Councilman Gil Cedillo’s ‘circular logic’

Councilman Gil Cedillo’s ‘circular logic’

circular reasoning

For an article I was editing, I checked out L.A. City Councilman Gil Cedillo’s bio on his Website. It explains, “Gil Cedillo has found a balance with his underlying message that progressive politics is good for business. This circular logic of ‘what is good for the people is good for business’ is what allows this legislator to have his cake and eat it too—a working class tilt without antagonizing the business class.”

It’s curious that he thinks “circular logic,” also called “circular reasoning,” is a good thing. Circular logic uses the fallacy “begging the question.”

For example, suppose someone said, as many did last fall, including Gov. Jerry Brown, “We need to raise taxes with Proposition 30 because the schools need more money.”

That begs the question: Do schools really need more money? And other questions: Could the schools be run better with less money? Do we even need public schools?

In Cedillo’s case, the “circular logic” cited on the Website begs the question: Is what’s good for the people really good for business”? And another question: Is what he’s doing really good for business, and for the people?

 

 

4 comments

Write a comment
  1. Steve Mehlman
    Steve Mehlman 24 July, 2013, 02:23

    Slow news day, eh, John?

    “That begs the question: Do schools really need more money? And other questions: Could the schools be run better with less money? Do we even need public schools?”

    By voting yes on Prop. 30, the voters answered those questions. Just because they aren’t the answers you wanted doesn’t mean they are not the correct answers.

    Reply this comment
  2. Donkey
    Donkey 24 July, 2013, 03:16

    How a RAGWUS feeder views Math: “The different branches of Arithmetic — Ambition, Distraction, Uglification, and Derision.” Thanks Alice!!

    The voters are beomg duped by liers and thieves Mehlman!!! :
    )

    Reply this comment
  3. admin
    admin 24 July, 2013, 14:41

    Steve: Thank you for providing another example of circular logic!

    — John Seiler

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply


Tags assigned to this article:
Gil CedilloJohn Seilercircular reasoning

Related Articles

Just who wants to “take back America”?

Jan. 4, 2013 By John Seiler Last week I noted that Sam Donaldson attacked the Tea Partiers for their slogan,

Illogical liberal view of Sen. Ted Cruz’ Canadian birth

May 29, 2013 By John Seiler Sometimes I wish people would take a course in logic. Here’s a free one.

Radicals almost burned alive UC official faulted for Occupy response

As the left’s thoughtcrime offensive gears up, the latest victim is former UC Berkeley Chancellor Robert Birgenau, who backed out of