Do union activists work for Gov. Brown, farm board?

Do union activists work for Gov. Brown, farm board?

Guzman 1SACRAMENTO — The revolving door among political consultants, community organizers and state government revolves right into the governor’s office and the Agriculture Labor Relations Board.

In 2011, Gov. Jerry Brown appointed Martha Guzman-Aceves deputy legislative secretary for agriculture, environment and natural resources. Before that, she was a founding partner of Cultivo Consulting, which says it engages in lobbying, political campaigning and community organizing in California. It's a lobbying and outreach firm specializing in social, economic and environmental justice.

Guzman 2She also was listed on 2011 tax returns (pictured nearby) as president and CEO for Communities for the New California Education Fund, a 501(c)(3) organization “committed to achieving environmental, economic, and socially just public policy for working class families in the rural areas of California.”

Her biography says she “previously served as the Legislative Coordinator for the United Farm Workers (UFW) AFL-CIO covering a range of labor and environmental issues. She worked for the UFW for five years in both their political and research departments.”

Alegria De La Cruz was appointed by Brown on Dec. 13, 2011 as Regional Director for the Agricultural Labor Relations Board.  She was Guzman-Aceves’ partner in the CNC Education Fund. She previously worked for the Center on Race, Poverty and the Environment as a staff attorney. Prior to the center, De La Cruz worked for the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation as a staff attorney.

Cultivo ConsultingFarm workers appealed to Gov. Brown

I spent four hours earlier this month with nearly 700 farm workers protesting the state forcing them to join the United Farm Workers union. They made an appeal to the governor at his office.

Silvia Lopez, leader of the farm workers' group, thought Brown invited her and five other farm workers to meet with him. Instead, Brown sent them Guzman-Aceves, who as noted above was a former UFW official.

At the end of the meeting, Guzman-Aceves offered to contact Silas Shawver, the Visalia representative for the Agricultural Labor Relations Board. This frustrated and angered the farm workers. They said Shawver has been instrumental in forcing the UFW on them. Guzman-Aceves offered no other help.

Shawver used to be an attorney with California Rural Legal Assistance. Guzman-Aceves also worked for CRLA, as did her associate, Alegria De La Cruz. So did Jennifer Hernandez, Guzman-Aceves' partner in Cultivo Consulting.

Shawver is godfather to De La Cruz’s child, according to a story on the Western Growers website. And Shawver worked with De La Cruz at the CLRA as staff counsel, specializing in wage claims against agricultural employers. Shawver now works for the ALRB as Regional Director in Visalia.

After the meeting with Guzman-Aceves in the governor's office, the farm workers told me they felt they'd been railroaded. Silvia Lopez said, “They never planned on listening to us.”

Guzman 3Martha Guzman-Aceves

I dug out more information on Guzman-Aceves. Her biography says, “Martha is co-founder of Communities for a New California, a 501(c)(4) [sic], and Cultivo Consulting, a political consulting partnership.”

Under CNC's umbrella are the Communities for a New California Education Fund, a 501(c)(3) charity; the Communities for a New California Inc., a 501 (c)(4) charity; and the Communities for a New California Fresno-Tulare Independent Expenditure Committee. According to federal regulations, an independent expenditure is “an expenditure by a person for a communication expressly advocating the election or defeat of a clearly identified candidate that is not made in cooperation, consultation, or concert with, or at the request or suggestion of, a candidate, a candidate's authorized committee, or their agents, or a political party committee or its agents.”

However, while Guzman-Aceves has served as a public official in the Brown Administration, CNC lobbied the Legislature and governor’s office on various issues, including AB1081, federal immigration policy enforcement. AB1081's bill analysis shows CNC listed among the supporters.

