Only hope for further state bullet train $$ is gone

May 1, 2013

By Chris Reed

BrowndoggleLogoWe’ve seen some very good reporting about the bullet-train fiasco from around the state. The two best recent examples are stories outlining the chicanery in the bidding process for the contractor for the first segment and describing how the California High-Speed Rail Authority has lost support from key early advocates of the project.

But what’s needed is for someone to focus like a laser on the funding prospects for the second segment of the bullet train before we spend billions on the first. A U.S. Government Accountability Office report in December said that $39 billion more in federal funding would be needed for the project to complete its San Francisco to Los Angeles route, with $20 billion specifically to complete the first segment.

However, as I noted in today’s U-T San Diego editorial, hopes for such federal largesse are now pretty much dead:

“The congressional directive to the FAA to end air traffic controller furloughs strongly suggests the demise of the president’s contention that the March 1 budget sequestration requires proportional cuts across a vast range of departments instead of smart, focused cuts that establish and reflect national priorities. …

“This in turn suggests that we have just begun an era of relative frugality in Washington, D.C., after years of the federal government spending 40 percent more than it took in.

“And what does that mean specifically for California? That the state bullet-train project looks more futile than ever. Discretionary domestic spending is going to pretty much disappear in the post-sequester era. What does a December Government Accountability Office report on the bullet train say will be needed to build the second segment of California’s project after the $13.4 billion in committed state and federal funding is used up? Billions of dollars in federal funding –- i.e., discretionary domestic spending.”

Media ignore link between sequester fight, bullet train

Yet nobody in the California media besides the U-T has made the link between last month’s federal budget showdown and the state bullet train project. If they did, then this would be the conclusion that everyone but rail cultists would come to:

“The California High-Speed Rail Authority has attracted no private investors because such investors want revenue guarantees the state cannot legally offer. The federal government -– or some unlikely foreign benefactor –- is the authority’s only hope for funding to build its grand project. If the federal option is gone, should we really spend billions on an instant white elephant in the Central Valley?

“The answer is, no, of course not. But as long as Gov. Jerry Brown is in denial on bullet-train realities –- starting with but not limited to the death of the federal funding option -– here comes a boondoggle for the ages.”

John and Ken’s preferred shorthand for the project — the Browndoggle — should be what we call the white elephant that’s soon to rise in the Central Valley. Our alleged savant governor is the opposite of a genius on this topic. We’ll soon see a multibillion-dollar monument to his obliviousness.


Write a comment
  1. jimmydeeoc
    jimmydeeoc 1 May, 2013, 11:18

    Indeed — Many years from now, the Merced to Fresno segment will sit unused, baking in the San Joaquin Valley sun, while future explorers scratch their heads and look upon it as we do the megaliths of Easter Island.

    As to its usefulness, I would draw comparison to the Governor William J Le Petomane Thruway, except the Thruway actually served a purpose (it slowed down Taggart and his gang…..LOL)

    Reply this comment
  2. BigFire
    BigFire 1 May, 2013, 11:22

    No worry, the right people (Richard Blum) will get paid. Who care if it goes nowhere?

    Reply this comment
  3. stolson
    stolson 1 May, 2013, 11:57

    So, Blum gets rich yet Feinstein’s investors (contributors) are not going to put any private money into this train fiasco. Is Brown just their patsy?

    Reply this comment
  4. C. Wyatt Hertz
    C. Wyatt Hertz 1 May, 2013, 11:58

    I’ve been referring to the browndoggle as the “Moonbeam Zephyr.” That seems an appropriate name for the project.

    Reply this comment
  5. tomcatdad
    tomcatdad 1 May, 2013, 13:32

    In San Gabriel Canyon there is a bridge built in the 30’s that literally goes nowhere. I was a make work project that was poorly planned, just funded to put men to work.

    Reply this comment
  6. us citizen
    us citizen 1 May, 2013, 14:21

    Lets hope the wicked witch of the west is dead.

    Reply this comment
  7. George Chrisman
    George Chrisman 1 May, 2013, 15:51

    The train to nowhere. . .

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Mish: Budget avoids structural reform

From Mish’s Global Economic Trend Analysis blog (his posts are crossposted with permission): Tonight, with much fanfare, Schwarzenegger released his

I Can't Afford a Tax Increase

John Seiler: I usually make coffee at home. But this morning, I got a Starbucks. Fishing around in my wallet

9th Circuit protects conceal-carry gun rights

What’s it with California politicians and their obsession with grabbing our guns? They are guarded by heavily armed state troopers,