Despite record surplus, Gov. Newsom wants new water, phone taxes

Gov. Gavin Newsom’s has called for a first-ever water tax and an added fee on phone bills at a time when the state is enjoying what recently departed state Legislative Analyst Mac Taylor called “extraordinary” budget health. Newsom said last week that experts now forecast a $21.5 billion budget windfall in 2019-20. Until recent years, the optics of asking the public to pay more with an overflowing budget would have seemed impossible to overcome.

Specific details have not yet emerged on Newsom’s plan, but it’s expected to be similar to a rejected 2018 proposal from state Sen. Bill Monning, D-Carmel, to tax residential customers 95 cents a month to help fund water improvements in rural farming communities in the Central Valley and throughout the state.

It would raise about $110 million to get clean water to what the McClatchy News Service estimated last year to be 360,000 people without such access. Others looking at the problem see it as much worse. Newsom said 1 million residents face health risks from their own water supplies.

Newsom emphasized what a priority the water tax would be for him on Friday by taking his cabinet on a “surprise” tour of affected Central Valley communities.

The dairy industry would also face $30 million in new fees. The $140 million annually that Newsom hopes to get from his plan is dwarfed by money already available from a $7.5 billion 2014 state water bond. While the largest chunk of the bond – $2.7 billion – was reserved for water storage projects, one of its listed priorities for the remaining $4.8 billion was providing access to clean water.

Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association President Jon Coupal saw Newsom’s water tax plan as part of a historical continuum. He told the Sacramento Bee it was only the latest example “of California’s knee-jerk reaction to default to a new tax whenever there’s a new problem.”

But Newsom depicted his 2019-20 budget as reflecting discipline, touting its emphasis on continuing to add to the state’s rainy day fund and his commitment to prepay some of CalPERS’ and CalSTRS’ unfunded long-term liabilities. Finance officials say every $1 billion prepaid now saves more than $2 billion in the long haul.

Governor cites urgent need to upgrade 911 system

Newsom also confirmed that he wants to add a 20- to 80-cent fee on monthly cellphone and landline bills to upgrade the 911 emergency notification system. That would take a two-thirds vote of the Legislature.

A similar proposal died late in the legislative session amid fears that it was a regressive tax that could cause headaches for incumbents on the November ballot.

But Newsom depicts the fee as a vital part of upgrading a 911 system that has outdated technology and is not up to the challenge of keeping safe a state facing devastating wildfires on a yearly basis.

The 911 fee was part of a larger wildfire-response program Newsom announced last week in the aftermath of last fall’s Camp fire in Butte County that killed at least 86 people and destroyed about 14,000 homes and the Woolsey Fire in Ventura and Los Angeles Counties that caused three deaths and torched 1,500 homes.

The governor wants to add $105 million to the $200 million already earmarked for improved wildfire response efforts in fiscal 2019-20. The extra money would be used to boost forest clearing efforts, to expand emergency fire rescue crews and more.


Write a comment
  1. Fletch'
    Fletch' 14 January, 2019, 11:45

    Of course he does, no source of payment or income is excluded or sacrosanct.

    Reply this comment
  2. Richard Rider
    Richard Rider 14 January, 2019, 12:32

    I love it! It’s time we start sticking it to the average Joe (and Joan) — those folks who elected Newsom and his crowd into office.

    CA can’t continue to soak the rich for our socialist state’s endless “needs.” Unlike a country, rich people (and their companies) are MUCH more likely to depart a state if given enough “incentive” — which we are already providing.

    I’ve always respected the European countries for spreading the burden for their welfare state via higher income taxes on the lower income population — and a 20+% “sales tax” (a.k.a. VAT tax) on all purchases. Their voters support it. GREAT!

    Let’s see how well these new broad regressive taxes play in California. Should be fun!

    Reply this comment
    • Sean
      Sean 14 January, 2019, 13:29

      California already has a lot of regressive taxes. State and local sales tax averages more than 8.5% statewide putting it in the top 10 nationwide. Fuels taxes and fees increase the cost per gallon of gas nearly 50% over other states. The highest portion of Medicaid recipients nationwide (31% of population) increases healthcare costs for those with employer provided coverage. A single person only needs an income of $52,600 to hit a marginal tax rate of 9.3%. Proposition 13 also increases property taxes on young, less affluent buyers. There is a reason young adults leave the state when they want to have children.

