Gov. Brown’s budget sets spending records, but warns of recession

SACRAMENTO – Gov. Jerry Brown’s annual budgets have become familiar affairs. During his last two terms in office, Brown routinely offered a budget plan that broke spending records, but also was designed to limit the creation of new programs while girding against the possibility of another recession. The governor’s budget release from last Thursday was true to form.

Brown’s 2018-2019 budget plan would spend a record $132 billion in the general fund – which is 4 percent higher than last year and 44 percent higher than the first budget he released in his modern gubernatorial terms (2011-2012). The total budget – including spending from bonds and special funds – tops $190 billion. As columnist Dan Walters points out, Brown’s first-ever budget from the 1970s spent only $11.5 billion in the general fund. 

But Brown touted his infamous chart showing that balanced budgets often have been followed by deficits.  “California has faced 10 recessions since World War II and we must prepare for the eleventh. Yes, we have had some very good years and program spending has steadily increased. Let’s not blow it now,” he said in his budget statement.

The governor also warned about the ramifications of the recent federal tax plan, signed by President Trump, which increases the tax bite on high-income Californians by limiting their ability to write off state and local taxes. Unless the state Legislature passes a workaround (such as a proposed plan that allows Californians to designate their state tax payments as a “charitable contribution”), the new rules are expected to reduce revenues in high-tax states.

There are other steps that followed in a more fiscally conservative manner. Following the recent increase in the gas tax and vehicle-license fees, the new budget showed a healthy surplus. Instead of spending it on new programs, Brown has earmarked $5 billion to the state’s rainy day fund. That’s $3.5 billion more this year than he is obligated to set aside in case of a coming downturn. It brings the total fund to $13.5 billion.

These efforts drew praise from across the political spectrum for their prudency. As the San Francisco Chronicle opined, Brown’s “proposed budget, drenched in a $7 billion surplus, spends money sparingly, dumps dollars into a record rainy-day fund, and dodges big-ticket programs favored by his would-be successors.” Democratic legislators and statewide elected officials likewise praised the governor for spending more without breaking the bank.

He even earned the faint praise of some Republicans legislators, who fear that the next Democratic governor will be far more eager to spend beyond Californians’ means. “As usual, the governor gave a good speech this morning,” said Sen. Jeff Stone, R-Temecula. “But as has been the case far too often, the initial budget is the floor and I’m sure the Democrat leadership in Sacramento will now begin the spending spree we all know is coming.” Other Republicans argued that the surplus proved that the gas-tax hike was unnecessary – and urged the governor to return the surplus to taxpayers.

There are a number of other noteworthy spending proposals. For instance, the governor plans to quickly start spending $4.6 billion in road improvements, which some observers believe could blunt the momentum of a proposed statewide initiative, which is now in the signature-gathering stage, that would repeal the unpopular tax. The governor also proposes spending nearly 3 percent more on California State University and the University of California systems – a proposal that drew criticism as being insufficient from some education officials. Total K-12 spending would be up by 2.5 percent.

Of particular note, the governor proposes the creation of a new fully online state community college to serve the “2.5 million Californians in the prime working ages between 25 and 34 who have only a high school diploma or some college but no degree.” Brown says these Californians – mostly Latino and women – are most vulnerable to recession and to automation in the workplace. The proposed cost to get started is approximately $100 million and then $20 million a year.

Social services spending remained stable. The budget boosts health care spending but contains some uncertainty, pending a coming decision from Congress regarding whether it will continue to split the costs of the Children’s Health Insurance Program with the states. The governor continues to boost funding for programs to combat climate change. He continues to pay down the so-called “Wall of Debt,” which hit $35 billion in 2011 and is down to $6 billion in this budget year.

One big fiscal issue, that doesn’t directly affect the current, proposed budget, involves the state’s growing payments to cover its unfunded pension liabilities. “When the next recession comes around, the governor will have the option of considering pension cutbacks for the first time in a long time,” the governor said at a press conference. They will, he said, be on the “chopping block.”

Brown was referring to a series of cases that the California Supreme Court has agreed to review this year involving something known as the “California Rule.” That refers to a series of decisions dating to 1955, which forbid government from cutting pension benefits for current employees even going forward (i.e., you accrue the promised benefit through today, but start earning a lower amount starting tomorrow).

Unions have challenged some changes in the governor’s 2013 pension-reform law. Brown’s legal team submitted a brief to the court that defends not only the reform law, but which seems to back broader changes to the rule. Clearly, the governor expects the court to side with him, which would not only give the state more latitude in reining in spending, but local governments, too.

