Bay Area Newspaper Group goes trolling for outrage

March 20, 2013

By Chris Reed

H1B-visa-holders-stay-usaThe publications that are part of the Bay Area Newspaper Group are giving big play to a story that suggests broad sexism in the granting of H-1B visas:

“As Congress negotiates its biggest immigration overhaul in decades, new numbers obtained by this newspaper reveal a stunning imbalance in a program that admits highly skilled immigrants to the United States, often for Silicon Valley jobs: More than 70 percent of those special visa holders who entered the country in 2011 were men.

“The long-overlooked disparity is beginning to attract attention on Capitol Hill, where activists demanded Monday that the federal government take a closer look at whether U.S. visa policy discriminates against women.”

Incredibly, reporter Matt O’Brien never makes the explicit point that this is happening because men are far more likely to have the sort of engineering and specialized science degrees for which the H-1B program is designed. There is no “stunning imbalance” once this context is understood. Instead, O’Brien offers up this misleading factoid to provide context: In the U.S., “women hold 51.5 percent of professional and management jobs, according to annual visa statistics and the Department of Labor.”

Trolling for outrage instead of supplying context and nuance

trollThis is trolling for outrage, not honest reporting. The numbers showing male dominance in fields that win people H-1B visas are easily available.

That is an interesting story about persistent and, to some, troubling patterns of gender interest in certain professions — and I’m not talking about the Larry Summers controversy from 2005. A 2009 Cornell study made many juicy, arresting points:

“Women tend to choose non-math-intensive fields for their careers — not because they lack mathematical ability, but because they want flexibility to raise children or prefer less math-intensive fields of science, reports a new Cornell study.

“‘A major reason explaining why women are underrepresented not only in math-intensive fields but also in senior leadership positions in most fields is that many women choose to have children, and the timing of child rearing coincides with the most demanding periods of their career, such as trying to get tenure or working exorbitant hours to get promoted,’ said lead author Stephen J. Ceci, professor of human development at Cornell.

“Women with advanced math abilities choose non-math fields more often than men with similar abilities, he added.

“Women also tend to drop out of scientific fields — especially math and physical sciences — at higher rates than do men, particularly as they advance, because of their need for greater flexibility and the demands of parenting and caregiving, said co-author Wendy M. Williams, Cornell professor of human development.

“‘These are choices that all women, but almost no men, are forced to make,’ she said.

“The study, published in the March issue of the American Psychological Association’s Psychological Bulletin (135:2), is an integrative analysis of 35 years of research on sex differences in math. Ceci and his Cornell co-authors reviewed more than 400 articles and book chapters to better understand why women are underrepresented in such math-intensive science careers as computer science, physics, technology, engineering, chemistry and higher mathematics.”

This is genuinely interesting, as opposed to puerile and provocative.

But instead of anything remotely reflecting the nuance and insight of the Cornell study, the Bay Area Newspaper Group would rather hype a slanted story that pretends the granting of H-1B visas is driven by bias against women. Great, just great. WTG.



Write a comment
  1. jimmydeeoc
    jimmydeeoc 20 March, 2013, 09:01

    Then there’s the “gender pay gap”……

    If there remains a problem…’s infinitesimally small compared to even 20 – and especially 40 or 50 years ago.

    But you’ll never hear that on the MSM either. Or President Barack “The Balkanizer” Obama. Who trots out the nonsensical “average pay comparison” at every opportunity.

    Reply this comment
  2. The problem is men aren't sharing
    The problem is men aren't sharing 20 March, 2013, 09:26

    “California’s Women Not Sharing Equally in Recovery, Recent Budget Cuts Threaten Opportunity” March 19, 2013 press release from California Budget Project, in partnership with the Women’s Foundation of California

    Reply this comment
  3. The problem is men aren't sharing
    The problem is men aren't sharing 20 March, 2013, 11:22

    Here’s another one just out!

    “Education Data Show Gender Gap in Career Preparation” by National Coalition of Women and Girls in Education , National Coalition on Women, Jobs and Job Training (March 2013)

    It is truly miserable to be a woman or girl in America today.

    Reply this comment
  4. James
    James 12 April, 2013, 06:44

    Actually women can face subtle bias early on:

    Why are the so many visa given to communist..communist China and not communist Vietnam?

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Minimum-wage law’s opt-out provision unlikely to be used by governor

A California governor is asked to sign historic, far-reaching legislation that could have unknown consequences — and tells the Legislature

This could be fun

Oct. 28, 2012 By John Seiler It looks like Proposition 30 is going down to defeat. So what I’m looking

Think tank explained CA’s affordable housing debacles long ago

A weekend story about the gross failure of affordable housing policies in San Francisco contained plenty of public frustration and