In the spirit of ‘Animal Farm’: Some projects are more ‘worthwhile’ than others

By Chris Reed
Sept. 21

The difference between the federal government’s go-slow-or-is-it-no-go approach on the Keystone XL oil pipeline and the let’s-get-it-done push for the first segment of the California bullet train is instructive, in that in both cases we are told that environmental rules need to be taken seriously and rigorously enforced. Hence this paragraph in the Wednesday Mercury-News story about the (tiny) delay to the formal federal go-ahead for bullet-train work in the Central Valley:

Even though Congress and President Barack Obama previously approved enough funding to split the cost of the initial stretch of track, U.S. officials still needed to ensure the project met federal environmental laws. Wednesday’s 41-page ruling said that while the bullet train will have “significant” negative impacts on the environment and community — from loud noises to reducing property values — it’s still worthwhile.

But wait a minute: So now whether a project is “worthwhile” is somehow a formal metric for approval? Isn’t “worthwhile” kind of an ultimate eye-of-the-beholder thing? Are there federal standards for worthwhileitude that someone can cite? So the preposterous, lie-driven bullet train is worthwhiler than Keystone, which could transform the already-wildly-improving U.S. energy picture? Sheer insanity.

Thankfully, we know that there are actual federal regulations that can be used to tie big infrastructure projects into knots — even “good” ones — and rich cities in Silicon Valley are eager to use them. Go, NIMBYs, go. Administer a beating to the bullet-train nuts. A worthwhile one.


Write a comment
  1. Bob
    Bob 21 September, 2012, 09:33

    Just another in the endless examples of DemoNcrat hypocrisy.

    Reply this comment
  2. Queeg
    Queeg 21 September, 2012, 10:48

    Oh Bob….. just being Bob…..did not have his usual Grape Nuts this morning!

    Reply this comment
  3. us citizen
    us citizen 21 September, 2012, 12:30

    That’s right Bob.

    Reply this comment
  4. Queeg
    Queeg 21 September, 2012, 13:04

    Us is short and sweet today.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Arnold should blame himself

John Seiler: Reports Capitol Alert: Speaking today at the Goleta Valley Chamber of Commerce, the Republican governor had no qualms about

CalWatchdog Morning Read – April 21, 2016

Economic outlook grim, reality not as bad. Plus minimum wage, pensions and taxes. Good morning. A new report on the

U.S. CEOs again call California most hostile to business

It’s a May tradition: Chief Executive magazine announces its best and worst states when it comes to receptivity to business.