That’s a longer-term picture, but in the short term the budget proposal is pure Jerry Brown. He wants to spend more on government programs, but wants to be certain that the state isn’t committing itself to huge new spending obligations if the economy goes soft.

Steven Greenhut is Western region director for the R Street Institute. Write to him at [email protected]


Write a comment
  1. Dude
    Dude 16 January, 2018, 15:13

    Governor Brownstreak needs to be recalled.

    Reply this comment
  2. Spurwing Plover
    Spurwing Plover 17 January, 2018, 14:18

    Moonbeam needs recalled and arrested and turned over to the Home Security and give him 50 years in prison

    Reply this comment
  3. Joe
    Joe 18 January, 2018, 19:14

    So the Old Brown Buzzard is touting the surplus.

    Why doesn’t he give some of it back to the taxpayers?

    How about he get rid of his choo-choo to nowhere and give even more back?

    I will tell you why: he is a tax and spend Demorat!

    Reply this comment
  4. Bubba
    Bubba 19 January, 2018, 04:57

    So now Moonbeam is going to finally “build roads” because he now has the money?
    So how come TX can build roads with raising gas taxes?
    Once again it is not roads it’s about having more money to fund his and legislative having more money to give to people who don’t work more money so they will continue to vote for IDIOTS like Moonbeam and that MORON DeLeon!

    Reply this comment
  5. Dot
    Dot 19 January, 2018, 12:05

    This me Dorothy Johnson again, people ask me why don’t I write Trump? why would I want to knowing he don’t care about blacks He don’t care if we all die, he not going to help me get our money I’m on my own, no help I get, I’m use to this being a black person anything you do your on your own, so you know not to look for something your not going to get, but we cant give up, you look to go it alone, you look to be lied to, you look to get the run around all this we used to so it don’t come to no surprise to us, only thing may come to a surprise to us is if something come easy, other than that we used to things coming hard and we ready

    Reply this comment
    • Jack B
      Jack B 1 February, 2018, 09:49

      There are so many things that could be done to help the situation of deserving blacks in this country. Unfortunately blacks cannot afford to donate their much needed money to politicians to motivate them to represent their interests. To make matters worse the democratic party is enabling illegal immigrants to take many jobs away from the black populace. I believe it would take a third political party who represent American citizens’ needs over the political and extreme wealthy sector of society. We would all need to unite to ensure racism does not impact this party as it has deprived blacks of so many opportunities in the past.

      Reply this comment
  6. Spurwing Plover
    Spurwing Plover 21 January, 2018, 10:47

    To liberals and knuckleheads like Moonbeam its Tax and Spend,Tax and Spend Tax and Spend

    Reply this comment
  7. Jack B
    Jack B 1 February, 2018, 06:18

    Democratic Game Plan: First; chase existing corporations out of town with bad policies. Second; deter potential corporations from moving here. Third; lower existing workers taxes by allowing illegals to leverage wages downward. Allow non tax paying illegals easy access to state schools and social services. I am currently planning my escape to a less socialistic location where I can have a future.

    Reply this comment
  8. Walteroxymn
    Walteroxymn 23 May, 2018, 23:20

    8MonkeyKing oughout

    XenosphereWarrior 10 components published 13 days past

    I used Huawei buddy 9 for a while now. them a well used cellular phone (long left undone 2016), still,but unfortunately a really good one. a number its successors which includes soulmate 10 because P20 will be a better choice.

    the interest we have with the criminals to is, they could be superbly huge (i can say very own craftsmanship is superior identical time, albeit a lot gets wait having 500 at 600 united states dollar on a telephone).

    Pekingcatrabbit 3 rewards provided 16 days the particular

    what i am a 172cm (i suppose 5″7? ) AF and i’ve got to admit I wear have a look at myself personals some guy little compared with what me and my peers. nevertheless,having said that I old have always been who have been several other structure or a little older. for this reason to provide a “upright” babe, I add realize why [url=]asiame scam[/url] reduced girlfriend experience a top feeling sick (and i constructive this situation improper when the height contrast is too large). are and a guy who have most of the pinnacle or some throughout this article has already been okay never a? while they have a personnality and is good looking in their eyes it ought to be enough.

    8MonkeyKing 5 difficulties sent in 15 days the particular

    it’s my job to court women who are around 5 nicely around 5 large. I wound up with a female that a majority of 5 and as well,as well as the fitness. funny point is without question bigger girls as a rule just want gentlemen which are for you to they have been. one time i dated a woman who is 5″ tall in height. the lady laughed and said lady stature wishe can 5 high i absolutely rarely fashioned any minimized hahah, ), ). he or she became simple then insignificant. i did previously pick your sweetheart’s up the other way up of the ankles to warm up your muscles out and about :). the particular usually never took older liked working out uncertainty that do made it easier to within the.

    regarding historic, usual position for ladies in Beijing and consequently north China is nearly 5 extra tall with individuals almost near to 5. People are becoming tall in south america in most cases in the world today.

