Moody's Views of Brown's SOS Speech

FEB. 1, 2011


In a press release dated Jan. 27, Moody’s credit-rating agency began adding unfunded public pension debt to total bonded indebtedness for state and municipal governments across the U.S.  Moody’s press release wasn’t reported until the day of Gov. Brown’s State of the State speech on Jan. 31.

Moody’s analyst Ted Hampton, is quoted in the press release:

“Pension underfunding has been driven by weaker-than-expected investment results, previous benefit enhancements and, in some states, failure to pay the annual required contribution to the pension fund. Demographic factors — including the retirement of Baby Boom-generation state employees and beneficiaries’ increasing life expectancy — are also adding to liabilities.”

Moody’s now shows California with a combined debt of about $137 billion ($136.9 billion), well under the half trillion that Stanford University estimated last year. But this is a step in the right direction of risk disclosure to bond investors and taxpayers.

The California State Treasurer’s Web site shows total state and local debt issued of about $89 billion ($88.773 billion) as of Dec. 31, 2010.

Moody’s apparently added $48 billion in unfunded debt to the state’s official debt figure. However, it is unclear if the $137 billion in combined debt for California includes only the unfunded debt for pension obligations of state workers or of all state and municipal workers in cities and counties as well.

The report, “Combining Debt and Pension Liabilities of U.S. States Enhances Comparability,” is available at for registered users or for $550.

CalPERS, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, recently increased its pension contribution formula for every level of government given that it is underfunded.

California’s proposed general fund budget is about $86 billion for the upcoming 2011-12 fiscal year. Gov. Jerry Brown has proposed a mix of spending cuts and tax increases totaling $25 billion over the next 18 months, or $16.6 billion for the upcoming fiscal year.

How to understand California’s debt

By analogy, California’s debt picture can be likened to a family household living on $86,000 per year but with debts of $89,000, after running up four straight years of about $20,000 of accrued debts on a low interest credit card (bonds).

In the past, this fictional household has been making its mortgage payments from stock dividends (bubble money), which stopped after the national financial panic of 2008.

The head of the household estimates an added $25,000 debt over the next 18 months (or $16,600 next year) if his plan of belt tightening and added gifts from relatives doesn’t work out. But that would do nothing to retire the accrued existing debt of about $89,000.

Now his bank tells him his credit rating has been downgraded because the bank is considering that the balloon on his mortgage will be coming due of $48,000.

So reducing the $16,600 debt for next year would be one step forward and three steps backwards. Even if the $16,600 debt for next year can be plugged, total household debt will swell to $137,000. If the $16,600 debt cannot be plugged the total family debt would rise to $153,600.

Stock dividends have resumed in 2009 and 2010 due to stimulus policies of the Federal Reserve.  But as of February, 2011, the Standard and Poor’s and Nasdaq indices have risen higher than the 200-day moving average in the stock market than at any time in the last 10 years (see chart at link below). Thus, some are forecasting a market correction bigger than in 2007 with an accompanying recession worse than the last one.

The above is a depiction of the debt situation for California as of the Governor’s 2011 State of the State speech.

Learning of the above debt analogy for California, do you think that California can dig itself out of a hole?

California State Treasurer Bill Lockyer has been stating publicly that media rumors of the state becoming insolvent are overblown.  But just before Gov. Jerry Brown’s State of the State speech Moody’s released its new credit rating practice.  What rating do you think Moody’s gave Brown’s speech for full disclosure of what the state is facing (A, B, C, D, F)?


Write a comment
  1. Susan
    Susan 1 February, 2011, 18:39

    For all that Gov. Brown neglected to address, his State of the State deserves a “D” (for Depression).

    Reply this comment
  2. David Mark
    David Mark 2 February, 2011, 15:37

    California will not dig itself out of this hole – not with the public employee unions, who are the main cause of the problems, being in even firmer control of state government with their good friend Jerry Brown now in the top office.

    Instead, while Brown, the legislature and the unions continue to dig furiously, a sea of debt will wash across the state, filling the hole and flushing out all that hunker down in the hole. It will be sort of like your mother washing your mouth out with soap – a cleansing flush, but bitter tasting for awhile.

    Unemployment may go to 15-20 percent, schools will be closed and many government services shut down. Voters will wonder what went wrong, but in due time the plunging poll numbers of Brown and the spendthrift legislators will indicate that voters are learning what generations before have learned…we can’t spend our way to prosperity, we have to produce our way there.

    Reply this comment
  3. Rex ther Wonder Dog!
    Rex ther Wonder Dog! 3 February, 2011, 09:30

    Stick a fork in CA, we’re done.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Bill outlaws drug label fine print

JUNE 15, 2010 By KATY GRIMES Sen. Ellen Corbett, D-San Leandro, announced new legislation today that refutes recent decisions made

California’s Debt Bondage

APRIL 20, 2010 By JOHN SEILER In my previous article on finding ways to suspend some state spending for a

Video: More choices means a better education’s Brian Calle talks to Superintendent Liz Fagen about how a robust program to offer parents and students choices about