‘Transit workers vs. just plain workers’

‘Transit workers vs. just plain workers’

hyperlinear-bart2A renewed BART strike could bring chaos to the Bay Area on Monday. But as CalWatchdog founder Steven Greenhut points out in his U-T San Diego column, the BART labor strife isn’t prompting the public reaction that transit unions may have expected.

“… the most fascinating development [is] the lack of sympathy liberal-oriented Bay Area residents and even Democratic politicians are showing toward the BART workers.

“’I couldn’t even get a burrito without confronting someone who asked that we take our stand on behalf of the public,’ said San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee, according to published reports. He said that BART riders need a ‘voice at this table.’ One newspaper column was aptly headlined, ‘In BART strike, it’s transit workers vs. just plain workers.’ …

“These reactions are a sign that the public is grasping a core point: When officials give in to excessive compensation demands, it is the public that pays the price. BART employees are an unsympathetic bunch given that their average pay is above $80,000 a year, they make no contributions to their generous pension plans and pay only 92 bucks a month for some of the best medical benefits on the planet. They are at the top of the compensation heap for California transit workers.”

Shades of Detroit

If BART’s compensation practices sound absurd, they shouldn’t. Consider the details behind Detroit’s bankruptcy:

“Fully 99.6 percent of the city’s retiree health-care liabilities are unfunded, and the program generally pays 80 percent to 100 percent of retirees’ medical costs. From 2007 to 2012, the city’s two biggest pension programs paid out $3.3 billion more in benefits than they took in through contributions or investment income. Unfunded obligations account for $9.2 billion of Detroit’s $18 billion debt: $3.5 billion comes from the pension part and $5.7 billion comes from the retiree health-care liability.

“… Salaries and benefits for current employees consume 36 percent of the city’s revenue. Legacy obligations, which include pension contributions and benefit payments, take an additional 39 percent of revenue….

“In many ways, Detroit is a model of tax-and-spend liberalism. … A few years ago, the nonpartisan Bay Area Center for Voting Research rated Detroit as the most liberal city in America.”

If the Bay Area wants to avoid its own Detroitization, regional leaders will stand up to the BART fleecers and say enough is enough.



Write a comment
  1. Rex the Wonderdog!
    Rex the Wonderdog! 9 August, 2013, 23:53

    BART station agents are GED customer service jobs that would pay $18K-$22K per year MAX in real life……. with no insurance of 401K….

    Reply this comment
  2. S Moderation Douglas
    S Moderation Douglas 10 August, 2013, 12:59

    Shades of Detroit?

    By most accounts, Detroit pay and pensions are lower than average for cities its size. And they are NOT responsible for the bankruptcy.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Six Californias?

Dissatisfaction with the current state of California continues to spread. The latest idea: Split the mega-state into six smaller states.

New dose of Obamacare pain arriving by mail

After nearly four years of covering the Affordable Care Act, more commonly referred to as “Obamacare,” it's hard not to

CalWatchdog Morning Read – May 26

  Clinton, Sanders tied in CA, both lead Trump San Jose Senate race splits Democrats Cap-and-trade credits ain’t selling High-speed