CARB scandal also shames California media


Nov. 5, 2012

By Chris Reed

It was four years ago yesterday that the California Air Resources Board sent out a letter that marked the beginning of an amazingly juicy and revealing scandal that the Los Angeles Times and San Jose Mercury-News chose to ignore — a scandal that the Sacramento Bee later tried to pretend it hadn’t ignored.

In the Nov. 4, 2008, letter, state Secretary for Environmental Protection Linda S. Adams responded to S. Stanley Young of the National Institute of Statistical Sciences, based in Research Triangle Park, North Carolina. Young had questioned the expertise of the authors of an air board report on the purportedly extreme health risks posed by tiny airborne pollutants contained in diesel emissions. Adams wrote that Young was off-base:

“Regarding the professional background of the authors, the lead author and project coordinator, Hien Tran, holds a doctorate degree in statistics at the University of California at Davis …”

Except he didn’t, as I established seven weeks later. (I had been contacted by UCLA epidemiologist James L. Enstrom, who worked with Young in questioning Tran’s credentials.) But for months, no California newspaper, except the editorial page of my newspaper, the U-T San Diego, covered this undeniable scandal. This greenout occurred even though Rough & Tumble had my blog item on Tran’s deception as its lead story for several hours on Dec. 23, 2008.

Truth kept from CARB leaders for nearly a year

Incredibly, most of the governing board of CARB didn’t hear about Tran’s deceit from the staff of air board chair Mary Nichols for nearly a year.

What followed the events of December 2008 was a slow-unfolding debacle in which Enstrom became a martyr for scientific integrity and Tran turned out to be the perfect symbol of CARB arrogance and media incompetence, unprofessionalism and bias.

Tran did have a statistics Ph.D. — a mail-order document (shown above) from an online degree mill with a mailing address that matched a New York City UPS office and that was associated with a fugitive pedophile named Avrohom Mondrowitz.

But Tran didn’t get fired by CARB. He only got suspended without pay for two months and demoted. He now makes $87,492.52 a year as a CARB pollution analyst.

Given that the rules for diesel particulates that Tran crafted were costly and controversial, isn’t this a perfect storm for a scandal gleefully detailed by a media eager to heap scorn on some really bad public servants? How can the pedophile link not be irresistible?

Media were air board’s partner in deceit

Well, when you’re as deeply in the green tank as most of the people covering CARB, it’s plenty resistible.

(The San Francisco Chronicle did a solid job. But, incredibly, it didn’t depict “Thornhill University” as a diploma mill. It called it a “distance learning” institution.)

The L.A. Times has never mentioned Hien Tran in its pages. The Mercury-News never covered the scandal either, with Tran only mentioned in two columns by non-Merc writers.

And when the scandal finally broke wide open, the Sacramento Bee — the newspaper of record for state government — tried to rewrite history. In December 2009, after CARB’s governing board publicly confirmed Hien Tran’s lies, Bee columnist Dan Walters said the scandal had received “a couple of brief media mentions.” In his front-page story, Jim Sanders of the Bee said that Tran’s lies had been detailed by “bloggers.”

Actually, as Nexis confirms, I’d written about it over and over again on the pages of the UT San Diego — a total of 10 editorials and columns. Lois Henry, star columnist for the Bakersfield Californian, had also covered it thoroughly. I pointed this out to several people at the Bee. None thought it was worth correcting. Why? Because the Bee’s account made the Bee look good, but not the truth.

This is your mainstream media, California. I don’t know what we did to deserve this.

I was asked on a radio show a few months ago how on Earth reporters could actually promote the bizarre CARB claim that arbitrarily increasing the cost of energy via AB 32 would somehow help the economy.

I replied that nothing is beneath California’s environmental journalists — starting with those at the L.A. Times and Mercury-News.

Consider the amazingly juicy basics of the Tran scandal:

* Costly, controversial pollution rules were crafted by a guy who lied about his scientific background.

* The liar’s mail-order degree came from a bogus institution linked to a fugitive pedophile.

* The liar not only didn’t get fired, he continues to write state regulations.

* His leading academic critic did get fired (by UCLA).

