Vergara ruling: Silicon Valley titan KOs teachers unions

Vergara ruling: Silicon Valley titan KOs teachers unions

In 16 pages, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf M. Treu dealt California’s teachers unions an unprecedented defeat. Using unsparing, uncompromising language, Judge Treu ruled that job protections passed at these unions’ behest violated the state Constitution by denying equal educational opportunity to students including the plaintiffs in the case, Vergara vs. California.

In one sense, the astonishing result is a reminder of how powerful the legal doctrine of equal protection has become. Treu did not agree as a matter of law that “every child, everywhere, deserves great teachers.” But he did conclude that union job protections for teachers, including bad teachers, had fostered inequalities of opportunity so grave as to shock the conscience.

brownboeExplicitly drawing a comparison between Vergara and Brown vs. Board of Education, Treu ensured that similar litigation will spring up around America. It is a surprising reversal of roles for political partisans, many of whom associate bold, consequential readings of equal protection clauses with traditionally liberal causes, plaintiffs, and judges. (Indeed, lead counsel in the plaintiff’s case was Theodore Boutrous Jr., who successfully litigated the challenge to Proposition 8, which banned same-sex marriage in California.)

Silicon Valley muscle

But in another sense, the Vergara case reveals how the power of Silicon Valley now reaches far beyond technology, politics or even the economy as a whole. The priorities and perspectives of some of Silicon Valley’s most socially involved figures now shape the most basic legal concepts undergirding American life.

silicon-valleyDavid Welch, a longtime fiber-optic communications entrepreneur, founded and chairs the board of Students Matter, the group responsible for organizing and pursuing the Vergara case. A board member of the National Resources Defense Council, he does not fit the stereotype of the movement conservatives often presumed to spearhead legal action against teachers unions. Yet at the same time, neither does Welch’s profile match the prevailing view of Silicon Valley’s youthful, web-centric titans. Rather than pursuing public policy outcomes in realms like surveillance or gay marriage, Welch sought structural change in K-12 education — without relying on the internet, like Mountain View heavyweight Khan Academy.

Welch’s efforts underscore how Silicon Valley can no longer be presented as “disrupting” settled institutional practices in a one-dimensional way. Although the buzzword of disruption has come in for its share of scorn, critics will feel pressured by events to acknowledge that the change wrought by Welch scrambles typical partisan battle lines, rather than reinforcing Randians-versus-the-masses cliches.

Divided Democrats

Democrats, for instance, are now as deeply divided on education reform as they have been since the civil rights era. In California, the differences are striking. Tom Torlakson, the incumbent superintendent of public instruction, benefited from $2.5 million in independent expenditures by the California Teachers Association this primary election. LAUSD Superintendent John Deasy, by contrast, penned an op-ed for the Los Angeles Times touting his “responsibility and privilege” to make good on Judge Treu’s ruling.

Democrats nationwide who remain loyal to teachers unions will likely face an opportunity to change their political calculus. Education reformers are looking to pattern lawsuits off of the Vergara case in Connecticut, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon and elsewhere, according to Politico — along with a “relentless public relations campaign, backed by millions of dollars from reform-minded philanthropists, to bring moms, dads and voters of both parties to their side.”

In that fashion, it’s clear that even Silicon Valley’s most powerful figures can’t single-handedly change America’s legal landscape. Although Welch has proven instrumental in achieving an early victory essential for a broader national attack on teacher unions’ tenure regimes, that kind of reform movement requires more than money or influential figureheads. Like most large-scale political efforts, without an energized, broad base of ordinary Americans, it will fizzle out and fail.


Write a comment
  1. Bud Led Ted S.
    Bud Led Ted S. 10 June, 2014, 22:36

    This case will have a VERY short shelf life———Zzzzz

    Enjoy while u have it doomers!!

    Reply this comment
  2. SkippingDog
    SkippingDog 11 June, 2014, 09:24

    That’s why we have appellate courts.

    Reply this comment
  3. Hondo
    Hondo 11 June, 2014, 09:31

    Yoooohoooo. Judge Treu was appointed in West Covina, my hometown, by Wilson. I agree that some socialist dem judge will defecate on the students by siding with the teachers and over turn this great ruling.
    As for doomers, it is the occupy enviornmentalists who are saying that this global warming is about to set the earth on fire. This is after the coldest winter in recorded history in North America.
    But I agree with Bud. The 9th circuit will dump on this as they dump on the children too.

    Reply this comment
  4. Seanmorhamcpoly
    Seanmorhamcpoly 11 June, 2014, 10:31

    Anyone who believes two years is adequate experience for tenure is either too ignorant, or does not care about educating the next generation.

    Reply this comment
    • Bud Led Ted S.
      Bud Led Ted S. 12 June, 2014, 17:51

      Sean— Not only does the crew out here NOT know–

      They do NOT care! It’s a tea baggy reactive dull normal crowd here.

      Reply this comment
  5. Bill Gore
    Bill Gore 11 June, 2014, 15:51

    This is a 9 on the Richter scale, shaking the ivory towers of kalifornia uniondom to their foundations.

    Of course 2 years to tenure is ABSURD.

    If it is upheld, that will be the ‘coup de grace’ to all public employee union entitlements, think of a towering tsunami smashing into said ivory towers.

    Look for panicking public employee unions to run to their sock puppets in the legislature even before the appeals begin,seeking some kind of ironclad/bulletproof legislative ‘relief’. After all, these people are utterly focused on job security, if not their ‘jobs’.

    Reply this comment
  6. Seanmorhamcpoly
    Seanmorhamcpoly 11 June, 2014, 20:16

    It is all about the kids, not! $+!k them.

    Reply this comment
  7. Bud Led Ted S.
    Bud Led Ted S. 12 June, 2014, 17:49


    The LA County Superior Court!
    The highest court in the land….LMAO

    Case reversed in 3, 2, 1…….

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

School Cuts Would Mostly Target Fluff

DEC. 17, 2010 By WAYNE LUSVARDI At a state budget forum held on Dec. 14 in Los Angeles, Gov.-elect Jerry Brown and

Brown unveils governors’ energy accord

Gov. Jerry Brown announced on Tuesday that California joined a bipartisan, multi-state coalition promoting energy efficiency. Brown has long pursued

Bill Would Mandate Union Teacher Jobs

JUNE 2, 2011 By, KATY GRIMES An education bill is being used to increase the power of teachers’ unions. AB 515