LAT: All hail ‘economic stability,’ surpluses achieved by Gov. Brown

LAT: All hail ‘economic stability,’ surpluses achieved by Gov. Brown

latThe ability of Gov. Jerry Brown to convince the state press corps that he has righted California’s listing ship continues to amaze. The Golden State has by far the highest poverty rate in the nation. One in six adults can’t find full-time work — the second worst rate in the U.S. At a time when income inequality is the issue du jour, California is the poster child for the problem, and with a dramatic geographic twist: Rich people are thriving in coastal areas and Silicon Valley. The rest of Cali — say, 150,000 square miles of the state’s 164,000 square miles — remains in the deep recession that most of the nation escaped two or three years ago.

So against this backdrop, what does the L.A. Times’ Chris Megerian come up with for a big overview of how California is functioning? A sunny story with this headline: “California’s economic stability leaves Gov. Brown a new challenge.” Its message? This guy is a genius! If only he could get more support in the Legislature!

“Gray Davis, a fellow Democrat, was recalled by voters as state finances imploded following an energy crisis. Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger limped out of office with rock-bottom poll numbers, leaving a pile of debt.

“But on Brown’s watch, deficits have become surpluses, helped along by tax hikes the governor persuaded voters to approve. More money is being pumped into schools.

“University tuition has stabilized.

“Budget standoffs that once dragged through the summer are now wrapped up by the June deadline, lending the Capitol a new sense of orderliness. And on Wednesday, the governor called a special legislative session to prod lawmakers to pass his plan for saving money and paying off debt.

“That record, which will be a major part of Brown’s reelection campaign, is due partly to good fortune. California is benefiting from a nationwide economic recovery that has helped flood the state with revenue. Brown is also blessed with a Capitol dominated by fellow Democrats and a 2010 rule change that lowered the number of votes needed to pass a spending plan.”

A worship of process, an indifference to the real world

kevin-bacon-all-is-well-remain-calm-300x273So if you read this story in a vacuum, you would believe that California had a healthy economy. That’s just not true.

You would also believe California has budget surpluses. That’s just not true. California has at least $200 billion in unfunded pension and health care oblgations to retired employees. The governor declines to ask the Legislature to provide even close to the actuarial minimum to fund these obligations. How does he finesse official budget documents to sustain the myth that the state has budget surpluses? With Enron-style accounting.

What’s going on here? How can the state with the worst poverty rate in the nation and staggering debt be depicted as nirvana?

Contrary to some libertarians and conservatives in California, I really don’t think it’s the West Coast version of Obamaphilia, where gigantic screw-ups and scandals are ignored because of idolatry and partisanship. (Do you really think the IRS hassling and impeding hundreds of conservative nonprofits during a presidential election year would be covered as it’s been if Bush were sill president and the nonprofits were liberal?)

Mainly, I think it’s a reflection of how stunned the Sacramento press corps was by the post-Pete Wilson dysfunction — the decade preceding Brown’s return to the governor’s office in which the Legislature couldn’t even pass a budget on time year after year after year.

Now that Brown, aided by Proposition 25, is able to get budgets passed, the absence of this chaos seems miraculous to the Sacramento media.

RIP, skeptical journalism. At least in Sacramento.

But instead of just giving the governor credit for restoring order to the budget process, they give him much broader credit for California’s rebound and its “economic stability.”

But what rebound? Nearly one-quarter of the state is in poverty, a much worse rate than West Virginia and Mississippi.

And what “economic stability”? If a household ignored its gigantic credit-card debts, mom and dad could pretend they were thriving. But are they really thriving?

Of course not.

In our idealized “All the President’s Men” conception of journalism, we believe that journalists hunt for discrepancies between what our leaders tell us and what is the truth. But in Sacramento, our journalists do no such thing. Instead, they put on the blinders, and reflect the view expressed in another classic 1970s movie.

Remain calm! All is well!