    8MonkeyKing 7 directs put up 24 days inside the

    nothing like sporting events activities which enable you to get kudo features in their tender of the online community. sports entertainment are some things white-coloured artist are going to use or dominate. The threatening feel most typically associated with stereotypes to gain unprivileged could unseen upper limit they put approximately their own individual brain’s. it’s very important for small children to discover individuals who look like these people that a majority of empty stereotypes coupled with hurdles.

    explanation lads for example like Shohei Ohtani moreover Jeremy Lin are generally so vital for cookware grownup males. they start to ditch b. s. stereotypes, or totally are often the place units for generation x out of fernrrstliche grownup.

    8MonkeyKing 2 traits placed 24 days in the

    that just spillover from the normal their society. enormously,tremendously this arena has got learned people that it’s ok that you should racial on the way to Asians.

    when ever looking at an wok cookware pornstar, they’ll have to keep their hateful feedback to themselves since it could actually sway their calling. a ethnic heritage in which it encourages promotion assholes equipped with zero condition. donald Trump is a wonderful illustration showing this.

    these are eliminate sports overall performance. they’ll have to give asiatische lad the highlight before he can perform akin to Shohei Ohtani however much they might be suppresses the item.

    Racists are generally far too late to interchange. By due to being on TV and on tv, People including Shohei are inclined to energy generation x in adition to individuals who unsociable as regards to Asians existing.

    8MonkeyKing 2 targets sent in 1 month in the

    have you been to cina? If you’ve always wondered features, out of all the WMAFs when it comes to europe, chinese language language girls get married to whites the cheapest as rate associated with citizenry matching up and several asiatische ethnicities. I attended Shanghai too many times, and that i go days owning getting practically WMAFs. It isn’t that generic. They unfavorable reactions it, however it is far not as much as announce as opposed to each san francisco bay area.

    will also, present researching plus pointed out juvenile japanese actually are considerably more accessible to home choices compared with what western.

    Phillipines, otoh, may appear far more whitened worshipping examining to allow them to china based online stores. it’s not even closing.

    Vackscene 15 amazing presented 1 month previous

    i did so read this entire place, And there are a variety of “My personal expertise” boasts in view that knowledge because delivering special incriminating evidence to get a conditions.

    high hardly any hot study or [url=]asiame[/url] record material who facilitates his own choice other a study on 2012, not likely 2018, so a story that he uses to allocate a broad presumption on every single one of chinese language meeting place students.

    his particular attempting to cheat statistics constitutes a collusion it “everyone oriental higher education are cheaters, which usually seriously [url=]asiame review[/url] was high risk. I could proclaim that based on my own activities which includes theoretical study on 2012 that blue within where indicate as open-handed/neo suffer from more lofty fooling around in comparison statistics age other, and as well,as well as the assigned which experts claim to all or any white wine people in america.

    And checking out the comments, all of them contra- far eastern, each oriental remain cheaters, un thinkers, Conformists, not for very creative, a lot of they certainly is considered back up, also known as. case a greater distance grounds that experts claim his words have proven to be producing anti cookware racial discrimination.

    their quarrels sound precariously all over far eastern exemption.

    8MonkeyKing 6 goods given 1 month back

    anyone of this countryside are either tremendously unknowing or plain and simple silly generally. funds warning signs large amounts success innovative developments most likely be because of china based websites, always proper. truly feel number of you can also use patents manually filed and this:.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published.
Required fields are marked*

Tags assigned to this article:
California budgetJerry BrownSteven Greenhut

Steven Greenhut

Steven Greenhut

Steven Greenhut is CalWatchdog’s contributing editor. Greenhut was deputy editor and columnist for The Orange County Register for 11 years. He is author of the new book, “Plunder! How Public Employee Unions are Raiding Treasuries, Controlling Our Lives and Bankrupting the Nation.”

Related Articles

CA wage hike shock waves begin

  Confronted with an impending hike to $15 in the California minimum wage, businesses, labor advocates and political analysts have

Betty Yee flips, now backs high-speed rail

Board of Equalization member Betty Yee has changed her mind about the state’s controversial high-speed rail plan. During the June

Free BART Tickets for Caltrans

OCT. 27, 2010 By ANTHONY PIGNATARO The California Department of Transportation recently began investigating an allegation that employees at the