Average Joe seat on state commission filled by the well-connected

Stockton’s Anthony and Rima Barkett were hosting a fabulous party in Rome in 2007 to discuss what the world could do to stop the Darfur killings.

The party’s guest list included actors Don Cheadle and George Clooney, two Nobel Laureates and the mayor of Rome.

There at the Barkett’s apartment at the Villa Borghese, a verdant central park of fountains and museums, began a three-day, annual summit started by former Soviet Union President Mikhail Gorbachev to honor those who spread peace, reported the Los Angeles Times.

Today, Barkett serves on the state commission that sets pay for top officials, in the seat meant to represent the state’s Average Joes. The commission, which convenes its annual pay-setting meeting next month, also has spots set aside for business, union, nonprofit and compensation professionals.

Barkett told CalWatchdog he was not sure of the criteria for the seat, but said he has “a diverse background in law, real estate, agriculture and general business so I think I am well suited to represent the general public on this commission.”

Barkett’s seat

The seat on the California Citizens Compensation Commission for the “general population” could include a “retiree, homemaker, or person of median income,” according to the state constitutional provision put in place by the voters.

Barkett was appointed in 2013. He succeeded a former mayor and bank vice-president as well as a roofing contractor who had contributed almost $150,000 since 1997 to federal campaigns.


Sacramento_CapitolThe commission’s duty — which came out of a sweeping ethics reform package, Proposition 112, in 1990 — is to decide the pay and benefits of constitutional officers, like governor, attorney general and state legislators.

That package was aimed at giving regular citizens a measure of influence.

“When voters passed Proposition 112, there was a clear interest in creating a California Citizens Compensation Commission that would not be dominated by wealthy donors with personal connections to elected officials,” said Kathay Feng, the executive director of the good government group California Common Cause, which lobbied for Prop. 112 at the time of its creation and passage.

“The spirit of the law was to create a commission that would represent average Californians from different walks of life who could assess what would be reasonable compensation for our lawmakers,” Feng said.

However, because for the 12 months prior to being appointed Barkett hadn’t been a lobbyist, held elected or appointive office or been a candidate for elected office (a blanket requirement for three of the commission members), Brown’s office contends there’s nothing to see here.

“The appointment is consistent with statute,” said Brown spokesman Evan Westrup.


Barkett and his cousin Edward, described in local reports as being from “one of the city’s most prominent families,” are commercial real estate developers. The two own an office building in Sacramento with a $4.2 million value for taxing purposes and a city center development in Lodi worth $6.8 million. They developed downtown Stockton’s reported $15 million City Centre Cinemas 16.

The median household income in California is $61,489. In Stockton it is $45,347.

The value of Barkett’s home in Stockton is estimated around four times the average local home value, according to data gathered from public disclosures and real estate websites.


He’s listed as legal counsel for a company called 3 Leaf Holdings. Along with another business partner, Chris Flaherty, chairman and CEO of 3 Leaf Holdings, Barkett owns or manages a few development companies, a renewable energy company, a 160-acre walnut and olive orchard in Linden and a 110-acre cherry orchard in Salida. Flaherty is also a Brown appointee, to the 2nd District Agricultural Association, San Joaquin County Fair Board.

Since 1999, Barkett has given about $45,000 to federal candidates, mostly Democrats. He contributed another $81,000 to state candidates since 2002. And Rima, his wife, also a Brown appointee, gave another $5,900 at the federal level.

For years, Barkett has served as a political consultant for the Stockton East Water District.

Barkett’s father was Dr. Joseph Barkett, a family physician who, like Barkett, owned commercial properties and orchards. He was chairman of the San Joaquin County Democratic Club and raised money for two Democratic presidents: John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson. He was appointed to two terms on the World Trade Center Authority by then-Gov. Jerry Brown (during his first stint as governor).

His predecessors

Barkett replaced on the commission Kathy Sands, an appointee of former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who had been on the Auburn City Council for eight years, with two terms as mayor — but not for 12 months prior to her appointment (as required by law).

