Will Blue-State California become Detroit on the Pacific?

Detroit city limits

Environmentalists have used the allusion of the canary in the mineshaft when describing the importance of protecting the endangered Desert Sand Fly, Stephens Kangaroo Rat or the infamous Delta Smelt. By placing these insignificant creatures on the Endangered Species List, they were able to stop construction of hospitals, schools, roads and homes. And in the case of the Delta Smelt, they turned off water to countless farms in the fertile Central Valley of California.

Long ago, the death of a canary in a mineshaft signaled the presence of poisonous gases that would imperil miners. Today, environmentalists argue that the loss of the slightest of creatures is a signal of man’s impending doom. Policies like the Endangered Species Act worked — not to save species, but to slow or stop development. Countless jobs were lost by the imposition of such noble logic. Initially created to protect the American Bald Eagle, according to the Scientific American, only 1 percent of species (20 out of 2,000) under the protection of ESA have recovered to qualify for being taken off the endangered list.

It is time to use this same allusion to analyze the aggressive policies of the Progressive Movement in America as they seek to create their vision of a Blue Utopia in America. One must study the impact of their policies, not on canaries, but to the plight of hard-working American families. Will the canary warn us of the poisonous economic gases of Progressive policies? Or has the canary already died? Look no further than Detroit as a city and California as a state before entering the economic future mine shaft of our nation.

Detroit: A Model City in Blue Utopia

In the 1950ss and 60s, Detroit was the fourth largest city in the United States, with arguably the highest median income, the highest percentage of home ownership and the highest standard of living in the country. The industrial capacity of Japan, Germany, France and England had been decimated by war. America, the “arsenal of democracy” protected by oceans, stood alone with an untouched industrial capacity able to supply the Baby Boom population with the new suburban homes, appliances and cars they wanted.

Detroit’s workers had plenty of good-paying jobs thanks to the dominance of the auto industry. Detroit had modern skyscrapers, mass-transit trolley cars and great public services — water, sewer, roads, public schools and libraries. It had museums, parks, a symphony orchestra and a world-class zoo. Its sports teams included Lions, Tigers, Pistons and Red Wings. Detroit worked. Its weather was not great, but no worse than Cleveland, Philadelphia, New York or Boston. This was Detroit’s Golden Era.

After 1962, backed by the powerful unions of the auto industry, Detroit tilted from a two-party political system to one-party rule. Democrats, fueled by union contributions, routed Republicans from office and had their way governing Detroit for the next 50 years. They brought $400 million in federal funds to Detroit from President Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society and “Model Cities” initiatives. Their progressive policies were unchallenged.

With one-party rule, the Progressives were able to impose their utopian ideas on the bluest of American cities without political debate. What did their vision of Blue Utopia create? In 1967, Detroit burned. During horrific race riots, 2.500 businesses burned to the ground and 43 people were killed. That same year saw 67,000 people move out of the city and another 80,000 followed in 1968.

With the election of Coleman Young in 1973 as the nation’s first black mayor, the shift to Progressive policies supported by massive federal funding was complete. Detroit’s Golden Era was gone. The canary was dead. The proof is history itself.

Detroit in 2012 is a shadow of its former self. Its population has shrunk from 1,849,568 in 1950 to 706,000. Of 12,103 babies born in Detroit in 2009, 75.4 percent were born to unmarried women (2010 Census Bureau survey). Unemployment officially stands at 29 percent. But Mayor Dave Bing said at a recent White House Jobs Summit that Detroit’s unemployment rate was “probably close to 50 percent.”

Bing, like every Detroit mayor since 1962, went to Washington to press the federal government to channel more money directly into the city. There are between 100,000 and 200,000 vacant houses in the city and the average home price has fallen below $10,000. That unimaginable number is not a typo but a symbol of reality in modern Detroit. Over 500 arson fires are set in the city of Detroit per month.

According to one report, “The Detroit Fire Commissioner, Donald Austin has suggested that it be wiser for the sake of cost and safety, to allow some vacant structures to burn when set on fire by arsonists. He has suggested the fire department handle the fire as a controlled burn, rather than extinguish the fire and leave a half burnt down shell that poses the danger of an unpredicted collapse.”