Write a comment
  1. S Moderation Douglas
    S Moderation Douglas 19 April, 2014, 10:37

    Sour grapes.

    Whoever is in charge gets the credit…..or the blame.

    If Meg had won she would have taken full credit for the ending of the “great recession”.

    Of course, she probably would have screwed that up, too.

    Reply this comment
    • Rex the Wonder Dog!
      Rex the Wonder Dog! 19 April, 2014, 18:07

      The problem is there is no “surplus”, the pension costs are still not being funded, CURRENT COSTS, not even talking unfunded liability.

      It is a falsehood the budget is balanced.

      Reply this comment
  2. S Moderation Douglas
    S Moderation Douglas 19 April, 2014, 10:38

    The glass is AT LEAST half full.

    Reply this comment
  3. Chris Reed
    Chris Reed Author 19 April, 2014, 10:56

    SMD, my point is that Brown is getting the “credit” for victories that don’t exist.

    Reply this comment
    • S Moderation Douglas
      S Moderation Douglas 19 April, 2014, 11:45

      Only if you read the article with blinders on.

      The pension problem, in particular, is covered later in the article, and the bullet train controversy.

      “The Golden State has by far the highest poverty rate in the nation.”?

      Could that be because Brown reduced the increases in entitlement programs?

      Sounds like you’re damned if you do, and damned if you don’t.

      We are in much better shape now than four years ago.

      Wisely, he takes big challenges one at a time,” “He tries to actually get something done.” Bill Lockyear(not one of my favorite politicians, by the way)

      Reply this comment
    • Ted O'Steele, CEO
      Ted O'Steele, CEO 19 April, 2014, 21:00

      Chris you’re a broken record– Brown did what NO Repub in history has done on cuts—- wake up sleepy.

      Reply this comment
  4. Queeg
    Queeg 19 April, 2014, 16:57

    This article was a pep talk for the inevitable.

    Raise taxes.

    Reply this comment
  5. SeeSaw
    SeeSaw 20 April, 2014, 10:26

    Brown is a human being, not a magician. He took a pragmatic approach that did a lot of good for the state and caused a lot of hurt for the cities and counties, when he abolished Redevelopment. We hadn’t had a real politician guiding CA since the days of the senior Brown. Like him or hate him–he is our leader. Why doesn’t some researcher do a Study about the exact liability amount that each CA citizen pays to fund pensions each year. If that were done, all the doomers could pay their, respective, two dollars and stop focusing on the multi-billion dollar debt that will be paid in minute amounts by all the citizens as they pass through this universe. There is no Utopia–we are either going to live, or we are going to die–thankfully we live in America. I would like to live a while longer, and I don’t want to do it watching others whine 24/7 about the cost of pensions. Focus on the cost of food–that is pretty catastrophic for people on a very limited income. (My son recently went into his WalMart in WA, hungry for an avocado–the cost was $4+–he didn’t get it. CA is not the only state where the cost of living is high.)

    Reply this comment
  6. Queeg
    Queeg 20 April, 2014, 17:29

    Food costs will soar due to energy costs and practically a helpless dumbed down population incapable of personally adding value to basic food commodities……feed themselves.

    A four dollar avocado is nothing……it will be unavailable….that’s worse. Who will invest in expensive distribution when no one can afford food products.

    Reply this comment
  7. Leotis Ahmad Jones
    Leotis Ahmad Jones 21 April, 2014, 14:34

    Queen, “dumbed down population” You are pissing me off, will visit soon at ahaul.

    Reply this comment
  8. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 21 April, 2014, 23:50


    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

AG gives Parks Dept. employees immunity

Aug. 21, 2012 By Katy Grimes SACRAMENTO — The document dump over the weekend of the State Parks and Recreation

Steinberg's office responds

CalWatchdog just received this response from Darrell Steinberg’s communications director Nathan Barankin regarding this recent blog post: I read your

Video: More choices means a better education’s Brian Calle talks to Superintendent Liz Fagen about how a robust program to offer parents and students choices about