Audacity! Mich. shows Calif. GOP how to revive party

Audacity! Mich. shows Calif. GOP how to revive party

union right to work michigan - cagle cartoonDec. 12, 2012

By John Seiler

When I was growing up in Michigan in the 1960s, the Democratic Party mostly dominated the state. Kennedy, Johnson and Humphrey won the presidential contests. Democrats controlled the Legislature. And labor unions dominated the Democratic Party. Much like in California today.

One difference was that Michigan’s governors were Republicans, but they were liberal Republicans in the Schwarzenegger mold. In particular, Gov. George Romney, Mitt’s father, imposed the first state income tax and more than doubled the state budget in just six years in office. He was a Democrat in all but name.

But in the 2010s, Michigan’s Republican Party is resurgent — and offers lessons to California’s down-and-out GOP. L.A. Times columnist George Skelton and many others have suggested that the CA GOP would do better if it just became a lot more like the California Democratic Party.

The Michigan experience suggests the opposite. Two years ago, the state was a mess after eight years of Democratic Gov. Jennifer Granholm, Canadian born but raised from childhood in California’s Bay Area. Like Schwarzenegger, she also had a career in Hollylwood acting, although hers was brief. She now is teaching at U.C. Berkeley, so California taxpayers are paying for her pay, perks and pension as she teaches impressionable young minds how to misgovern.

Instead of trying to imitate Granholm and other Michigan Democrats, Michigan Republicans did the opposite: They strongly backed major budget reforms and tax cuts. They were rewarded with victory. The party now has large majorities in both houses of the Michigan Legislature. And Rick Synder is the popular, and mostly conservative, governor.

This has occurred even though the state remains mainly Democratic and voted for Barack Obama for president. The last time Michigan backed a Republican for the Oval Office was way back in 1988, the same as California.

A big reason for Republican success is that voters trust them to deal with the state’s financial messes, including effectively bankrupt Detroit. It’s not exactly clear what will happen, but actually dissolving the Motor City is one option.

In a similar fashion, former Mayor Richard Riordan has warned that Los Angeles is headed for bankruptcy.

Taking on the unions

A key part of the Republican resurgence in Michigan is taking on the unions. The Great Lake State was the cradle of the union movement a century ago. But now it has become a liability, with unions impeding reforms — the same as in California.

In the November election, the unions placed on the ballot Proposal 2, called by the unions the “Save Our Jobs” initiative. It would have given unions almost total authority over the state. Critics charged that it even would have protected unionized public-school teachers that were drunk or dealing drugs in the classroom. (That’s close to how California’s unions succeeded in defeating in our Legislature SB 1530, by state Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Los Angeles. It would have made it easier to get rid of teachers that use sex, drugs or violence against students.)

For Michigan’s union-backed Proposal 2, according to Ballotpedia, the unions massively outspent opponents by 22-to-1.

But Proposal 2 lost anyway, 57 percent to 43 percent.

Aggressive GOP

In the past, Republicans would have sighed in relief and gone back to their country clubs. (That’s certainly what Republicans did in California in the mid-1990s during their brief period of ascendance in the state Legislature.)

Not this time. As you may have heard, the Michigan Legislature just passed right-to-work laws, which Snyder signed into law. Payback time.

The reforms guarantee workers the right to join a union — or not join a union. The unions have boiled over with hatred. For them, “freedom” means forcing others to join their union. Here’s a typical response (note: bad language in the YouTube):

But here’s what it really means. An old journalistic comrade of mine, Patrick McGuigan of Oklahoma, described what happened when his state passed similar legislation:

“Congratulations, Michigan.

“In 2001, after decades of debate and a multi-million dollar campaign, voters in Oklahoma approved a ballot question enshrining the right to work in the state Constitution.

“Today, Oklahoma City has the lowest unemployment rate of any large American city. The state has outperformed much of the nation even during the depths of the Great Recession, and is projected to become one of the top states for job creation in the first quarter of 2013. Per capita personal income growth is outpacing the nation.

“Ultimately, the same results will come to Michigan.

“Monday, President Obama said the fight over Michigan’s right-to-work proposal is about politics and ideology, not economics.

“Politics is indeed part of the equation in any major policy shift in any American state — and that was certainly the case in Oklahoma in 2001, and in Indiana last year.

“But in the end, the proof is in the pudding: Oklahoma is evolving from its longstanding status as a poor, bottom-tier state into a steadily growing economy with a bright future — and that’s all about economics. Still, the strongest arguments for right to work are moral, rooted in rights of voluntary association and personal liberty.”