Guzman tax signatureCommunities for a New California

Guzman-Aceves signed the IRS tax return for Communities for a New California Education Fund as CEO on Feb. 29, 2012. Click on the picture at right to see her signature. The full tax return can be seen at this link. But according to the 2011 California Environmental Scorecard of the California League of Conservation Voters, she was appointed “early in his term” in 2011, the prior year, as Brown's “Deputy Legislative Secretary for Agriculture.”

She used a residential address located in a Sacramento neighborhood on the non-profit IRS form, which is on the Guidestar rating website for CNC.

And someone at the CNC received $14,740 for “travel, meetings and auto” expenses, the IRS tax return reported.

On the IRS form, CNC has a public charity status and checked off the box indicating that it receives a substantial part of its support from the government.

Cultivo Consulting

The bio on the Cultivo Consulting website  reads:

“We have fifteen (15) years [sic] experience in lobbying, political campaigning, and community organizing across the state of California. Our commitment is to ensure that non-profit and community organizations are able to move an effective and successful policy agenda at all levels, providing comprehensive project management, lobbying, strategic advising, facilitation and coalition building services. We believe in promoting policies that are socially, economically and environmentally just. Headquartered in Sacramento with an additional office in Los Angeles, California, Cultivo Consulting provides the solution to your statewide organizational policy needs.”

The bio for Jennifer Hernandez on the website says the firm was started in 2008 and reads:

“Currently Jennifer is a Partner with Cultivo Consulting, a consulting firm started in 2008 aimed at helping nonprofits and community organizations participate in public policy shaping from the local to state levels.”

Hernandez also worked for the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, “where she coordinated efforts with the Poder Popular Program, a project funded by the California Endowment.” “Poder Popular para la Salud del Pueblo” means “The Power of the People for the Health of the Community,” and was “a community organization designed to empower agricultural workers.”

“In the 2004 Presidential Election cycle, Jennifer worked with Voices for Working Families, the second largest 527 [tax-exempt organization] that cycle, which conducted voter education, registration, mobilization, and voter protection activities in communities of color in seven battleground states,” the bio says.Guzman URL, accessed 8 am, Oct. 11, 2013

The Cultivo website still maintains a web page for Guzman-Aceves — but there is no actual reference to her on the web page. See the nearby picture, which was captured at 8 am on Oct. 11, 2013. Notice the URL in the upper left-hand corner, which includes her name:

However, the text of the page reads:

“We're sorry, but there is an error with your selection.”

The phone number still listed on the website also is revealing: 916.524.2241.

tracer report shows Guzman 4the phone number rings to a cell phone owned by Guzman-Aceves, where a voice mail message recorded by a child says, “Hi. You’ve reached Martha Guzman-Aceves. Please leave her a message.”

CRLA and community for a new CA connections

Listed as officers of CNC on the IRS Form 990, along with Guzman-Aceves, are Jennifer Hernandez, Alegria De La Cruz, Phoebe Seaton and Charles S. Eaton.Guzman 5 Guzman-Aceves, Hernandez, Seaton and De La Cruz all worked at CRLA.

Seaton is an attorney with the CLR, and is listed as the Communities for a New California Education Fund, Board of Directors Secretary. Seaton also was listed in a CRLA Annual Report as the Community Equity Initiative Program Director. The CEI's “goals are to eliminate infrastructure inequity in disadvantaged, unincorporated communities.”

Eaton is a Ph.D. candidate at UC Berkeley. He wrote “Stronger Together in Fresno” in the collection, “In Critical Solidarity,” and “Student Unionism and Sustaining Student Power.


Related Articles

Caltrans accused of waste, sloth

  March 18, 2010 By ANTHONY PIGNATARO “Caltrans is a good organization with lots of good policies and procedures,” Manas Thananant told

Why CA carbon auction and overall AB 32 approach are doomed

This month marks the seventh anniversary of Arnold Schwarzenegger signing AB 32 amid an orgy of self-congratulation over this alleged

Will "Going Green" Backfire?

With nearly every politician — from city councils to state legislators, governors  and congress – embracing green technology as the