Transparency activists seek CA sunshine


California Flag 3National Sunshine Week — an effort to increase and encourage government transparency — has come and gone in California while multiple types of state secrecy continue to draw fire from lawmakers and citizens.

Budgeting has topped the list of recent complaints. “The state of California spends nearly a quarter trillion dollars annually, but taxpayers aren’t allowed to see where that money goes,” warned, which has demanded state officials release its line-by-line state vendor payments. “This information should be available through California’s open records law, but the last two controllers, John Chiang and currently Betty Yee, told us: stop asking because the records aren’t accessible,” the organization’s founder and CEO claimed.

“The Controllers of California – John Chiang and Betty Yee – aren’t arguing against the law. Instead, they’re ignoring the law and a transparency revolution that is sweeping this country at all levels of government. The Controllers don’t cite a single provision of the California Open Records Act or a legal exemption to justify their behavior, and they aren’t fulfilling their fiduciary duty under the law to ‘assist us’ in gathering the public records.”

Chiang has tried to build a reputation as a relatively pro-transparency reformer. He proposed a law, introduced as Assembly Bill 2833 by Assemblyman Ken Cooley, D-Rancho Cordova, “that would require alternative investments such as hedge funds to publicly disclose their fees to public pension plans,” as the San Francisco Chronicle reported. “The state has committed to contribute $96 million this year toward the university [of California]’s unfunded pension liability. Yet, last year alone, UC’s pension plan paid out $97 million in fees to the hedge fund managers who are delivering mediocre returns for the plan, according to our analysis.”

String of controversies

But in recent months, transparency and accountability have become watchwords for reform across a host of flashpoint issues in California politics and policy.

In education, trouble with the state’s community college system has led its governing board to “begin searching for a replacement for the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges, Western Association of Schools and Colleges,” as the Sacramento Bee reported. “The organization, which regulates two-year schools in California, Hawaii and American territories in the Pacific, has been under fire for an inconsistent, oblique and overly punitive accreditation process.”

In criminal justice, discord has erupted over the appropriate degree of public disclosure that law enforcement officials should be required to apply to video collected by cops on the job. “Assemblyman Jim Cooper, D-Elk Grove, a former Sacramento County sheriff’s deputy, is proposing to exempt video involving police shootings and serious use-of-force incidents from the California Public Records Act until after a case is adjudicated,” as the Los Angeles Times observed, “which could be months or even years after the event.”

Sacramento squabbles

And in lobbying, Assemblyman Rich Gordon, D-Menlo Park, has taken heat for a bill, AB1200, that would “require individuals or entities to register as a lobbyist if they have been hired to influence how California awards state contracts,” as Government Technology explained. “The goal is to give the public more information about the $11 billion the state spends every year on goods and services, including lobbying activity before contracts are put out to bid.”

The state Fair Political Practices Commission has told lawmakers that it has no business tracking state procurement as a lobbying activity,” added the site. “In a March 22 letter, FPPC chair Jodi Remke wrote that AB1200 would expand the commission’s oversight to ‘a highly specialized area that is best regulated by the Department of General Services’ and other state agencies. She also questioned whether the bill would bring about the type of disclosure its backers seek.”


Write a comment
  1. Bruce
    Bruce 31 March, 2016, 11:16

    “Keep moving, these aren’t the droids (corruption) your looking for”. And with that, the peons have been dismissed.

    Reply this comment
  2. Standing Fast
    Standing Fast 1 April, 2016, 13:43

    When a public servant refuses to respond to a public records request, State law provides for a remedy. If you follow the procedure outlined in the law, you will achieve either the records you asked for, a letter explaining why the request could not be honored, or nothing.
    In the first instance, no harm.
    In the second instance, either the record qualifies as one of the few items that can be considered confidential (pending litigation and personnel matters except salaries & benefits, mostly) or the public servant that wrote the letter is mistaken.
    If the latter is the case, and in the third instance, State law tell you what you can do next, which is file a lawsuit against the government agency which denied you the records.
    For expert legal counsel, contact the California First Amendment Coalition, Californians Aware, and/or the Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence.
    The first two have handbooks on the State’s Open Government laws as well as updates on legislation, court cases and local government policy.
    Knowledge is power.

    Reply this comment
  3. Spurwing Plover
    Spurwing Plover 1 April, 2016, 20:29

    Transprency in moonbeams goverment Woo Hoo yeah Sure tell me about it

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Gov. Jerry Brown forcing electric car market in CA

Gov. Jerry Brown must be in the market for a Chevy Volt, Nissan Leaf or Tesla electric car. There could

CA continues to inhale ‘Medical’ marijuana

Faced with a growing chorus of concern among municipalities, California legislators are about to consider an innovative approach to the

Concerns raised over taxpayer disclosure bill

A bill that recently passed the state Assembly would make it easier to disclose confidential tax information and harass businesses,