California desperately needs political competition. A one-party state never turns out well, whether in California or Cuba.

If Republicans want to get back in the ring and compete in California, the wrong strategy would be to mirror the Democrats.

Instead, they should look to the feisty Michigan GOP. They should take direct aim at the powerful unions. Make it a David vs. Goliath contest.

For starters, how about a right-to-work initiative on the ballot in 2014? Make sure it’s not a compromised initiative, like Proposition 32 was this year. The California unions ran ads attacking the loopholes for “special interests.”

Instead, get the ballot language from Oklahoma’s initiative, Question 695, which now is Section 23, Article 1A of the Oklahoma Constitution (text below). Make the new initiative about the unions themselves. Make it about union power. Because then the very exercise of that power — spending tens of millions of dollars in attack ads — itself is turned against the unions.

And every Republican in the state should make the right-to-work initiative the center of his campaign. No Democrat would dare buck the unions and back it. So it would be a clear contrast.

That also would help win Latino voters to the GOP. Because even many Democrats, such as former state Sen. Gloria Romero, are sick of how the the teachers’ unions care less about Latino students’ poor performance than about maintaining spiked pensions for teachers who aren’t even teaching any more.

When California state finances fall off a cliff, as they soon will, voters will look for the culprits. And as in Michigan, those culprits will be obvious: The Democratic Party and its union string-pullers.

For California Republicans, the key to victory is the same as when Danton exclaimed to the French Assembly in 1792: “Audacity! Audacity! Always audacity!”


Here’s the language of Article 23, Section 1A of the Oklahoma Constitution:


Right to work.

A.  As used in this section, “labor organization” means any organization of any kind, or agency or employee representation committee or union, that exists for the purpose, in whole or in part, of dealing with employers concerning wages, rates of pay, hours of work, other conditions of employment, or other forms of compensation.

B.  No person shall be required, as a condition of employment or continuation of employment, to:

1.  Resign or refrain from voluntary membership in, voluntary affiliation with, or voluntary financial support of a labor organization;

2.  Become or remain a member of a labor organization;

3.  Pay any dues, fees, assessments, or other charges of any kind or amount to a labor organization;

4.  Pay to any charity or other third party, in lieu of such payments, any amount equivalent to or pro rata portion of dues, fees, assessments, or other charges regularly required of members of a labor organization; or

5.  Be recommended, approved, referred, or cleared by or through a labor organization.

C.  It shall be unlawful to deduct from the wages, earnings, or compensation of an employee any union dues, fees, assessments, or other charges to be held for, transferred to, or paid over to a labor organization unless the employee has first authorized such deduction.

D.  The provisions of this section shall apply to all employment contracts entered into after the effective date of this section and shall apply to any renewal or extension of any existing contract.

E.  Any person who directly or indirectly violates any provision of this section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.

Added by State Question No. 695, Legislative Referendum No. 322, adopted at Special Election held on Sept. 25, 2001.


Write a comment
  1. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 12 December, 2012, 13:48

    Those clowns fight like Teddy’s…I mean girls… 😉

    The police should have been there to monitor this protest, but gov is pathetic, cops are only minutes away ….when seconds count..

    Reply this comment
  2. Dyspeptic
    Dyspeptic 12 December, 2012, 15:04

    “cops are only minutes away ….when seconds count..”

    Exactly! And don’t forget, the police are union thugs too.

    I heard a union goon on the radio today debating Steven Crowder. He accused Crowder of inciting the violence displayed above by, get this – asking the union demonstrators why they opposed right-to-work laws. Seems perfectly reasonable to resort to violence when asked a legitimate question. This is what happens when you allow labor monopolies to run amok.

    Regarding the resurgence of Republicans in this state I am not optimistic about that at all for these reasons – It has to get much, much worse here before that can happen and this state is bursting at the seams with people (like Jennifer Granholm) who have ruined the rest of the country with bad governance and stupid voting and then escaped the smoldering ruins of their own policies by moving here. I call them nest foulers.

    Crazyfornia really is an alternate universe so you can’t apply lessons the from reform movements in other states here. Not yet anyway.

    Reply this comment
  3. stevefromsacto
    stevefromsacto 12 December, 2012, 17:54

    Great idea, John! You got your butts kicked on Prop. 32, but you propose to keep on attacking unions. You blew Prop. 30, but you want to keep up the same anti-tax, anti-government zealotry that has turned off the moderates and independents who actually decide elections in our state.

    Guess you’ve not heard the famous expression: If you’re in a hole, the first thing to do is stop digging.