      Reply this comment
      • RBC
        RBC 14 January, 2019, 16:23

        I hear you, Sean. I have a family with 3 kids and finally made the decision to put a plan in place to exit California in the next 3-5 years.Sadly, this is a common theme for just about everyone I speak with here in California.

        Reply this comment
        • Chuck4084
          Chuck4084 15 January, 2019, 10:31

          Good for you. I left 4 years ago and haven’t missed California a bit. I discovered there is a lot of “hidden” expenses. For example I had a $1M personal liability insurance policy that cost nearly $500 per year, now I have a $2M policy that costs $150 per year. Car insurance was cut nearly in half. Once you make the move you will wonder why you waited so long.

          Reply this comment
          • kathy
            kathy 29 June, 2019, 01:33

            Where’d you move to?

        • Teddy Steele Cakes Trump Cult Fighter
          Teddy Steele Cakes Trump Cult Fighter 10 February, 2019, 10:48

          Goodbye lads!

          I love the weather, history, multi cultural communities and progressive State politics in one of the world’s best economies—- have a good time fellas— you’ll love Texas or other dust bowl ™ areas where you move!

          Reply this comment
        • Mar
          Mar 12 February, 2019, 11:41

          Yep I have a 5 year myself. Can’t retire here.

          Reply this comment
        • Me too
          Me too 19 February, 2019, 16:29

          Nevada here I come

          Reply this comment
      • phil horner
        phil horner 24 February, 2019, 22:34

        prop 13 is all that keeps from crushing renters and fixed income people.

        Reply this comment
    • Joe
      Joe 14 January, 2019, 19:52

      It’s only the beginning.

      The DemoRats have a super majority in the legislature, they hold every state wide office, Gabby Newscum is governor. They have an absolute stranglehold on power.

      There will be an orgy of tax increases, guaranteed!

      Reply this comment
      • Ted Steele, Instructor
        Ted Steele, Instructor 22 January, 2019, 10:47

        DemoRats? Wow–that’s funny— what, are you 9?

        LMAO Brown left a fiscally sounder California– I’ll take Dems any day— discuss

        Reply this comment
        • Judi
          Judi 8 February, 2019, 23:36

          Oh really? You like that newsomme gave free insurance to illegals? How bout take care of your legal people FIRST?

          Reply this comment
          • Teddy Steele Cakes Trump Cult Fighter
            Teddy Steele Cakes Trump Cult Fighter 10 February, 2019, 10:50

            FALSE Judi— didn’t happen— turn off the Fox little biddy!

            and remember what our Lord Jesus Christ said about taking care of the poor…..

            there– fixed

  3. Ulysses Uhaul
    Ulysses Uhaul 14 January, 2019, 16:38

    Uli feels your pain!!!!!

    Little use tax here and a little use tax there…….

    They are going for morning donut or burrito-

    Reply this comment
  4. machiavelli
    machiavelli 15 January, 2019, 15:15

    We congratulate the Governor…with a healthy budget, no, a budget that is “extraordinary,” the state has successfully extracted billions of our tax dollars for state programs resulting in a $21B surplus.

    This is the kind of proud announcement that immediately demands a fresh question, “Do you drink water, take a bath/shower, wash your car or water your lawn? If so, it’s time for you to pay more taxes based on your water usage. We could use the money for…whatever.”

    Reply this comment
    • RBC
      RBC 16 January, 2019, 15:55

      Mach, Thank you for the note. Curious on your perspective. why is the answer to always tax more ? The corrupt government continues to increase cost without optimizing existing budgets.

      Reply this comment
    • Nostradamus
      Nostradamus 4 March, 2019, 16:35

      A “projected” surplus. Through creative accounting practices (ie potential sale of Unicorn Farts).
      Sadly these surplus dollars never materialize and do nothing to put a dent in the $1.3T debt.
      Newsome is a typical tax & spend liberal and nothing is going to change that or the inevitable outcome.