* The boss of CARB didn’t tell members of the governing board about the scandal until forced to nine months later by comments made at a public hearing.

Air board boss the luckiest woman in the world

If the L.A. Times and Mercury-News didn’t think this was worth sharing with their readers, their reporters and editors are capable of infinite distortions on behalf of their green gods and their friends at the air board.

CARB Director Mary Nichols is the luckiest woman on Earth. In any responsible organization, her handling of the Tran scandal gets her fired. But here in California, she’s a media hero who could soon become a Cabinet member if President Obama wins re-election.

If that happens, I hope someone brings up Hien Tran in the confirmation hearings — so the L.A. Times and Mercury-News can ignore him all over again, and the Sac Bee can pretend once again in its coverage that its staff wasn’t part of a shameful media cover-up.



Write a comment
  1. Dyspeptic
    Dyspeptic 5 November, 2012, 11:00

    It’s all pretty simple really. The establishment lapdog news media exist to carry water for The Overlords they serve. Most “news” articles from high profile media organizations are nothing but press releases from party headquarters, usually a certain Blue Team faction whose academic apologists control journalism schools across the fruited plains. No silly conspiracy theories needed, just good old fashioned partisan flim-flam mixed with public credulity. The old adage “There’s a sucker born every minute” doesn’t tell the half of it.

    Reply this comment
  2. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 5 November, 2012, 14:05

    Dys…you’re one unhappy puppy!

    Reply this comment
  3. econprof
    econprof 5 November, 2012, 14:58

    Thank you, Chris Reed, for reviewing the record for us. The San Diego U-T has been the only truth-teller among CA media regarding this, and other, issues.
    There was much talk, recently denied by the U-T, that U-T owner Doug Manchester might buy the LA Times. I think that would be delicious, given the Times’ sorry record of honesty and journalistic integrity.
    In the last few days, talk has surfaced of Murdock, another conservative, buying the LA Times. Bring it on!

    Reply this comment
  4. Charles Clotz
    Charles Clotz 5 November, 2012, 19:58

    Chris Reed is frankly a hero. This is a man with a passion for the truth and a lifetime of relentless fact finding, against the odds and incessant voices that are constantly trying to silence him. Before the new ownership took over the UT, Chris Reed was honestly the only reason that I subscribed. Now with his talent getting the exposure that he deserves, Californians throughout the state will quickly become enlightened into the hard to find truth to so many stories. Thank you, thank you, thank you Mr. Reed, your are a world-class freedom fighter and we honor your efforts on behalf of integrity and the truth.

    Reply this comment
  5. Hondo
    Hondo 6 November, 2012, 07:00

    Say, where can I get one of those ‘distance learning’ degrees. Hell, I’ll work for 65k and say whatever Moonbeam wants.

    Reply this comment
  6. Hondo
    Hondo 6 November, 2012, 07:04

    Of course I’ll need one of those ‘ethnic’ sounding names. How does Hondo van Tran sound?

    Reply this comment
  7. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 6 November, 2012, 13:13

    Say, where can I get one of those ‘distance learning’ degrees.

    Reply this comment
  8. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 6 November, 2012, 13:14

    Of course I’ll need one of those ‘ethnic’ sounding names. How does Hondo van Tran sound?

    Reply this comment
  9. Fred
    Fred 5 September, 2014, 21:02

    I don’t mean to bolster the use of false credentials, because in some cases that could in fact be disastrous. However, it should be noted that a Body builder with no science background enacted AB32 which is now the green house gas regulation which strangles the state. Instead of giving more credence to the diploma-cracy which empower regulators, why not attack the facts, the regulatory law, and the lact of scientific rigor? You are only giving credence to PhDs, and last time I checked, most of them voted for more regulation, more government, etc.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

First CalWatchdog Caption Contest!

We have been rendered speechless. Words escape us. Help CalWatchdog caption this photo of our colleagues, taken in the CalWatchdog

Politicians seek special enviro deal on arena

This is Part One of a two-part series. March 30, 2013 By Katy Grimes SACRAMENTO — The unusually speedy approval

For The Los Angeles Times, a highly revealing juxtaposition

If you’re a conservative or libertarian who’s not just mad but astounded by how much the media protect Barack Obama,