Judge: Pensions can’t be cut, but pay can

Judge: Pensions can’t be cut, but pay can

U.S. bankruptcy courtCalifornia still is a long way from resolving its pension crisis, in the courts and elsewhere. But here’s an important new development:

“SAN JOSE — In a landmark ruling that could help shape city budgets around the state, a judge invalidated key parts of San Jose’s voter-approved pension cuts but upheld other elements that could still save huge taxpayer costs.

“Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Patricia Lucas’ tentative decision released Monday prohibits the city from forcing current employees to contribute significantly more toward their pensions, as called for in last year’s Measure B. But the ruling allows the city to cut employees’ salaries to offset its increasing pension costs.”

However, unlike San Bernardino, San Jose isn’t in bankruptcy court. Judge Lucas is a California judge, who must follow California law on pensions — or at least the common current interpretation that the California Constitution prevents cuts to pensions.

As Detroit’s bankruptcy has shown, federal bankruptcy judges are under no such constraints.


Tags assigned to this article:
San JoseDetroitJohn SeilerSan Diego

Related Articles

Another company splits anti-biz CA for TX

June 26, 2013 By John Seiler Despite the so-called California recovery, companies keep leaving: Daegis Inc., the Roseville-based electronic discovery

Backlash to GOP’s AQMD takeover accelerates

Democratic politicians and environmental groups are scrambling to reverse decisions made by the South Coast Air Quality Management District board, which

Time to privatize CA parks

Feb. 15, 2013 By John Seiler Last year Californians discovered their state parks were mismanaged. While shutting parks supposedly because