TX routs CA in education test scores

TX routs CA in education test scores

Every time I write or speak on a radio show favorably about Texas compared with California, I get harsh online comments, emails and phone calls. The usual theme isn’t just that California is a nicer place to live. It’s that Texas is a hellhole compared with just about anywhere — a place that hates unions, poor people, nonwhites and more, and has a culture that celebrates ignorance.

This is supposedly reflected in the priorities of Gov. Rick Perry. A phone message I got expressed disbelief that I praised Texas public schools and called them broadly better than California’s. A male voice said something along the lines of … “Have you seen how little they pay for K-12? It’s obscene.”

Cal-vs-Tex-map-imageThat is not a good argument. In fact, it’s another argument for Texas.

It’s time to bring in Chuck DeVore, Orange County assemblyman turned Austin think tanker. DeVore suggests the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) is a good baseline to compare states. It measures fourth- and eighth-graders in math, reading and science and breaks down the results by the performance of white, Latino and African-American students.

So guess what happened in an analysis of the NAEP results for the eight biggest states? According to what Chuck wrote last year for the San Francisco Chronicle, it’s a rout.

“Looking at the most recent NAEP testing data for fourth and eighth graders in math, reading and science as well as looking at race and ethnicity and considering the eight biggest states, there are 24 categories to measure (e.g., eighth-grade science results for African American students, etc.). The 2009 results showed Texas as having the strongest scores in 11 of 24 categories while California was last in 15 of 24 categories. Further, Texas showed no areas of weakness compared to the national average.”

Texas makes case for Gloria Romero’s CA civil-rights argument

So Texas, the hellhole that pays obscenely little for K-12 education, stomps California — including specifically with the Latino and African-American students who are supposed to be oppressed in a Southern state like Texas as opposed to an enlightened state like California.

Gloria Romero is so right: The biggest civil rights issue in California by far is that the needs of the majority Latino students in our public schools are trumped by the needs of the largely white California Teachers Association and California Federation of Teachers.

In Texas, where teachers unions don’t dominate public education, Latinos do much better. That is not a talking point. As the NAEP scores show, it is the truth.

It should matter in the CA debate over education far more than it does. When you look at California’s actual deeds — not its rhetoric — our state government certainly celebrates ignorance far more than Texas.


Related Articles

Police video flap flares in Oakland

Several local police forces in California got on the police body-cameras bandwagon well before police killings around the nation in

Shot in the dark

At 11 a.m. today Assemblyman Pedro Nava, D-Oxnard, will hold a press conference in the State Capitol’s Room 1190 announcing

Kashkari unveils education overhaul plan

Neel Kashkari, the Republican candidate for governor who promised to campaign on “jobs and education, that’s it,” delivered on half