technological basis for the plant is wildly outdated. The plant has leaked, belched out radioactive emissions and safety violated with regularity almost since the day it went on line. ALL of that has been widely reported including it’s last fiasco of leaking radiation, as yet unable to be resolved in full. There is still no longitudinal cancer study around the plant.

    Songs needs to go. It has outlived it’s life based on what it’s builders intended.

    Reply this comment
  4. PJ
    PJ 29 April, 2013, 19:58

    When the nuke plant broke down, I predicted the zealots would never let it operate again. Guess I was right.

    Obama and his tsars want high, high energy costs. They will get them.

    Reply this comment
  5. Ted Steele DD
    Ted Steele DD 29 April, 2013, 20:39

    pj’s– i think the “zealots” are just worried that the dangerous plant might hurt alot of people like has happened elsewhere so many other times, that’s all.

    Reply this comment
  6. Itachee
    Itachee 1 May, 2013, 08:23

    Clearly the LA City Council and power users in So. Cal. fit the definition of low information voters/power users. So they deserve the black outs that will befall them this summer. And it is quite possible, if not probable, that CalISO’s now month old forecasts of hydro power generation are going to turn out to be overly optimistic. That because just released updated forecasts of runoff into reservoirs up and down the state are showing less reservoir inflow than predicted just last month.

    On one hand hope that CalISO doesn’t try to raid power from other parts of the state power grid, with resulting blackouts, to backfill shortages in So Cal. Time will tell and we in the Central Valley will be watching.

    On the other hand I hope CalISO does so that power users far and wide get a grasp of the power shortage reality our state is facing because of environmental activism and the NIMBY mentality.

    Reply this comment
  7. Ted Steele, Navigator
    Ted Steele, Navigator 1 May, 2013, 10:16

    Itchy— It aint a nimby situation little buddy— the back yard will be the southwest US if SONGS has a catostrophic failure. Or should I say when it does.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Tags assigned to this article:
Joseph PerkinsSan Onofreblackoutselectricity

Related Articles

AB 32 Poll To Be Released Today

Later today a poll will be released demonstrating that a large majority of Californians want AB 32 suspended. The consequences

Harris distorts democracy to aid unions

Feb. 20, 2012 We expect all sides in politics to fight hard, given the stakes involved, but our system rests

Fed bills could be key to CA water storage

There was a lot of hoopla last week over the California Legislature and Gov. Jerry Brown putting a bipartisan water bond