Gut and amend time

Gut and amend time

sausages - wikimedia“Laws are like sausages. You should never see them made,” is a variant on a saying by Otto von Bismarck. The old Prussian has been dead 116 years, but if he came back he certainly would recognize the California Legislature’s “gut and amend” process, which even sounds like making sausages. Except the “guts” belong to the people of California.

“Gut and amend” is going on right now. As this last week of the 2014 Legislature winds down, it means an existing bill is “gutted” of its entire wording, then “amended” to put in new content. Then it’s voted on — usually with no legislators, or only a few, having read it in its entirety. Most legislators have no idea what the “amendments” are, but just vote with their party leadership.

Given Democratic dominance, that means the Democratic leadership writes the amendments.

This happens in part because bills must be introduced by February, but then can be amended until the end of the session in August.

But the main reason is that the Legislature just sits too long. A part-time legislature, sitting for half a year once every two years as in Texas, would have plenty of time to consider real state business, then go home to see what’s really going on in their districts. Legislators also would have to get real jobs those 18 months not “serving” the people, so they would know what the rest of us suffer when taxes and regulations slam businesses or local government budgets.


Write a comment
  1. Kathy Hamilton
    Kathy Hamilton 28 August, 2014, 15:52

    The gut-and-amend process is an injustice to the people and the process that is supposed to be followed. The contents of those bills do not go to the proper committees to be fully vetted, the process is just blatant politics and should be banned.

    Reply this comment
  2. ECK
    ECK 29 August, 2014, 17:57

    A shameful banana republic practice that does not belong in a free nation. Yet no one seems to give a d**m.

    Reply this comment
  3. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 29 August, 2014, 20:17


    You’re ruled…accept your fate!

    Be though not afraid.

    These are your trusted representatives.

    They feel for you-

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Tags assigned to this article:
Gut and AmendJohn SeilerlegislatureBismarck

Related Articles

CA ban on racial preferences upheld

April 3, 2012 Katy Grimes: Proposition 209, a constitutional amendment that prohibits the government from granting educational or employment preferences

EdSource look at superintendent turnover ignores union elephant

Dec. 8, 2012 By Chris Reed There are none so blind as those who will not see. EdSource does a

Wells Fargo faces massive new scandal

Wells Fargo’s hopes that a $142 million June settlement of a class-action lawsuit over its agents creating up to 2.1