Jerry Brown about to annihilate UC president on tuition hikes

Jerry Brown about to annihilate UC president on tuition hikes

Janet-NapolitanoAficionados of California politics are going to be in for a fun exercise over the next month or two. Gov. Jerry Brown is absolutely going to annihilate UC President Janet Napolitano in their fight over her proposal to get UC regents to commit to five years of annual 5 percent tuition increases unless the university system gets guarantees of state funding hikes.

The latest Bee headline suggests Napolitano may have the upper hand in initial skirmishes. But the former Arizona governor is doomed.

Napolitano doesn’t understand how California politics works. She doesn’t remotely get that the UC president’s office isn’t a political power center. Her job is more for people with a courtier streak than a my-way-or-the-highway streak.

Beyond that, Napolitano is a Golden State newcomer who after 14 months doesn’t have remotely enough political capital to take on a California institution just re-elected in a landslide. She also has no idea how toxic tuition hikes are to the state’s dominant Democrats.

But what is perhaps most tone-deaf of all is that Napolitano has launched this fight even as she defies a new state law that requires UC to be way more transparent about its finances so when it imposes tuition hikes, elected leaders understand why they are impossible to avoid.

I wrote about this angle in Tuesday’s U-T San Diego:

It’s hard to believe any government agency in a democracy would think it had no obligation to disclose essential details about its finances. Yet that has long been the norm with the University of California system and its multibillion-dollar annual budget.

This was supposed to change with enactment of a 2013 state law that requires UC to break down how — and for what — it uses state funding, tuition, research grants and other incoming dollars. This was done to force UC to offer a clear financial case when considering tuition hikes and enrollment changes. Presently, UC officials offer a vague “average cost of instruction” per student instead of a detailed analysis.

Beginning Oct. 1, university officials were supposed to provide such data. Not only has UC refused to comply, it has done so even as UC President Janet Napolitano proposed annual tuition hikes for the next five years.

In an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, Napolitano insisted UC wasn’t being “defiant.” But she also belittled the law as an inconvenient “budget exercise.”

This is inexcusable. Gov. Jerry Brown and the Legislature need to send Napolitano a clear, strong message that UC must comply with a plainly written — and badly needed — state law.

How long until Napolitano gives up on her tuition-hike push and launches a laughable attempt at face-saving? I’d say the over-under is Dec. 24. She’ll announce her new stance on Christmas Eve at 5 p.m. to hope it minimizes her embarrassment at being massively schooled by Gov. Edmund G. Brown Jr.

1 comment

Write a comment
  1. Jim Reardon
    Jim Reardon 20 November, 2014, 11:33

    What few realize is that the UC President has no power. She is ruled by the UC staff and Academic Senate, among others. Napolitano had two choices when confronted with UC’s bloated sense of entitlement, 1.) do the bidding of UC insiders, or 2.) resign. A resignation might have looked odd considering that she just took the job.

    What UC insiders are deaf to understand is the feeling of betrayal held by California parents and taxpayers who have paid all their lives to support an institution intended to to support California research and educate top-performing California students. The runaway UC cost structure has to be brought under control, but the UC President is powerless to make this happen. In the name of “academic freedom”, UC has become answerable to nobody and it is little wonder that the Legislature has no appetite for increased funding. What UC needs is less funding and less independence, but this can only be achieved by Constitutional reform of its charter. The voters would approve this in a heartbeat.

    As a conservative California parent, I long ago learned not to bet against Governor Brown. When Brown and Newsom together say “too much”, we should take notice. The focus on Napolitano is misplaced. She is merely a sad figurehead in a runaway educational bureaucracy that has outgrown its usefulness and lost its direction.

    Until UC is brought under control, it will simply continue to demand more tuition, admit more out-of-state and foreign students who pay FULL PRICE, and further alienate ordinary Californians.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Bicycle nuts driving local traffic issues

Sept. 14, 2012 Katy Grimes: Most of us recognize that California government is out-of-control. The state Legislature has just passed

Republicans Moving Forward?

UPDATE: I spoke with Assembly member Roger Niello over the weekend. Niello said that his discussions with Garrick were informal

Schwarzenegger Carbon Footprint ↑

John Seiler: Here’s the latest on the Schwarzenegger split: It now definitely looks like Arnold Schwarzenegger’s estranged wife Maria Shriver