St. Louis Fed: There was no recovery

Federal Reserve Bank of St. LouisMay 31, 2013

By John Seiler

Gov. Jerry Brown and others have been proclaiming “California is back” because of greater state revenues. But I’ve been warning here all along that the “recovery” is hollow. For one thing, the reduction in “unemployment” has occurred only because millions of people have become discouraged and quit looking for jobs.

Now a shocking new report from the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank shows how weak the recovery has been:

“American households have rebuilt less than half of the wealth lost during the recession, leaving them without the spending power to fuel a robust economic recovery, according to a new analysis from the Federal Reserve.

“From the peak of the boom to the bottom of the bust, households watched a total of $16 trillion in wealth disappear amid sinking stock prices and the rubble of the real estate market. Since then, Americans have only been able to recapture 45 percent of that amount on average, after adjusting for inflation and population growth, according to the report from the St. Louis Fed released Thursday.”

I have pointed out how a real recovery cannot occur with Chairman Ben Bernanke’s Federal Reserve Board keeping interest rates at zero percent. Inflation is low at about 2 percent (officially). So the middlec class’s savings are eroding every year by about 2 percent. And that has been going for six years now.

Usually, interest rates are about 2 percentage points above inflation. That allows people to save, invest, grow and start businesses without gambling in the stock market or real estate. You just plunk your money in the local bank or S&L, and it grows at 2 percent a year. Not great, but over time it adds up. You can use the accumulated savings to pay for a kid’s education, build a nest egg or finance a new small business.

But in recent years, doing that has been impossible because the nest egg isn’t growing, but shrinking.

More:

“In addition, the report showed most of the improvement was due to gains in the stock market, which primarily benefit wealthy families. That means the recovery for other households has been even weaker.”

Right. Unless you know how to play the markets, which can be risky, you didn’t have any economic “recovery” at all.

This also means that, when the next recession strikes — and they do every four-six years — it will do so with a weaker underlying economic base than existed when the last recession hit in 2007 and the economic meltdown struck in Sept. 2008.

For California, this is really bad news. It means that the current state and local surpluses are likely to be as fleeting as a Monterey summer breeze. And when the next recession strikes, people and businesses are going to be finding ways to make do on less. One way to do that is to move somewhere that living and doing business is cheaper — where land costs less and taxes are lower. Which is about anywhere outside California.

This isn’t as evident during good times, like now, when profits are rising. But in recessionary times, people move to where they can survive.

 

4 comments

Write a comment
  1. Dyspeptic
    Dyspeptic 31 May, 2013, 11:53

    “Inflation is low at about 2 percent (officially). So the middlec class’s savings are eroding every year by about 2 percent. And that has been going for six years now.”

    I don’t subscribe to ShadowStats, but I would imagine that it shows at least twice as much real inflation as what The Ministry of Truth CPI nonsense purports to show. That would reduce the value of everyone’s savings by twice as much as this study shows. Not that anyone in the Land Of The Lotus Eaters actually saves anything anyway. Only suckers save for tomorrow and live within their means now. The smart people spend everything they make, get underwater on their houses and rack up huge debts so they can get bailed out by the profligate Compassion Nazi’s who are running the system into the ground.

    “In addition, the report showed most of the improvement was due to gains in the stock market, which primarily benefit wealthy families. That means the recovery for other households has been even weaker.”

    Crony Capitalist Stock market gains can vanish in an instant for us little people, as we saw in 2008-2009. This is mostly illusory, paper wealth based on the Federal Reserve bubble economy. Same with the new housing bubble. In my neighborhood behind the Orange Curtain housing prices are up 20% year over year and it is beginning to feel like 2006 all over again. Real Estate agents are crawling all over my neighborhood and the house flippers are back. I’m sure nothing could go wrong this time though. After all, The Dear Leader is in charge now, and he knows everything, except for all the stuff he doesn’t know about, like Benghazi, Fast and Furious, the IRS scandals, the Black Panther voter intimidation scandal, the HHS/Sibelius shakedown, Solyndra, the AP/Fox News scandal, the real cost of Obamacare, etc.

    This is what the world looks like when a paradigm shift occurs and 2500 years of Western Civilization gets flushed down the toilet in a few generations. Prepare for the barbarian hordes and just hope you can get in on the Sack of Rome before the Obamanoids steal everything that isn’t nailed down. We are all Visigoths now.

    Reply this comment
  2. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 31 May, 2013, 20:12

    Your never too old to pay taxes….

    Thick or thin, up or down…pay the man!

    It’s for the kids!

    Reply this comment
  3. Dypeptic
    Dypeptic 31 May, 2013, 23:25

    “Your never too old to pay taxes….”

    Uhaul, I hope you pay taxes long after you’re dead. Seems like you deserve it.

    BAM!!!

    WHAM!!!

    POW!!!

    Reply this comment
  4. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 1 June, 2013, 09:37

    Dipper…..never threaten CWD posters…..without diverse posts your life experiences will be your only memory bank for making the usual cruel decisions about those who suffer in California…..

    Pay your taxes and be joyful your helping your neighbors, seniors, poor exploited migrants and disadvantaged children.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply


Related Articles

CalWatchdog Morning Read – July 5

Hernandez stripped of committee assignments Older Latinos key to defeating legal pot? Will Brown keep his promises on Prop. 30?

Wealthy fleeing NY for FLA

Jan. 29, 2013 By John Seiler From the NY Post: “The city’s hedge-fund executives are flying south — and it’s

We’ll be live-blogging the election

Nov. 6, 2012 By John Seiler We’ll be live-blogging the election beginning around 5 pm, if that’s when the East