Anti-vax referendum push falls short

vaccine121014The drive to restore California’s vaccination exemptions through the state referendum process has failed.

At stake was Senate Bill 277, signed into law by Gov. Jerry Brown on a wave of concern that “herd immunity” among California children was compromised by a growing anti-vaccination trend. Coauthored by state Sens. Richard Pan, D-Sacramento, and Ben Allen, D-Redondo Beach, SB277 “will require all children entering kindergarten to be vaccinated unless a doctor certifies that a child has a medical condition, such as allergies, preventing it,” as the Los Angeles Daily News summarized the law.

Missing the mark

After submitting signatures gathered in the hopes of meeting the legal threshold of adequate public support, organizers behind the would-be measure discovered that their numbers had fallen short: “They turned in some 228,000 signatures on petitions for a referendum to overturn the measure, far short of the number needed to qualify it for next year’s ballot,” as the Los Angeles Times reported. “Referendum supporters needed the signatures of 365,880 registered voters by Monday to place the measure before state voters in November 2016.”

Efforts to meet the requirements were bedeviled by the shoestring character of the operation. “While the campaign deployed paid signature gatherers in the final stretch before the deadline, it was largely a volunteer effort,” according to the Sacramento Bee, “a tough task given that successful initiative campaigns typically cost millions of dollars.”

Citing internal documentation, the Bee noted that some California counties weren’t represented at all in the final tally. “Organizers in six counties did not submit any signatures by the deadline, according to an initial survey of raw data from the California secretary of state’s office. While the organizers’ spreadsheet contains estimates for large population centers like Orange County, Los Angeles County and Riverside County, they did not have an estimate for 16 counties in addition to the six the secretary of state said did not submit signatures,” the paper reported.

Raising allegations

vaccination cartoonBut one of the foremost political figures behind the movement to restore the personal belief exemption to mandatory child vaccinations alleged that the signature-gathering effort had fallen victim to foul play. “The leading proponent of the effort, former Republican Assemblyman Tim Donnelly, said in an email Monday that volunteers were coerced and threatened while collecting signatures,” according to the Associated Press. “Donnelly did not return repeated messages inquiring about the effort’s chances but said in his email that he was proud of the volunteers who worked on the campaign ‘whatever the outcome is.'” Donnelly said the push “was sabotaged from without and within by powerful forces from its very inception, but we never gave up and we never gave in.”

Although Donnelly had gained notoriety of late as an outspoken gubernatorial candidate, his charges have yet to faze supporters of the stringent vaccination mandate. In remarks to KOVR Sacramento, Pan said he supported “the right to pursue a referendum,” according to the Daily News. But Pan also told reporters he was “sure the voters of California are not interested in letting a privileged few take away the rights of all Californians to be safe from preventable disease,” the AP noted.

Plan B

As the deadline for submitting signatures neared, some anti-vaccination activists created what could be a second opportunity to accomplish objectives similar to the hoped-for referendum. In a recent message posted to Facebook, the group announced that they had filed for a so-called Parental Rights Constitutional Amendment Initiative. “The measure was filed now in part because the filing fee for initiatives is going up Jan. 1 from $200 to $2,000,” the post said, according to the Los Angeles Times. “Supporters have six months to collect signatures for an initiative, far longer than 90 days provided for a referendum.”


Write a comment
  1. AntI vax man
    AntI vax man 5 October, 2015, 12:09

    The 6 counties with no totals is due to one gal fed exing then overnight on a Sunday. Fed ex does not work Sundays, so they arrived tuesday, one day late. Everyone knows fed ex doesn’t overnight on Sundays and fed ex will tell you that. Why didn’t she delivery them in person to guarantee they would be counted?

    Reply this comment
  2. Pam
    Pam 5 October, 2015, 12:15

    This was billed as “Anti-Vax” Referendum in your article. That is inaccurate. We were not Anti-Vax, we were for taking back Parental Rights to make decisions for their children’s healthcare instead of the government. We wanted to make sure the parents understood they were losing their rights over their children. We also had parents working on this Referendum because they had vaccine injured children due to Big Pharma covered up the known risks and problems.

    Reply this comment
  3. Mitch
    Mitch 5 October, 2015, 13:01

    Well I guess if you think our legislative body should receive over 2 million in ‘bribes’ for a bill then I guess we no longer have any scruples.
    If you read to the end of the bill you would see that this whole plan for mandatory vaccinations is a scam built up by big pharma because it states the amount of people affected. 137 out of 38.2 Million stole the show.
    How about we get the Grand Jury to investigate the CA legislative body? All these special interest groups are taking control. It doesn’t matter who we vote into office at this point.
    I thought they worked for me……

    Reply this comment
  4. bob
    bob 5 October, 2015, 23:20

    It’s a Brown Clown state and we are all just visitors…

    In his view all your kids are “Jerry’s Kids” so you’d better have them roll up their sleeves.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Divided Democrats look to Brown for lessons

Waiting until nearly the last possible moment, Gov. Jerry Brown endorsed Hillary Clinton for president, highlighting both the limits of

Who’s running the Delta Stewardship Council?

By KATY GRIMES With the five major component bills of the 2009 water package representing a massive undertaking for the

Group Touts New Pension Initiative

DEC. 1, 2010 By STEVEN GREENHUT A pension reform organization has released a draft initiative plan for the 2012 ballot