    Speaking of holes, enough about Dyspeptic. Perhaps we can share his comment about “thugs” if he ever has to call 911.

    Reply this comment
  4. Greg in LA
    Greg in LA 12 December, 2012, 19:37

    Steven from Sacto,
    Don’t get all cocky about Union power and Prop 30.
    The state of California and all of the major and minor cities in California are going to declare bankruptcy. There is nothing that is going to stop this, It’s just a matter of when.
    The state and local government employees might have been promised all the gold in the world as part of their union contracts, but it’ll never be fully paid.

    When the bankruptcy courts and governments renegotiates the contracts and pensions don’t expect anybody in the private economy to care.

    Reply this comment
    NTHEOC 12 December, 2012, 21:44

    Greg in LA, The “sky is falling” chicken little routine is getting old!!! Get over it,we won and unions are not going anywhere, so go back to your teabagger KKK meetings and think up a new mantra,loser!!!

    Reply this comment
  6. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 12 December, 2012, 22:59

    NTHEOC says:
    Greg in LA, The “sky is falling” chicken little routine is getting old!!! Get over it,we won and unions are not going anywhere, so go back to your teabagger KKK meetings and think up a new mantra,loser!!!

    KKK meetings????? Oh brother….ntheoc, take a stress tab and relax, stop the mud slinging racial comments.

    Reply this comment
  7. Marten purdy
    Marten purdy 13 December, 2012, 06:36

    Wooden, lifeless doll manipulated by hidden string pullers who put words in his mouth while living vicariously through his actions
    “At least Al Gore can pop a woody, unlike that Texas marionette”

    Reply this comment
  8. Hondo
    Hondo 13 December, 2012, 07:06

    It took the complete collapse of it’s biggest city, Detroit, to get people in Michigan to go republican. Detroit was run into the ground by a series of corrupt democratic mayors with the help of equally bad city councilmen. The big car companies didn’t just leave Detroit for no reason. They fled the horrific violence and corruption. They went to poor southern states to set up shop where the people and the cities and states were happy to have good, high paying jobs.
    You can surf the web and see the horrific pictures of that failed city, Detroit. Look up Scott Hocking on google and be prepared to be horrified. When I was young it was one of the greatest cities on earth, with the highest standard of living in the USA for its size. Now it sets the standard for failure in Amerika.
    I am afraid that Kali will have to have failures like that to get them to turn things around.

    Reply this comment
  9. SeeSaw
    SeeSaw 13 December, 2012, 09:02

    Don’t think it will last long, Hondo. Once the voters realize what their politicians have done to them, they will throw them out. In Right-to-Work states, people like restaurant servers do not even make minimum wage. They must eck out their livings via tips. Love Cali or leave it!

    Reply this comment
  10. NEM
    NEM 13 December, 2012, 10:48

    Union idiots and their poor education. What a bunch of brown-shirts. If Unions could stand on their own merits, they would not require intimidation and blood to tow the line for them. Fear thugs, fear. Your day of reckoning will be coming soon. California money will dry up for your absurd pension plans. Here is a tip: stay relevant in the work force. Less beer and sports watching and more after hour self development will land you a better job. Sissies.

    Reply this comment
  11. RC59
    RC59 13 December, 2012, 13:11

    Having lived in MI longer than I’ve been in California, I think there are a few drastic differences. Michigan is the midwest, not the left coast, meaning people there don’t so easily embrace such a leftist social welfare society as they do in CA. But politically MI is much more of a two party state than CA is. Outside of Detroit, Flint, and a few other places most of MI is moderate republican. CA has embraced dems, and dems and unions have an even bigger embrace. Even though more of MI workforce is unionized, they don’t have control of elected officials.

    Reply this comment
  12. stevefromsacto
    stevefromsacto 17 December, 2012, 11:02

    “most of MI is moderate Republican”

    Mommy, what’s a moderate Republican? Never heard of such a thing here in California. Oh, I see, they’re the ones with their heads on a stick.

    And BTW, RC59, it’s ridiculous to say: “outside of Detroit, Flint and a few other places…”. That’s like saying “outside of Los Angeles and San Francisco, California is a small state.”

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Why subsidize millionaires and billionaires?

Here’s two cheers for Democratic Assemblywoman Lori Saldaña of San Diego. She’s introduced a new law that would ban stadium

Good and bad news on bullet train(s) front

March 24, 2013 By Chris Reed As I wrote last week, the budget that Senate Democrats have embraced contains so

Amb. Bolton warns of Pacific challenges to the U.S.

California and the United States as a whole need to get their act together to face the rising challenges posed