Kern County sheriffs seize cell phones to hide killing of citizen

Rodney-King-beatingMay 14, 2013

By John Seiler

Cops are getting out of control, especially in California. Not yet two years since the Fullerton police beat to death homeless man Kelly Thomas on July 5, 2011, comes this:

“Blood stains are still visible on the sidewalk at the corner of Flower Street and Palm Drive, where a Bakersfield man struggled with as many as nine officers and later died this week.

“David Sal Silva, 33 and the father of four young children, died early Wednesday morning after deputies say he fought with them and CHP officers who’d responded to a report of a possibly intoxicated man outside Kern Medical Center.

“The Kern County Sheriff’s Office says Silva resisted, a canine was deployed, more law enforcement arrived, batons were used and the man later had trouble breathing. He was taken to KMC, where he died. An autopsy was slated for Thursday, but no results have been released.

“Some witnesses apparently took cellphone video of the incident but deputies moved quickly to seize the phones. The Sheriff’s Office, after releasing a statement Wednesday and naming its officers Thursday, declined all further comment.

“People who say they witnessed the incident as well as Silva’s family members described a scene in which deputies essentially were beating a helpless man to death. They were indignant that cellphone video had been taken away by deputies.

“‘My brother spent the last eight minutes of his life pleading, begging for his life,’ said Christopher Silva, 31, brother of the dead man. He said he’s talked to witnesses but did not see the incident himself.

“At about midnight, Ruben Ceballos, 19, was awakened by screams and loud banging noises outside his home. He said he ran to the left side of his house to find out who was causing the ruckus.

“‘When I got outside I saw two officers beating a man with batons and they were hitting his head so every time they would swing, I could hear the blows to his head,’ Ceballos said.

“Silva was on the ground screaming for help, but officers continued to beat him, Ceballos said.

“After several minutes, Ceballos said, Silva stopped screaming and was no longer responsive.’

‘Police Tape’ app

Let’s hope one of the cell-phone videos somehow survived seizure by the Kern Sheriffs-Stasi. Also, the Kern Medical Center might have surveillance cameras that could be subpoenaed by Silva’s family. And someone in the hospital itself might have taken pictures without the Stasi seeing them.

If you’re ever in a similar situation, this shows the importance of immediately posting your photos to Facebook or somewhere else. We’re 22 years now from the video-taped beating of Rodney King (shown above), and most people have phones with cameras.

Also, the ACLU of New Jersey has released a free “Police Tape” app for Android and iPhones. According to the description:

“Citizens can hold police accountable in the palms of their hands with “Police Tape,” a smartphone application from the ACLU of New Jersey that allows people to securely and discreetly record and store interactions with police, as well as provide legal information about citizens’ rights when interacting with the police.

“The Android “Police Tape” app records video and audio discreetly, disappearing from the screen once the recording begins to prevent any attempt by police to squelch the recording. In addition to keeping a copy on the phone itself, the user can choose to send it to the ACLU-NJ for backup storage and analysis of possible civil liberties violations….

“The popularity of cellphones with video capabilities has raised legal questions about the rights of citizens to record in public. Fortunately, the courts have sided with citizens. In May 2012, a federal appeals court struck down an Illinois law that had made it illegal for citizens to record police officers on-duty. Also in May 2012, the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice released a letter affirming the constitutional rights to record the police in public. These two developments came on the heels of a landmark ruling in August 2011, which recognized the right of citizens to record police officers after a Massachusetts man in Boston Common was wrongfully arrested for filming an interaction with a police officer.”


So the Kern Stasi’s seizure of the phones was completely unconstitutional. That could generate further lawsuits against the county for violations of citizens’ rights. The seizures violated not only the Fourth Amendment “right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.” The seizures also violated the First Amendment right of “freedom of… the press,” because in this age of Facebook and blogs, everyone is a journalist.

Finally, as I mentioned in my previous blog on a new private Detroit program, police need to be re-trained from their current mode of beating and shooting first, to the old one of first protecting the lives of citizens — even at the risk of their own lives.


