CA drought brings fines, shaming

waterAfter a wave of new rules, regulations and crackdowns, many water-conserving Californians have evaded formal and informal punishment. With no end in sight, however, others have begun to face both forms of penalties.

The mood of the public and officials alike has tilted hard against outsized consumers. Although “water providers such as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power have refused to divulge the names of California’s top residential water users,” the Los Angeles Times reported, “the DWP is now considering changes to its water conservation ordinance that would impose ‘substantial’ fines for excessive use and make the names public.”

Pressed by “public outrage, and questioning by Los Angeles City Councilman Paul Koretz,” the Times noted, DWP would follow in the East Bay’s footsteps, where agency overusers recently confronted “an excessive-use penalty ordinance that allows it to fine and name water customers who consume more than four times the average household.”

From nagging to snitching

In the Bay Area, a culture of water shaming has developed from the ground up. In a report on “the domestic water police,” the New York Times recently identified “moms and dads, spouses and partners, children, even co-workers and neighbors” as among the residents “quick to wag a finger when they spot people squandering moisture, such as a faucet left running while they’re brushing their teeth, or using too much water to clean dinner plates in the sink. And showers? No lingering allowed.”

More nagging has gone hand in hand with more snitching. The Times reported that “state water agencies issued more than 70,000 warnings for overuse and more than 20,000 penalties” this June and July, with many issued when “someone’s neighbor ratted on them,” according to State Water Resources Control Board climate and conservation manager Max Gomberg.

Although those penalties landed on a relatively small group of die-hard squanderers, the state has now leveled substantial fines on whole cities that failed to meet conservation targets. “While most communities continue to hit mandated conservation targets, a few have consistently missed,” the Sacramento Bee noted. “All four were in Southern California: Beverly Hills, Indio, Redlands and Coachella Valley Water District. Each was fined $61,000.”

These sums could be only the beginning. “The penalties are based on the board’s authority to issue fines of $500 per day for violations of its emergency regulation,” according to the Press-Enterprise. “The board could also issue the providers a cease and desist order, which carries a fine up to $10,000 per day for non-compliance.”

A vicious circle

water meter 2The crackdown has come as agencies have hiked rates for users who do conserve. “Water providers in Los Angeles, the San Francisco Bay Area and other parts of the state have recently told customers that rates will go up at least temporarily, as utilities struggle to pay for building and repairing pipes, buying water and other costs, even as customers cut back,” according to Reuters. Agencies have sometimes wound up a victim of their own success. “In Los Angeles, conservation led to a $111 million drop in revenues during the fiscal year that ended July 1, a period mostly before the mandatory cutbacks kicked into high gear, Department of Water and Power budget director Neil Guglielmo said Friday.”

But for now, regulators have tried to emphasize the positive. “Californians slashed their water use 26 percent in September, meeting Gov. Jerry Brown’s goal of 25 percent for the fourth straight month,” the San Francisco Chronicle reported, citing recently released state data. Though encouraged by the numbers, water agencies have strained to strike a messaging balance between threats and warnings on the one hand and encouragement and pride on the other, hoping to give savers a sense of reward without subtly encouraging a return to laxity. Utilities, noted the Chronicle, remained dedicated to “trying to keep the conservation message front and center after four dry years, especially as residents may be tempted to become less diligent with forecasts calling for a wetter-than-average winter.”


Write a comment
  1. Spurwing Plover
    Spurwing Plover 3 November, 2015, 08:20

    Imperial govenor Moonbeam Brown plans fines for green green lawns

    Reply this comment
  2. Queeg
    Queeg 3 November, 2015, 08:44

    Comrade Plooper

    Careful… Medfly copters are airborne, GPS locked on your Graboid bunker!

    Reply this comment
    • Ted
      Ted 4 November, 2015, 13:51

      He’s right ! And the black helos will take your guns and put Grandma in front of the death panel !!!

      Reply this comment
  3. Skep41
    Skep41 3 November, 2015, 11:18

    So the state that has refused to build any new water infrastructure for 40 years and which is now building a $60 billion bullet-train to Fresno to Save The Planet is going to start trying to shame Saudi princes for changing the water in each of their four wives’ pools at their Beverly Hills mansions every couple of weeks? That’ll fix everything.

    Reply this comment
  4. winesmith
    winesmith 3 November, 2015, 12:50

    The State Water Resources Control Board is now trying to assess small wineries in California $500 for NOT discharging storm water (not waste water) into “Waters Of The US (WOTUS).
    The fee/tax is much larger for those who discharge. More confiscatory theft to support the Gov’s tunnel project?

    Reply this comment
  5. desmond
    desmond 3 November, 2015, 19:04

    We need to shame Ellison and Zuckerberg, Dorsey. These scum need to leave the state and take their businesses with them.
    The money saved could go to education and border crossers.
    California needs to get rid of all for profit businesses. They are responsible for climate change.Yah.
    Close gas stations, ban jobs!!!

    Reply this comment
    • Queeg
      Queeg 3 November, 2015, 20:37

      Comrade Desi

      Love, community, shared investment and leveling the playing field too!

      Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Sen. Leland Yee allegedly brokered arms deals

A prominent San Francisco Democrat, who has been one of the state’s leading proponents of gun control, is accused of

Government transparency effort faces union backlash

Senate Bill 331, a bill sponsored by government employee unions that is on Gov. Jerry Brown’s desk, is touted as

Watchdog: Costly veterans’ homes not serving broad population

SACRAMENTO – The U.S. Veterans Administration has been a font of scandal in recent years, with various reports showcasing the