Sands had held other notable positions in Auburn city government as well. She had served as the vice president of the Auburn Chamber of Commerce and had, by the time she left after 40 years, worked her way up to vice president and senior loan officer of Placer Savings and Loan.

Johnny Zamrzla, an appointee of Republican Gov. Pete Wilson, held the seat before Sands. A roofing contractor in Palmdale, Zamrzla had been active in industry groups like the Western States Roofing Contractors Association — there’s even an annual roofing award given in his honor. He has given to $145,000 to federal candidates over the years.

Read more:

Some legislators proudly refuse pay increases
Vacancies plague commission on state lawmaker’s pay


Write a comment
  1. Dana Law
    Dana Law 26 March, 2016, 05:34

    I always learn something about our government, or lack of it from your columns. And in an even handed way. I’m fortunate to have a in depth source of political reporting that informs me as a citizen of California.

    Thank you,

    Dana Law
    San Diego

    Reply this comment
  2. Spurwing Plover
    Spurwing Plover 26 March, 2016, 06:15

    The average joe don’t stand a chance of being heard especialy with a ignorant cement head like Moonbeam in Sacremento he like most of the demac-RAT party do as they please

    Reply this comment
  3. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 26 March, 2016, 08:15

    Yep. These fair and balanced articles shiver ye timbers….thank goodness Donkey, Poodle and Desi are not well connected…..

    Have you ever wondered if the unconnected have gene deficiences concerning rational discernment in dealing with public service issues?????

    Reply this comment
  4. Richard Rider
    Richard Rider 26 March, 2016, 09:27

    Salary setting commissions are a rigged jury, where the beneficiaries of the salaries pick the members of the “jury.” Everyone in this ‘circle of life’ knows how it works.

    IF we are to rely on such commissions, the “jury” should be selected by lottery. And even that system is subject to corruption. But the current commission system GUARANTEES crony corruption.

    Reply this comment
    • josil
      josil 27 March, 2016, 14:31

      Of course such commissions are rigged…and probably all commissions given the selection process. In fact, it is possible to identify the selection process by viewing the results of their conclusions.

      Reply this comment
  5. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 26 March, 2016, 09:39

    Well, it could be worse, Teddy Steals or Seesaw could be on the commission, where million dollar comp packages could be “negotiated” 🙂

    Reply this comment
  6. Mark 1 Advance
    Mark 1 Advance 26 March, 2016, 09:41

    Spirit of the law. Letter of the law. While the letter is being followed the spirit is certainly not. Appointments to contributors is how the system works and as evidenced, the “Average Joe” appointee is anything but. As long as we keep electing career politicians we will continue to get what we have.

    Reply this comment
  7. Leaving Soon
    Leaving Soon 26 March, 2016, 09:42

    What a shock! Voters create board position to represent the every day working tax-payer and the ruling elites hijack it to benefit their wealthy friends. Follow the money every time!

    Reply this comment
  8. Susan
    Susan 26 March, 2016, 10:56

    Very grateful to Matt Fleming and Calwatchdog for covering a story such as this one that we wouldn’t otherwise know about. Thank you

    Reply this comment
  9. RobertV
    RobertV 26 March, 2016, 12:52


    Reply this comment
  10. Truthafuss
    Truthafuss 27 March, 2016, 06:21

    If these people, these self-adoring rich, had any influence, if their ideas had essential validity, maybe we’d actually see it sometime? Down where the wheels meet the road?

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Doctors more worried than ever about nurse practitioners getting expanded role

California doctors’ long-held opposition to nurse practitioners expanding their scope of practice into areas now reserved exclusively for doctors has

Think tank explained CA’s affordable housing debacles long ago

A weekend story about the gross failure of affordable housing policies in San Francisco contained plenty of public frustration and

Democrats jeopardize $1.3 billion in federal funds

May 15, 2012 By Katy Grimes It appears that Democrats aren’t really sincere or even serious about working toward solutions that