Credibility crisis comes as PUC faces tough decisions

san.onofreThe recent series of scandals involving the California Public Utiities Commission hang like a pall over the regulatory agency. Recently deposed PUC President Michael Peevey’s swapping of favors with Pacific Gas & Electric and his surreptitious work with Southern California Edison on the $4.7 billion bailout for the damaged San Onofre nuclear plant raise questions about decisions the PUC has made dating back to 2002, when Peevey joined the PUC board. Given that San Diego Gas & Electric is the minority owner of San Onofre, Peevey had troubling ties to all three of the state’s giant power providers.

This cloud over the PUC comes at a particularly delicate point. California’s embrace of renewable energy is forcing the regulator to rethink how the state’s electricity grid can be maintained and kept healthy going forward. As the San Jose Mercury News reported last month, it wasn’t built with the idea that it would receive energy from so many different sources.

Nearly 23 percent of California’s energy now comes from renewable sources such as wind and solar, and the state is on track to reach its goal of generating one-third of its energy from renewables by 2020. But feeding all that green energy into the Golden State’s grid — without overloading it — has become a major challenge.

That’s because the state’s aging natural gas plants aren’t nimble enough to turn off when the sun starts shining and then quickly switch back on when it gets dark. And while the technology to generate clean energy is growing by leaps and bounds, efforts to store the power haven’t kept up. …

Roughly 140 companies sell to the market, resulting in about 27,000 transactions per day. The [California Independent System Operator, or ISO] makes sure the purchased electricity makes it to the utilities’ substations. …

Solar generation hit record in early March

Nellis_Solar_panelsIn the morning, electricity demand rises as people wake up and turn on appliances, lights and electric toothbrushes. And as the day wears on, the state is increasingly dependent on solar plants, especially in the afternoon.

A recent record was set on March 6, when solar peaked at 5,812 megawatts, five times what it was three years ago. All this solar power is allowing California to cut back on natural gas — which now provides about 60 percent of the state’s energy needs — and other traditional sources of electricity.

But this can be a problem because the sun sets at the same time that people are returning home. That causes electricity use to surge, and the power plants that were turned down or even off need to start producing — fast.

The majority of California’s power plants, however, aren’t up for the abrupt on-and-off challenge.

Officials with ISO, the nonprofit that manages the state’s electricity grid, see a need to build new natural-gas plants and retrofit old ones to deal with the headaches the system now faces. Peevey was much less hostile to natural-gas plants than members of the state’s green movement.

But if the PUC, with new president Michael Picker, continues this approach, he is sure to be depicted as being under the thumb of giant utilities.

Another headache: How to deal with solar homeowners and grid?

The PUC faces a related headache with homeowners and companies with solar panels which want to continue favorable rates they get for sending their excess power to the grid. San Diego Gas & Electric says the current approach doesn’t pencil out, as the U-T San Diego reported:

Under current regulations, solar owners get to sell their power into the grid at the full retail price, offsetting their costs at night when they pull electricity into their homes.

Everywhere else in the utility economy, power producers must sell at lower, wholesale prices. In most cases, they even pay for their use of the grid to reach customers.

So the PUC faces explosive questions here as well. Thousands of homeowners and companies with solar technology only made the costly investment because of a long-term expectation of a great deal from utilities. But if this great deal plays havoc with utilities’ bottom lines, they’ll need to transfer costs to their customers who don’t have solar panels.

And every rate change SDG&E, PG&E and Edison seek will be considered with the backdrop of recent scandals in which Peevey appeared to have an extraordinarily chummy relationship with the three utilities.

It appears to be a recipe for distrust and controversy going forward as the PUC reckons with a new era in California power generation.

2 comments

Write a comment
  1. BRANDON
    BRANDON 23 April, 2015, 11:07

    The CPUC has lots of credibility issues. Today in the cites of Duarte and Ontario, California. CPUC President Picker will be touring residential areas where massive 200 foot tall transmission towers have been erected within 40 to 70 feet of homes to transmit between 500,000 to almost 1 MILLION volts of power next to homes. This is part of Gov. Brown’s “Green” agenda that ha many residents in fear of EMF radiation, destruction of property values, unknown health concerns, and so on. The residents are asking that the CPUC intervene and BURY THE LINES in residential areas as they did in the City of Chino Hills.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published.
Required fields are marked*



Chris Reed

Chris Reed

Chris Reed is a regular contributor to Cal Watchdog. Reed is an editorial writer for U-T San Diego. Before joining the U-T in July 2005, he was the opinion-page columns editor and wrote the featured weekly Unspin column for The Orange County Register. Reed was on the national board of the Association of Opinion Page Editors from 2003-2005. From 2000 to 2005, Reed made more than 100 appearances as a featured news analyst on Los Angeles-area National Public Radio affiliate KPCC-FM. From 1990 to 1998, Reed was an editor, metro columnist and film critic at the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin in Ontario. Reed has a political science degree from the University of Hawaii (Hilo campus), where he edited the student newspaper, the Vulcan News, his senior year.

He is on Twitter: @chrisreed99.

Related Articles

State worst place to do business!

A healthy round of congratulations to state officials is definitely in order. A press release just sent out by Senator

CA wants oil taxes without oil

March 12, 2013 By John Seiler Steven Greenhut, whose column we run, has written an amusing article in Bloomberg about how

U.S., Calif. Economies Crashing?

John Seiler: Californians should thank the ghost of Hiram Johnson that taxes weren’t raised in the new budget, and that