NRDC claim of ‘no government-made drought’ doesn’t hold water

NRDC claim of ‘no government-made drought’ doesn’t hold water

Water moves in one direction, memory in another for the National Resources Defense Council. The NRDC seems to be suffering from a case of voluntary amnesia in its running dispute with the Wall Street Journal over whether California is currently suffering from an historic dry spell or a “government-made drought.”

Delta smelt - wikimedia

Delta smelt

A Journal article, “California’s Fish Fry,” blamed the government for the drought. Peter Lehner, the NRDC’s executive director, replied that it wasn’t the government’s fault. (See excerpts from the his letter below.)

If you don’t remember who the NRDC is, they are the environmental organization that brought about the deep reductions in water deliveries in California from 2007 to 2010 due to their lawsuit to protect the Delta Smelt fish from alleged extinction.  The federal judge in the case ruled the scientific basis of the lawsuit was bogus and the reductions in water deliveries did not protect the fish from extinction.

Government-created drought 

Lehner blames the worst dry spell in California in 119-years for the six-month drought from January through June of this year. But 1894 was not the driest year in the last 119 years in California, as indicated here. California has experienced decades of dry water years without having to reduce water deliveries to farmers.

Lehner is half right that farm water reductions are not universal.  But contrary to Lehner, these reductions are targeted at larger corporate-owned farms served by the Central Valley Project.

The Inspector General for the U.S. Department of Interior, in a 2013 audit report titled “Central Valley Project California Repayment and Payoff,” found that farmers’ repayments to pay off the $1.3 billion in bonds for the CVP are lagging behind schedule because of water reductions to large farms.

According to the IG, over the three-year period from 2008 to 2010, actual water deliveries to large CVP farm water contractors were only 41 percent of their allocation, causing a $45 million shortfall in CVP bond repayments. The IG estimated that, by 2030, one large farm operator would have to double its bond payments because of less water being supplied.

An April 9, 2013 Board Letter of the Tuolumne Utilities District explains why the New Melones Dam that releases water for California Central Valley farms sits half empty except in very wet years. It blames not drought, but Congress’ enactment of the Endangered Species Act of 1972 and other legislation.

Smelt a gauge of how much government and economy we have

Moreover, the Delta estuary isn’t the only habitat for the smelt, as Lehner infers. It was revealed in the NRDC’s court case that schools of smelt fish are found throughout the Sacramento Delta.

The NRDC previously alleged that the smelt were found only in the brackish water zone in the San Francisco Bay, where fresh water and salt water mix.  In wet years, the boundary line of this pool of brackish water, called the X-2 Zone, is pushed westerly in the San Francisco Bay by fresh water flooding the Delta.  In dry years, the brackish water zone line is pushed easterly by saltwater intrusion from the ocean.

But the brackish water zone is also determined by how much water is pumped out of the Delta for water imports to farmers and cities.  The X-2 line is set each year by government in order to balance the need to protect fish and provide water to agriculture and urban areas.

In other words, the smelt is used as a gauge of how much government and how much of a water economy California has each year.  If the X-2 Zone boundary line is pushed westerly, California has a lot of fish but diminished farming.  If the X-2 line is pushed easterly, supposedly we have fewer fish but more agricultural production.

In reality, the Delta Smelt are found throughout the Delta and not just in the X-2 Zone, as the NRDC has contended.

Water war

The water war over where the X-2 line is set means a struggle for 300,000 to 760,000 acre-feet of Delta water, depending on whether it is a dry or wet year.  That is enough water minimally to supply the City of San Diego, or at maximum the City of Los Angeles, for one year.  The smelt represent a water gauge of how much government and how much economy we have.

If we dedicate enough Delta Bay water to supply the entire City of Los Angeles for one year to protect a few Delta smelt that also exist outside the X-2 zone, then urban water rates will have to rise to offset fixed costs. And farmers, cities and even urban wildlife will suffer. But the entire food chain of jobs that feeds off natural resources bureaucracies will thrive.

All “droughts” in California are man-made. We no longer live in a natural environment controlled by the changes in the “climate.” We live in an urban world dependent on huge water hydraulic systems.

California only has a thin six-month supply of water storage, due to the lack of building new reservoirs in the past 40 years, in part due to opposition by the NRDC.  The problem is rainfall capture and storage, not normal natural drought conditions.  The NRDC claim that there is no “government created drought” doesn’t hold water.


