Activists try to stop crude-by-rail

Activists try to stop crude-by-rail


Communities for a Better Environment“Boom!” read the signs carried by some of the five dozen or so protesters who raised a ruckus Saturday outside the Kinder Morgan rail yard in the Contra Costa County city of Richmond.

The aim of the environmental and community activists is to stop further rail shipments of crude oil extracted from North Dakota’s Bakken oilfield to refineries in Richmond and other California cities. They claim Bakken crude is highly flammable and explosive.

They point to an accident last year in Lac-Megantic, Quebec that occurred when an unattended freight train – which happened to be carrying Bakken crude – derailed and caught fire, resulting in the tragic deaths of 47 people.

Andres Soto, an organizer for Communities for a Better Environment, suggested it is only a matter of time before a similar tragedy occurs near one of the cities along the rail line on which the Bakken crude is shipped.

“What’s really scary,” he told the Oakland Tribune, “is on the other side of these ‘bomb trains’ are schools and houses.”


Yet, neither Soto nor any other of the demonstrators outside the Kinder Morgan rail yard expressed similar concern about rail shipments of other potential hazardous fuels, like ethanol, which is used as an oxygenate in gasoline sold in California.

In fact, there have been, over the past years, at least a half-dozen train derailments around the country that resulted in fiery explosions fueled by corn-based ethanol. That includes the derailment of freight train four years ago that was traveling from Barstow to Stockton. A tanker car carrying ethanol burst into flames, creating a toxic cloud.

No one is suggesting that California regulators ban ethanol-by-rail shipments. But environmental groups and community activists are demanding that the state ban crude-by-rail. They dismiss recent lab tests of Bakken crude (tapped from Marathon Petroleum’s Capline Pipeline) suggesting that the fuel source is not nearly as dangerous as they have represented.

For at least some of those determined to stop crude-by-rail shipments to the Golden State, Bakken is just a convenient target. They would just as soon ban oil use in California whether Bakken or another rude, whether it’s shipped by rail, pipeline or tanker.

Indeed, said Bradley Angel, executive director of Greenaction, which helped organize Saturday’s demonstration at Kinder Morgan’s rail yard, “Crude oil should stay in the ground.”

And if demonstrations don’t work, opponents of crude-by-rail will rely on the courts. In fact, a host of activist groups – the Sierra Club, National Resources Defense Council, Asian Pacific Environmental Network and Communities for a Better Environment – filed suit against the Bay Area Air Quality Management District for issuing Kinder Morgan a permit to transfer crude oil from rail cars to trucks.

They are asking that Kinder Morgan’s BAAQMD permit be voided and its crude oil operations be suspended pending a full review under the California Environmental Quality Act. A hearing will be held July 18 in San Francisco Superior Court.


Write a comment
  1. Sean
    Sean 3 June, 2014, 11:33

    It looks like the environmentalists approach to energy is a “none of the above” strategy.

    Reply this comment
  2. maximilian
    maximilian 3 June, 2014, 12:01

    Dealing with extremist environmentalists is like playing chess with pigeons; they kick over all the pieces, crap on the table and strut around like they just won.

    Reply this comment
  3. Bud Led Ted S.
    Bud Led Ted S. 3 June, 2014, 19:59

    People should shut up and let big oil do what they want to.

    Vote Repub in 2016

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Restive Democrats cautioned on budget surplus

A new report by the Legislative Analyst’s Office prepared the ground for fresh political combat in Sacramento over what to

Get prepared for this year’s fire season

July 16, 2012 By Chriss Street California is one of the worst fire zones in the nation.  As we go

DMV workers speak out

JUNE 17, 2010 By ANTHONY PIGNATARO For reasons that shouldn’t surprise anyone, employees of the California Department of Motor Vehicles