      Reply this comment
  5. Steele, Ted
    Steele, Ted 16 January, 2019, 13:57

    Newsome sounds wise like Brown was—- saving more for a rainy day! I love California!

    Reply this comment
  6. Donkey
    Donkey 21 January, 2019, 16:34

    Ted, you are a RAGWUS feeding rat! 🙂

    Reply this comment
  7. Teddy S
    Teddy S 22 January, 2019, 10:49

    Oh– Poor Duncey is back! LMAO— Must have finished rehab…. again

    Hey what is Rawis again?

    Reply this comment
  8. Kw
    Kw 8 February, 2019, 11:55

    So with all that money set aside for water where is the dams ? Why is the water still all running into the ocean? If something isn’t done to store water nothing is going to help. I hate the fact this ass was elected none of the money ever goes where it is suppose to go. Hope you guys that wanted him still think he is so great.

    Reply this comment
  9. Scubato
    Scubato 9 February, 2019, 06:44

    The governor wants to add a tax for our water to fund projects. What he fails to tell you is the State already has a program in place to provide low interest loans to cities, counties, and special districts for infrastructure improvement projects. It’s called the State Revolving Fund or simply referred to as SRF Funding. It is self supporting and does not require any new taxes or fee’s. So why is Mr Newsom proposing a new tax for something that already has a funding mechanism?

    Reply this comment
  10. Yogster33
    Yogster33 13 February, 2019, 07:49

    What Newsom is really doing is trying to find ways to pay for illegals free healthcare.

    Reply this comment
    • kathy
      kathy 29 June, 2019, 01:43

      I see a lot of tent dwellers that could use some health care.

      Reply this comment
      • AngryCaliNative
        AngryCaliNative 3 December, 2019, 17:02

        We get them at the hospital all the time. Medi cal is applied for the minute they are admitted and even if its just ER visit we file for emergency services only thru medi cal system !
        So all those Tent folks will get care and DO have access to care. Ive been in medical field for 31 yrs! No one gets turned away! But NEWSOME is reinstating the No Insurance penalty of around 700.00 per person who doesn’t get on some kind of insurance .. try telling the thousands of tent dwelling homeless to go to their nearest district office and get on medi cal ! Not going to happen. But if they are in need of services the ER or hospital staff will get it done for them thru the financial worker at the respective facility.

        Reply this comment
  11. Cricket
    Cricket 14 February, 2019, 00:38

    Been thinking about leaving CA for a while now anyway. Living on a fixed income. Can’t afford to live here. & too many druggies & crime esp. violent crime. 👋

    Reply this comment
  12. Jim
    Jim 26 February, 2019, 09:43

    It’s a shame for us hard working middle class families that we have to pay these taxes. Can’t understand why they could just do like ordinary people and take the monies from one place and put it in another place.

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Chris Reed

Chris Reed

Chris Reed is a regular contributor to Cal Watchdog. Reed is an editorial writer for U-T San Diego. Before joining the U-T in July 2005, he was the opinion-page columns editor and wrote the featured weekly Unspin column for The Orange County Register. Reed was on the national board of the Association of Opinion Page Editors from 2003-2005. From 2000 to 2005, Reed made more than 100 appearances as a featured news analyst on Los Angeles-area National Public Radio affiliate KPCC-FM. From 1990 to 1998, Reed was an editor, metro columnist and film critic at the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin in Ontario. Reed has a political science degree from the University of Hawaii (Hilo campus), where he edited the student newspaper, the Vulcan News, his senior year. He is on Twitter: @chrisreed99.

Related Articles

CA Lifeline program cost could triple under AB 1407

  It’s been trendy for a couple of years now for people to dump their phone landlines and go only

Assembly confirms Maldonado

APRIL 22, 2010 Today the Assembly voted 51-18 to confirm Senator Abel Maldonado for Lieutenant Governor. Back in February, the Assemblyfailed

San Francisco’s $15 minimum wage goes into effect for all businesses

San Francisco this week enacted its $15 minimum wage, making it the first major U.S. city to mandate a $15