9th Circuit throws out San Jose suit against MLB

9th Circuit throws out San Jose suit against MLB

Oakland AthleticsSan Jose has been trying to snatch the A’s from Oakland. But Major League Baseball has said, “You’re out!”

MLB also depends on a 100-year-old antitrust exemption that lets it control its teams more than is allowed in pro football, basketball and hockey. The Chronicle reported:

A federal appeals court preserved Major League Baseball’s roadblock to the Oakland A’s proposed move to San Jose on Thursday, setting the stage for the South Bay city’s against-the-odds appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to roll back the sport’s nearly century-old exemption from antitrust laws.

The high court first ruled in 1922 that laws restricting monopoly enterprises didn’t apply to big-league baseball, and reaffirmed that decision in 1953 and 1972, saying Congress had acquiesced by leaving the laws intact….

In Thursday’s ruling, the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco refused to reinstate a lawsuit by the city of San Jose against the major leagues that challenged the antitrust exemption. A federal judge had dismissed the core of the suit in 2013.

“Like Casey, San Jose has struck out here,” Chief Judge Alex Kozinski said in the 3-0 decision. “Only Congress and the Supreme Court are empowered to question continued vitality (of the 1972 ruling), and with it, the fate of baseball’s singular and historic exemption from the antitrust laws.”

On something like this, the U.S. Supreme court is unlikely to challenge Congress’ powers. After all, potentially Congress could repeal all anti-trust laws, making the whole thing moot.

But there’s more to it than is in the story or decision. A century ago, there were only two nationwide professional sports: baseball and boxing. College football was popular, but was amateurs. The NFL didn’t start until 1920 and the NBA until 1946.

The NHL started in 1917, but I remember as late as the late 1960s it consisted of just the “Original Six” teams, two Canadian: Montreal Canadiens, Toronto Maple Leafs, New York Rangers, Chicago Black Hawks, Boston Bruins and my hometown heroes, Gordie Howe’s Detroit Red Wings.

As to boxing a century ago, it was mostly local, and sporadic. So MLB was the only “national” pastime. Because of its influence, it got Congress to grant it the anti-trust exemption.

Is that the picture today? No, it’s entirely different. We not only have the four large major leagues, all of which compete in the fall during the World Series. And in May-June, MLB competes against the NFL and NBA playoffs.

We also have: movies, TV, the Internet, amusement parks, soccer, Arena Football and numerous other entertainments.

Assuming the Supreme Court even takes this up, that’s how it ought to rule.

If the court wants to go “activist” on major-league sports, it should rule taxpayer ripoff subsidies of stadiums is illegal under the “General Welfare” clause.


Write a comment
  1. Queeg
    Queeg 18 January, 2015, 16:07

    People eating gruel and now baseball trivia?

    Get a grip Comrades.

    Reply this comment
  2. eck
    eck 19 January, 2015, 18:30

    John, in my opinion there is a legitimate beef here. Let’s put aside that the 9th Circuit is the most overturned in history, and look at the “equal protection angle”. MLB is a business, a BIG business. Why should it have privileges that other big businesses don’t. I don’t think it should. I also don’t think that the anti-trust laws themselves are legit either.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Sen. de Leon defends kingly swearing-in ceremony

Being king means never having to say you’re sorry. That’s sure the attitude of new California Senate President Pro Tem

CA still worst run state in the nation; Sacramento’s stadium obesssion

For the third year in a row, California has been named the worst-run state in America, by 24/7 Wall Street.

Wretched teacher discipline law: CTA shows it’s still in charge

More than three years after appalling evidence emerged that a teacher at a school in an impoverished neighborhood in south