In 2010, Detroit Mayor Dave Bing proposed a radical plan to bulldoze 40 square miles of the city (25 percent), turning it back into pre-1950’s farmland. Economics writer Benjamin Clement wrote in an article, “Detroit: America’s War Torn City“:

Visiting Detroit is the closest Americans can come to viewing what appears to be a war-torn city without leaving the U.S. This former powerhouse is a barren stretch of land, devastated by looters and full of run-down, vacant houses. Rows upon rows of dilapidated structures line the streets; empty apartment buildings and factories consume the landscape. Almost a third of Detroit has been abandoned.”

Detroit once manufactured 5 million cars per year and now produces just 2 million. Detroit has been ruled for 50 years by one party, which is funded by the once-powerful labor unions. In the 1970s, the unions arrogantly ignored low-priced Japanese imports and allowed Toyota and Nissan to take their jobs. They refused to make wage concessions when manufacturers threatened to move to Ohio, Alabama and South Carolina — and lost more jobs.

As even more automobile manufacturing was outsourced under the North American Free Trade Agreement, the unions had become too weak to block the legislation in 1994. Understandably when jobs left, people followed in search of work, just as in the dust bowl days. Detroit today is a city on life support; its factories silent, its jobs gone, its coffers empty, its schools bankrupt and its families ripped asunder.

In 1960, no one could envision the rapidity of Detroit’s decline. How could this happen in Blue Utopia?

California: Today’s Blue Utopia

Spanish-American philosopher George Santayana said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” Californian’s political leaders ignore the canary lying on the bottom of its cage and blindly follow Detroit’s model.

Last November, California voters vanquished the last of the state Republicans, leaving no Republican holding statewide public office. Democrats, capturing supermajorities in both the state Senate and the Assembly, no longer need a single Republican vote to pass legislation, including tax increases. They are fueled by powerful labor unions that collect dues from teachers and public employees to fund campaigns that guarantee the re-election of their proxies in the Legislature, who vote higher and higher benefits to union members.

City after city faces bankruptcy and ruin from massive unfunded pension obligations that allow lifeguards in Newport Beach to retire at 50 years old with $108,000 annual pensions for life. The Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research reported in Feb.  2012 that local governments have $200 billion in unfunded pension obligations that will consume 17 percent of municipal budgets. An earlier report in 2010 revealed the State of California has $500 billion in unfunded pension obligations.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger issued a supposed hiring freeze during the worst of the 2008-2009 recession. Yet the state continued to hire more workers, adding over 13,000 employees in 2008-2009.  Salaries that fuel high pension costs are also out of control. U.C. Berkeley’s “Institute for Research on Labor and Employment” produced a detailed policy paper entitled “The Truth about Public Employees in California” that revealed the following:

* The average public sector worker makes $65,000 per year, plus pension, health and vacation benefits, making their average total compensation $102,225 per year.

* The average private sector worker makes $46,500 per year, plus pension, health and vacation benefits, making their average total compensation $57,558 per year.

With policies like this, California ran $20 billion deficits year after year. Gov. Jerry Brown declared California should generate a surplus this year with the passage of Proposition 30, which raised the top state income tax on the wealthy to 13.3 percent — higher than top tax rate in Russia. And Californians also have to pay the 39.6 percent top federal income tax rate.

But  Brown and his fellow Progressives have plans to spend this tax windfall on new state spending like a Bullet Train between Fresno and Bakersfield that will cost $68 billion. 

California’s schools once were the envy of the world. This is no longer true. Journalist Peter Schrag describes it as the “Mississippification” of California.

California voters and politicians have drained education’s coffers to pay for prolific spending elsewhere in the state budget. In 2011, public colleges and universities received 13 percent less in state money than they had in 1980 (when adjusted for inflation). Its Community College system lost $809 million — or 12 percent of their state funding — since 2008. The state’s K-12 education system now ranks 49th in state spending per pupil. California could face a shortfall of a million skilled workers by 2025.

According to Columnist David Spady, California local school districts have become some of the worst abusers of passing on debt to future generations. In Poway, voters approved borrowing $105 million for its schools. Payments of $50 million per year begin in 20 years, with total repayment of $981 million. Voters shackled future residents with a terrible burden for spending today.

Poway is not alone. In response to reduced funding, since 2007 school districts in California borrowed $7 billion for new construction projects using Capital Appreciation Bonds that feature no payments for 20 years.

