Dems make Peters-DeMaio race a referendum on Tea Party

Dems make Peters-DeMaio race a referendum on Tea Party

tea.cdmThe nationally watched race for a swing seat between Rep. Scott Peters, D-San Diego, and former San Diego Councilman Carl DeMaio is currently in a roiled state because of lewd allegations made against DeMaio by a former staffer whom DeMaio says is suspected in the burglary of his campaign headquarters. But at least on the TV airwaves, the themes of Peters, the national Democratic Party and super PACs endorsing the one-term incumbent have never varied: DeMaio is a threat to America because of what they call his “Tea Party values” — which they say make DeMaio want to cut student loans, imperil pension benefits for widows of dead cops, and prevent government from helping you deal with life’s vicissitudes, etc.

Obviously, there’s been focus-group testing galore that leads Dems to think this theme is powerful and resonates with independent voters. And so the decision to make the race a referendum on the Tea Party.

But the 52nd congressional district isn’t West Los Angeles or Marin County. It covers mostly affluent coastal and northern San Diego and went decisively for Mitt Romney, a part-time resident of the district, in 2012.

And given the fact that DeMaio is gay, the usual tactic of depicting tea party members as social conservative extremists doesn’t work so well — the “war on women” shtick, etc. Here’s an example of this framing, a Washington Post story headlined “Social conservatives are mobilizing in France, leading to talk of a tea party.”

It’s quite possible that Democrats and some in the media actually don’t realize that the Tea Party is fundamentally libertarian — devoted to liberty and small government — and is not a conspiracy-mongering birther front. When the only people you listen to are those on MSNBC and Daily Kos, and Paul Krugman, you’re inclined to see all Republicans as contemptible haters.

Tea Party no fan of GOP establishment’s views on immigration

Yet the more sophisticated observers get that the Tea Party really is at odds with the modern GOP establishment — not just on its habit of giving in and accepting the big-spending federal status quo but on immigration. This isn’t just an anecdote-based claim. This info is from Thomas Edsall, the veteran journalist who for decades has actually tried to bring political science research into political journalism:

Parker and Barreto conducted surveys to see if Tea Party conservatives differ from non-Tea Party conservatives. … the two kinds of conservatives diverge significantly on key issues: immigration, civil liberties and in how they see President Obama.

The surveys showed that 50 percent of Tea Party-identifying members opposed the DREAM Act vs. 30 percent of non-Tea Party conservatives; 66 percent of Tea Party-identifying members opposed the path to citizenship for illegal immigrants vs. 46 percent of non-Tea Party conservatives; and that 58 percent of Tea Party-identifying members correlated more immigration with more crime vs. 49 percent of non-Tea Party conservatives.

But other surveys show Tea Party members more likely than standard conservatives to reject limits on abortion and gay marriage — the social issue litmus tests. They’re not bomb-throwers on social wedge issues.

Tea Party members I’ve talked with often say they back higher immigration — but with a Canada-style approach valuing applicants with needed job skills, not a system in which immigrants essentially self-select.

DeMaio is in the real-border-security-first camp.

But he’s not making it a key theme in this very interesting congressional race.

Here’s a Breitbart account of how DeMaio is responding to the Tea Party narrative: by ridiculing it.


Write a comment
  1. Queeg
    Queeg 15 October, 2014, 10:50

    Tea Party values?

    Are you insane?

    Reply this comment
  2. Chris Reed
    Chris Reed Author 15 October, 2014, 10:52


    Reply this comment
  3. SkippingDog
    SkippingDog 15 October, 2014, 12:01

    Sorry Chris, but the Tea Party movement is not fundamentally libertarian, unless Lew Rockwell is your model. The Tea Party is nothing more than a contemporary repackaging of the fringe ideas of the John Birch Society.

    Reply this comment
  4. LetitCollapse
    LetitCollapse 15 October, 2014, 16:38

    Most of the Tea Party candidates, if elected, sell out to the 1% and to mainstream Republican party within their 1st year in office. You question me? Examine what 15 of the Congressional Tea Party candidates who ran on anti-Wall Street platforms and populist reform agendas did after being elected in 2010. Sold out to the Too Big To Fail banksters!

    None of them are worthy of your trust. None of them. They all lie. Don’t contribute any of your money to ANY politician and think 3 times before you give ANY of them your vote.

    Even Rand Paul is turning mainstream Republican. Don’t get suckered by any of them.

    Until 3rd party candidates have a snowball’s chance in hell of getting elected – this nation’s political system is doomed.

    Reply this comment
  5. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 15 October, 2014, 22:06


    This is a tough crowd to please…DeMaio is looking for a feedbag job like Mc Clintock, Garamendi, Lundgren…..once in DC ye no know ye!

    So typical… get along….when is the next junket?

    Reply this comment
    • T Mind of Ted Your God
      T Mind of Ted Your God 17 October, 2014, 19:16


      Do you think DiMiao wore one of those Ben Franklin ™ outfits at any tea baggy rally? If so the image could be quite fun out here? Just a thought.

      Hey Chris– While I am at this, do you dress up like one of the founders at these rally things?

      My thought is this—- if you could build a time machine and take alot of these teabaggers and republibaggers and fellow travelers back to Boston in say about 1775, most of them would be straight up loyalists. Waaaaaay to afraid closed minded to put it all on the line in defiance of the King ™.

      Reply this comment
  6. T Mind of Ted Your God
    T Mind of Ted Your God 17 October, 2014, 19:22

    Chris– I have NEVER understood the marketing PR side of the tea party? The party ideas at the start drew in democrats, independants and other unlikely folks. Then the strange costume thing and all of the tv coverage which of course we all expected and viola– they look nuts!!!!!

    Why can’t Repubs rise up and straighten out AT LEAST the horrible image of this stuff?? It just scares off normal folks.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

"IOU" A Tax Payment

Katy Grimes: Should the state of California accept its own IOU’s as tax and fee payments? AB 1506 authored by

Oregon claim of assisted suicide safeguards has critics

A key argument spurring Gov. Jerry Brown’s recent decision to sign a bill allowing physician-assisted suicide in California, and the

Just dissolve Bell

John Seiler: There’s a political and legal fight now over who or what will control the city of Bell, whose