Write a comment
  1. Hondo
    Hondo 13 May, 2013, 21:41

    As much as I try to take the side of the police, this is one of many instances they need to be smacked down. Then there were the 2 ladies who were shot up by idiot cops looking for Dorner.
    Cops across the country are horrified of those cell phones. Many states still try to make it illegal to video tape a cop on the job, no matter how many times courts defend it.
    The street law says it ain’t illegal till you get caught. And prosecuted and imprisoned. Possession is nine tenths of the law. The cops got the phones now and I imagine the videos will be somehow ‘damaged beyond use’.
    Part of the problem is the police unions. It is nearly impossible to fire a public worker of any type and their unions have amassed huge amounts of money to hire armies of lawyers.
    The city will have to settle. The police and afford to litigate but the city can’t. There will be no charges because the videos will end up being ‘unusable’, but there are still people who saw the attack and the city will be forced to pay idiotic amounts to the family. The cops will get off, scot free.

    Reply this comment
  2. Dyspeptic
    Dyspeptic 13 May, 2013, 22:30

    Just another routine thug swarm from our valiant boys in blue. Give some people a badge and they think they can do anything. Hondo, you are right about cop unions. They are a public menace. When will the complacent and self absorbed public wake up and put a stop to this kind of abuse? That’s obviously a rhetorical question. Most people don’t seem to understand that if it can happen to a stranger it can happen to them just as easily.

    We truly live in an idiotocracy. Thanks to government school indoctrination and a complicit “news” media the average American has about as much principled concern for civil liberties as the average German citizen of 1934. It’s a wonder we have any liberty left at all.

    Reply this comment
  3. Donkey
    Donkey 14 May, 2013, 12:33

    This is typical police behavior all over the nation. There is no accountability when the wolves are doing the investigating and police written policy usurps the Constitutional rights of the citizens they are murdering. The British didn’t even behave this badly towards the colonials. You can go to youtube and watch endless film of cops commiting felonies on both cuffed and unresponsive citizens, knowing that the system is rigged in their favor.

    The police officers Bill of Rights is used to keep the criminals in LE from being prosecuted, while the citizens Bill of Rights is ignored. 🙂

    Reply this comment
  4. Donkey
    Donkey 14 May, 2013, 12:35

    Hondo, the RAGWUS sucks!!!! 🙂

    Reply this comment
  5. Donkey
    Donkey 14 May, 2013, 12:37

    John wrote: “Finally, as I mentioned in my previous blog on a new private Detroit program, police need to be re-trained from their current mode of beating and shooting first, to the old one of first protecting the lives of citizens — even at the risk of their own lives.”

    I have been singing this same theme ever since the murder of Ashley MacDonald!! 🙂

    Reply this comment
  6. ExCop-LawStudent
    ExCop-LawStudent 16 May, 2013, 09:06

    The use of a search warrant to seize the cellphone likely violated federal law (42 USC 2000aa). In the 911 tape, the lady clearly tells the operator that she intends to send the video to the news media, meeting the work product definition of the statute as material intended for dissemination to the public. The Sheriff’s Office must subpoena the video, which also means that the owner would keep possession of a copy – which could then be sent to the media.

    Let me know if you want more info and I’ll post a link.

    Reply this comment
  7. bob moore
    bob moore 18 May, 2013, 01:47

    if we cant record cops how can they record us. the rules for the cops should be the same as for the citizens.when someone is killed by cops and they caused the incident like in bakersfield they should automatically be prosecuted .

    Reply this comment
  8. Cal Atty
    Cal Atty 24 May, 2013, 09:51

    Actually, the cell phones were taken after a warrant was secured, so, technically, no 4th Am. violation for that reason. However, the real question was the apparent forced sequestration of the phone owners in their homes for hours until a warrant could be secured. That is a no-no. As well the grounds for the warrants may be highly suspect.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

I’m going to Starbucks to support gun rights!

Feb. 22, 2013 By John Seiler When my work is done today, I’m heading off to Starbucks to patronize their

California’s new undocumented jurors

April 26, 2013 By Katy Grimes The dead Boston Bomber, Tamerlan Tsarnaev, would have been eligible to serve on a

Rice Talks of World Shocks in Sacto

Valerie Starr: Condoleeza Rice spoke to a packed house last night at the Sacramento Speaker Series at the Community Center.