The Central Valley, once the food basket of America, found its water diverted from farms to the ocean to “protect” the Delta Smelt. To protect this tiny fish, otherwise known as bait, water was diverted from farms, eliminating 37,000 jobs and leaving 300,000 acres fallow. Unemployment in the Central Valley is now 40 percent in places with farm workers relying on food stamps to feed their families.

With unemployment in California officially near 10 percent, but practically around 15 percent, people continue to migrate out of the Golden State in search of jobs and opportunities elsewhere. It is understandable and the consequences are obvious.

This migration, which began two decades ago, has now picked up speed with new taxes on the wealthy and the successful fund the Progressive vision of Blue Utopia. Golfer Phil Mickelson was ridiculed for stating the obvious — that he might have to leave California. With the new California taxes imposed by Prop. 30, Mickelson’s “fair share” is around $8 million per year — $22,000 per day or $1,000 per hour — for the privilege of living in their Blue Utopia. Can anyone blame Mickelson when he moves to Florida, where there is no state income tax?

Blue Utopia America?

We have a Progressive President who, with his re-election, made it clear he plans to pursue a Progressive agenda. He wants clean water, clean air and green energy. He proclaims Republicans want dirty air and dirty water and oppose him on green energy. He would like nothing less than one party rule so he can impose his vision of Blue Utopia on America.

If Americans paid attention to the past, they might not be condemned to repeat it. If they were paying attention now, they would notice the canary in their mineshaft gasping for breath. If they studied the policies that have already failed miserably, making Detroit a third world city, they could change course and save the Golden State. If our leaders in Washington did the same, they would know better than to push us down this path. The problem is we do not teach history anymore. And if Americans cannot remember their own past, they too will be condemned to repeat it.

Robert J Cristiano, Ph.D, is the Real Estate Professional in Residence at Chapman University in Orange, Calif.; a Senior Fellow at the Pacific Research Institute in San Francisco, Calif.; and president of the international investment firm, L88 Companies LLC in Washington, D.C., Newport Beach, Denver and Prague. He has been a successful real estate developer for more than 30 years. 


Write a comment
  1. American Ruins
    American Ruins 18 February, 2013, 13:58

    It’s possible the population of Detroit is below 700,000.


    The Ruins of Detroit:


    Another winner is New Orleans:

    1960 population 627,525

    2005 population 454,865

    2010 population 343,829

    The Ruins of New Orleans:


    Reply this comment
  2. s t olson
    s t olson 18 February, 2013, 15:18

    It amazes me that no one can stop the EPA from destroying the farming economy in CA. Politicians surely don’t want to have CA be a third world economy, mainly dependent on Silicon Valley and start-ups. I know of 2 owners who left CA and it was because of regulations and being treated as if criminals for conducting business in CA. There were then layoffs. How will thery collect taxes to pay for astronomical pension amounts? Maybe all public emplyees need to be put on a 401K plan as in private industry and forget the union pensions. Something has to be done.
    Agriculture in Mexico coming in is not inspected when in ground as in the USA, and this is a health issue. Why bring in imports? Is this a dark part of Agenda 21 run by Brussels via the UN????

    Reply this comment
  3. Wayne Lusvardi
    Wayne Lusvardi 18 February, 2013, 15:49

    I’m not sure the Detroit metaphor is apt for the future of California.

    What we’re more likely to see is something like the social class structure of Brazil: an upper class derived for historical Colonialism and from government granted monopolies; a thin middle class of “New Class” knowledge workers who own no real property and only work their way up the ladder by government patronage, an almost non-existent private middle class based on private property, and a large working and lower class with little social mobility.

    The private middle class is slowly leaving California. The rural mostly immigrant poor more resemble those living in favelas in Brazil.

    The new economic structure of California is government protected monopolies that can make rigged profits so as to support the dependents at the bottom of the class structure. Those at the top have formed a coalition with those at the bottom to play both against the middle.

    Reply this comment
  4. us citizen
    us citizen 18 February, 2013, 16:53

    What the sam blazes is wrong with the politicians in this state. Are they all so darned stupid that they cant see any of this or are they continually just worried about getting re-elected. I swear the AWFUL school system here is doing nothing but pumping out morons to run the govt.

