Report on massive cost overrun may be turning point for troubled bullet train

Despite Gov. Jerry Brown’s full-throated defense of the troubled bullet train project in his State of the State speech Thursday in Sacramento, a consultant’s report warning of a huge cost overrun on the project’s first segment in the Central Valley could end up a turning point in the high-speed rail saga.

The cost of the 119-mile segment was originally estimated at $6 billion. But the main consulting firm on the project, WSP (formerly Parsons Brinckerhoff), told the California High-Speed Rail Authority’s board at a recent meeting that it was now projected at $10.6 billion – a 77 percent increase.

The fact that the overrun was so high on the part of the statewide project with the least-challenging geography appeared to startle some rail authority board members and some Democratic state lawmakers.

On Tuesday, Assemblyman Jim Patterson, R-Fresno – a longtime bullet train skeptic – was joined by Sen. Jim Beall, D-San Jose, in a letter asking for a formal state audit of the $67 billion project. Beall is chairman of the Senate transportation committee.

The letter was sent to Assemblyman Al Muratsuchi, the Torrance Democrat who chairs the Joint Legislative Audit Committee. It has the authority to direct state Auditor Elaine Howle to audit the bullet-train project without the blessing of the governor, who in 2016 vetoed a bill that would have increased oversight of the project and the rail authority. Previous calls for an audit have been blocked by Democratic lawmakers.

While the bullet train has been regularly scrutinized by the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office, its reports tend to note problems without offering harsh criticisms or sweeping judgments.

State audit could influence vote on June bullet-train ballot measure

By contrast, Howle takes no prisoners if she believes she has evidence of incompetent management, deceit or secrecy. In the past two years, her scathing criticism of the University of California over admissions policies that more than tripled out-of-state students at UC campuses and over UC President Janet Napolitano’s aides’ interference with her office’s attempts to gather information led to admission policy changes and to a state law barring such interference by state agencies.

If the state auditor was directed to review the bullet train project in coming weeks and completes her report faster than usual, it could affect a bullet train-related measure on the June primary ballot.

Last July, then-Assembly Republican leader Chad Mayes of Yucca Valley agreed to help Democrats round up enough GOP votes to extend the state’s cap-and-trade program until 2030 in return for the Legislature ordering the placement of a Mayes-drafted constitutional amendment before state voters in the primary.

If it won approval, the amendment would mandate that in 2024, the Legislature must have an up-or-down vote on whether to continue allowing the state government to use cap-and-trade revenue on the bullet train – with a two-thirds threshold for approval in both the Assembly and Senate.

Cap-and-trade auction funds are the only firm source of revenue the rail authority will have after spending the remaining $10 billion in funds left from a $3.3 billion grant from the Obama administration and the original $9.95 billion in state bond funds that voters approved for the project in 2008.

Cutting off the bullet train’s access to cap-and-trade dollars could kill the project without it ever having carried a passenger – leaving a massive white elephant in the Central Valley. Even before the overrun was reported, authority officials said in 2016 that they didn’t have enough money to build their planned segment linking San Jose with Bakersfield. Officials told a U.S. House subcommittee hearing that the project’s eastern terminus would be an almond orchard about 30 miles northwest of Bakersfield.


Write a comment
  1. Lennie Luddite
    Lennie Luddite 28 January, 2018, 13:07

    “…leaving a massive white elephant in the Central Valley.”

    Got a name for it: Brownhenge. Hearkens back to the true good ol’ days when Gov. Rayes de Luna’s ancestors got stoned on the coast of England. Brownhenge — A Bridge Too Far.

    Reply this comment
  2. Bogiewheel
    Bogiewheel 28 January, 2018, 16:42

    Measure thrice, cut once.

    Reply this comment
  3. Richard Rider
    Richard Rider 28 January, 2018, 23:16

    Keep in mind that the “photo” above is a fraud. Just like every promise that HSR promoters made. All lies.

    * MUCH lower ridership now expected.
    * FAR fewer jobs than promised.
    * MUCH lower speed than the 220MPH projected.
    * FAR higher ticket prices than touted.
    * FAR longer travel times between destinations.
    * MUCH higher construction costs than projected.
    * PRIVATE INVESTORS without subsidies — they have never even appeared on the horizon.
    * MOST IMPORTANT: A DRAMATICALLY reduced HSR system. San Diego voters were promised a HSR connection to the rest of the state. No longer.

    In short, today’s HSR not the HSR system we voted on. What we voted on was — and IS — a fraud.

    Reply this comment
    • Joe
      Joe 29 January, 2018, 14:23

      …leaving a massive white elephant in the Central Valley

      Look on the bright side, Richard with that huge white elephant they could open a circus and recoup a little bit of what they’ve already stolen from taxpayers.

      Reply this comment
    • Ex Democrat
      Ex Democrat 1 February, 2018, 21:10

      Were you expecting accountability like they have in legitimate business ?

      Reply this comment
  4. Ex Democrat
    Ex Democrat 1 February, 2018, 21:08

    Use state surplus to finish it. Then give the rest to help illegal immigrants and pay for a new study on the possibility of raising taxes and alienating more businesses.

    Reply this comment
  5. Ex Democrat
    Ex Democrat 1 February, 2018, 21:17

    Connect train to Mexico to hasten arrival of more illegals that will vote Democratic. Make sure to enact yet another tax to cover the additional expense.

    Reply this comment
  6. Ex Democrat
    Ex Democrat 4 February, 2018, 11:43

    Why not have Pelosi’s 4 million illegals finish it. That should keep costs down. Have the ones picking her grapes at her vineyard help in the off season.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Chris Reed

Chris Reed

Chris Reed is a regular contributor to Cal Watchdog. Reed is an editorial writer for U-T San Diego. Before joining the U-T in July 2005, he was the opinion-page columns editor and wrote the featured weekly Unspin column for The Orange County Register. Reed was on the national board of the Association of Opinion Page Editors from 2003-2005. From 2000 to 2005, Reed made more than 100 appearances as a featured news analyst on Los Angeles-area National Public Radio affiliate KPCC-FM. From 1990 to 1998, Reed was an editor, metro columnist and film critic at the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin in Ontario. Reed has a political science degree from the University of Hawaii (Hilo campus), where he edited the student newspaper, the Vulcan News, his senior year. He is on Twitter: @chrisreed99.

Related Articles

Petty corruption all too common at CA special districts

The California government agencies that provide water, sewage, trash and other special services are often oblivious to ethical norms and

Arnold Was Detached As Gov.

John Seiler: As I’ve said before, the problems between ex-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and his estranged wife, Maria Shriver, are their

George Skelton: 34% is a ‘small minority’

Dec. 13, 2012 By Chris Reed The persistence with which George Skelton writes silly, slanted stuff is hard to exaggerate.