Civil liberty groups demand Solano County court stop suspending licenses of drivers too poor to pay fines

traffic ticketSolano County Superior Court fell under fire Tuesday from civil liberty groups demanding that judges stop suspending licenses of drivers without at least first determining if a driver has the ability to pay.

By the end of 2015, more than 1.9 million Californians, many of who whom are unemployed, disabled or homeless, had suspended licenses for failure to appear or failure to pay on citations, according to data provided by the coalition of groups, which includes the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of Northern California.

During that time period, there were nearly 33,000 suspended licenses in Solano County for a combination of failure to pay and failure to appear in court, which is about 7.75% of the county’s total population. And more than 11,000 of those suspensions were solely for failure to pay, the coalition wrote in a letter on Tuesday to the Hon. Robert C. Fracchia, Presiding Judge of the Superior Court of Solano County.

Snowball effect

In many instances, drivers receive an initial fine for some violation, with lots of additional fees tacked on. What was a $100 fine could be several hundred dollars and only swelling from there, sometimes escalating to thousands as payment is not made. This often leads to a suspension, which limits the driver’s ability to get to work and perpetuates the problem, the coalition argued.

“These non-safety related suspensions make it harder for people to get and keep jobs, harm credit ratings, increase county financial burdens in support of health and welfare and make it less likely that the court fines and fees will ever get paid,” the coalition wrote. “For low-income and indigent drivers, fines and fees create an insurmountable obstacle to the reinstatement of a driver’s license.”

Correlation to poverty 

Data shows a strong correlation between high poverty rates and high suspension rates in the bay area.

The Vehicle Code permits suspension for failure to pay only if the driver does so “willfully,” which the group argued shouldn’t include “indigence or financial difficulties.” The group continued that drivers should be afforded due process protections, meaning drivers should be “heard on the element of ‘willfulness’ and their ability to pay.”


The coalition is asking that Solano County Superior Court cease the practice of suspending licenses for unpaid fines.

But assuming the court doesn’t immediately comply, the coalition demands the court give the offending drivers notification of the total amount of fines and fees due, of his or her right to a judicial determination of ability to pay, of any payment options available (including an installment plan) and of the possibility that the driver’s license may be suspended.

Other efforts

Last month, the group sent a similar letter to the San Mateo County Superior Court.

The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the Bay Area, Legal Services for Prisoners with Children and the Western Center on Law and Poverty are working with the ACLU Foundation of Northern California in these efforts.


Write a comment
  1. Dude
    Dude 19 April, 2016, 19:08

    “By the end of 2015, more than 1.9 million Californians, many of who whom are unemployed, disabled or homeless, had suspended licenses for failure to appear or failure to pay on citations,

    They conveniently left out the fact that most of these people are illegal aliens.

    Reply this comment
  2. Dawn Urbanek
    Dawn Urbanek 19 April, 2016, 19:34

    We are all entitled to equal protection under the laws – you can’t force everyone except poor people to abide by the laws of the United States. If suspending the licenses of poor people is to harmful- then stop suspending any licenses- problem solved.

    Reply this comment
  3. Leaving Soon
    Leaving Soon 19 April, 2016, 19:43

    YOU COMMIT THE CRIME YOU DO THE TIME. Since when has illegal become legal? Crazy liberal thinking! Stop the insanity!!

    Reply this comment
  4. Queeg
    Queeg 20 April, 2016, 10:11


    Treat the Franks and Huns with compassion…..their cultures are openly primevil outside the dainty bounds of urban territorial frictions or reluctant coexistence.

    In other words…they use guarded HOA gate iron for toothpicks!

    Reply this comment
  5. Bill - San Jose
    Bill - San Jose 20 April, 2016, 11:26

    Why bother with the rule of law? If we don’t have police enforcing the laws, then we don’t need police,right?

    I love the idea of a wild west again. Sign me up because ain’t nothing better than a lawless country.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Kashkari would veto gun bills

GOP candidate Neel Kashkari assured gun owners Friday he’s opposed to controversial gun-control measures now sitting on the desk of

Brown struggles to hit education stride

With education becoming a major state issue just in time for the election, Gov. Jerry Brown has found himself in

Gov. Brown opposes CA minimum wage hike

Opening another fissure with members of his own party, Gov. Jerry Brown has come down on the opposite side of a