    Reply this comment
  5. Rex the Wonder Dog!
    Rex the Wonder Dog! 18 February, 2013, 17:39

    Detroit used to be beautiful over 30 years ago, it is so bad today it looks like Beirut, and I have been in Detroit many times in the last 20 years.

    Reply this comment
  6. Hondo
    Hondo 18 February, 2013, 17:58

    No MSM will look at Detroit or at the slaughter house that is Chicago. Go to Scotthocking.com to see the horrific pictures of that once shinning city. The pictures of the boats are beyond belief.
    There are no Republicans in the food chain that ate Detroit. Tens of billions of federal funds have been poured into the corrupt Detroit political machine to try and shore up the city. All of it has been stolen. Just look at the Scott Hocking pictures.

    Reply this comment
  7. eyeamok
    eyeamok 18 February, 2013, 18:01

    ” Are they all so darned stupid that they cant see ”

    Don’t think for one second these people do not know Exactly what they are doing, their goal is Power and Control, They truly are just EVIL. If we truly had real education in this country, the 18 yr olds upon graduating high school would Repudiate The Debt that the “Greatest Generation” so proudly ENSLAVED them with. The borrower is Slave to the Lender.

    Reply this comment
  8. jimmydeeoc
    jimmydeeoc 18 February, 2013, 21:22

    Re: Scott Hocking.

    I checked. I hate scrolling horizontally…..gives me indigestion….lol

    For a similar site that won’t make you toss your cookies:


    Chronicling Detroit’s destruction has become something of a cottage industry.

    Reply this comment
  9. stolson
    stolson 19 February, 2013, 08:01

    RE: The new economic structure of California is government protected monopolies that can make rigged profits so as to support the dependents at the bottom of the class structure. Those at the top have formed a coalition with those at the bottom to play both against the middle.

    I think this has been going on for awhile. However, those benefitting from the Silicon Valley start-ups are private propery owners, and hope the innovative ones keep them going. The illegals have really hurt this state in many ways. The Democratic machine now counts on them and the unions as the voter base. But, without the middle class, how can the monopolies keep rigging prices? Who will pay?

    Reply this comment
  10. surfpunk
    surfpunk 19 February, 2013, 12:16

    THE NEW CALIFORNIA will be really neat for some,mostly the ultra rich.agenda 21,one bay area,ab32,green green green. Is your house- smart,are you aware what is in your local general plan? Stop funding the U.N. now, before they take your guns.

    Reply this comment
  11. jimmydeeoc
    jimmydeeoc 19 February, 2013, 14:05

    Wayne’s crystal ball is indeed crystalline. Brazil is EXACTLY where we are headed. And while there……be sure to make note of the crime rates.

    Yes, I am well aware our rates have been in decline since 1990. (My preemptive response to the usual suspects who will point this out).

    But no one says they have to stay there. And given the lack of opportunity for the lower-middle and lower classes….don’t be surprised if they start climbing again.

    Reply this comment
  12. Greg in LA
    Greg in LA 24 February, 2013, 09:46

    The thing that the article didn’t mention is that it wasn’t the population that left Detroit, it’s the White population that left Detroit.

    Viewing the Detroit of today and the last 30 years, one can see what life is like in Black run areas and areas where Whites don’t live. One can safely say that it’s not a pretty sight.

    The suburbs around Detroit aren’t bad. There also majority White.

    I can see California becoming the counterpart of Detroit, as White Americans leave California the same way they left Detroit.

    Reply this comment
  13. DeeDee
    DeeDee 16 March, 2013, 08:14

    Again and again I say to deaf ears – America has left God out of the picture. Obama, sadly, was right. We are no longer a Christian nation. If America thinks they can survive without God, she is dead. But God knows the hearts of those who truly do repent and ask for His return. That means we vote for ONLY pro-life candidates. The moment she goes to her knees to ask forgiveness, watch miracles unfold. That’s it period!

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

New law needed to simplify CA budget

Nov. 21, 2012 By Wayne Lusvardi Every year state Senator Joe Simitan, D-Palo Alto, holds a contest for his constituents to

Deadbeat California Needs a Payday Loan

JULY 15, 2011 By CHRISS STREET For the State of California and its counties and cities, tax collections tend to

Reaching 50 percent renewable goal won’t be easy  

Yesterday Democratic leaders in the California Senate introduced a series of bills to move the state to a goal of 50 percent renewable