Letter to the Wall Street Journal by Peter Lehner:

Your editorial “California’s Fish Fry” (July 15) falsely scapegoats California’s environmental protections without mentioning the real cause. The state’s record dry conditions. January to June 2013 has been the driest period in the last 119 years in California, according to the National Climatic Data Center. Unless President Obama and Gov. Jerry Brown control the weather, this is decidedly not a “government-made drought.”

While corporate agribusiness in the Westlands Water District is receiving reduced water supplies due to drought, these cutbacks aren’t universal. Other Central Valley farms are receiving full water allotments this year. And Southern California’s investments in improved water efficiency mean many large cities are well prepared for a dry year.

Delta smelt is nothing more than a red herring in your editorial. Protections for these endangered native fish actually serve to safeguard thousands of fishing and farming jobs and drinking water in California by maintaining water quality in the estuary. Your proposal to eliminate scientifically sound water conservation measures in the Bay Area/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is a false choice between the environment and jobs.

Peter Lehner

Executive Director

Natural Resources Defense Council



Write a comment
  1. The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit
    The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit 25 July, 2013, 15:20

    The NRDC is 100% right– but of course tea party doomers do not like real science… they?

    Reply this comment
  2. admin
    admin 25 July, 2013, 15:23

    Ted: How can the NDRC be 100% right if the court case, and the judge, found the Delta smelt throughout the Delta? That it was not going extinct?

    — John Seiler

    Reply this comment
  3. The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit
    The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit 25 July, 2013, 15:57

    Smelt at the time of the first, second and third fresh water event were recorded at the lowest levels in recorded history….maybe that has something to do with it?

    Reply this comment
  4. The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit
    The Ted Steele Conceptual Abstraction Unit 25 July, 2013, 15:58

    …although they did thereafter rise….

    Reply this comment
  5. Ted Steele, The Decider
    Ted Steele, The Decider 26 July, 2013, 06:51

    To quote Monty Python…..”it got better…”

    On 4 fresh water events all time record low smelt counts occurred—- you do the math John.

    Reply this comment
  6. Bill - San Jose
    Bill - San Jose 26 July, 2013, 08:25

    All “droughts” in California are man-made.

    Truer words have never been spoken.

    Next topic please on why we haven’t built a new reservoir since 1999.

    30 behind schedule.

    Reply this comment
  7. Paul Taylor Examiner
    Paul Taylor Examiner 27 July, 2013, 08:32

    Great reveal of the eco-groups’ parade of “green lies” that the lazy-left media proliferates largely unchallenged.
    Green-obsessed bureaucrats and militant eco-groups have become an “axis of antagonism” that we can no longer afford.
    Like the new look Cal Watchdog !

    Reply this comment
  8. Itachee
    Itachee 28 July, 2013, 08:28

    Having worked on delta and delta smelt issues since 1989, and having coauthored biological assessments on delta smelt and other species, I can tell you with certainty that there is NO relationship between delta smelt abundance and delta outflow which controls the location of X2

    Reply this comment
  9. carlene hazan
    carlene hazan 14 February, 2014, 17:37

    You know nothing about me as I know nothing about you…except that I am “left” and you are “right” and rude and subscribe to fallacy ad hominen…
    I can make other comments about you…
    but I am not lazy…have always worked…and are lazy in your attacks resorting to comments that mean nothing and know nothing..

    Reply this comment
  10. carlene hazan
    carlene hazan 14 February, 2014, 17:45

    Paul Taylor…You know nothing about me as I know nothing about you…except that I am “left” and you are “right” and rude and subscribe to fallacy ad hominen…
    I can make other comments about you…
    but I am not lazy…have always worked…and you are lazy in your attacks resorting to comments and name-calling that mean nothing and know nothing….
    I must say you are very good at buzz words though

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Perez requests recount in controller’s race

California’s never-ending race for state controller entered a new phase Monday, as election officials are expected to begin recounting ballots

Video: Is Common Core a common floor?’s Brian Calle talks to Colorado superintendent Liz Fagen about how standards are crucial for long-term success in education.

Rising electric rates spark CA fight

A new plan under consideration by the state Public Utilities Commission has Californians up in arms over the prospect of higher