Caltrans director about to be quietly reconfirmed

April 2, 2013

By Katy Grimes


Caltrans is an agency in trouble. The most recent buffoonery involves putting California motorists at risk, with the 30 broken bolts discovered on the newly renovated San Francisco Bay Bridge. And apparently Caltrans knew about this.

A recently released report from the California League of Cities California State Association of Counties and other transportation organizations found only 56 percent of California’s local streets and roads were deemed to be in “good” condition, and 49 of the state’s 58 counties were rated “At Risk” or in “Poor’ condition.

“By ‘streets and roads,’ the report is also referring to bridges and essential components like sidewalks, storm drains, curbs and traffic signs,” the AllGov California website reported. “Pavement accounts for $59.1 billion of the projected shortfall. Essential components are $21.8 billion and bridges are $1.3 billion.”

California, once famously known as ‘The Golden State,” is now characterized as being “on the edge of a cliff” because of our failing roads and highways system, the 2012 California Statewide Local Streets and Roads Needs Assessment found.

And if you’ve ever had a pothole destroy one of your car’s wheels or rims, that’s just the tip of the iceberg.

Who is to blame?

But there is so much more, and Malcolm Dougherty, Caltrans Director, is about to be reconfirmed by the Senate without so much as a single question or confrontation over the many important issues.

According to a memo originated in Sen. Joel Anderson’s office, and passed around to many offices in the Senate, Dougherty has been a key member of Caltrans’ “deteriorating leadership” for the last 21 years.

While Dougherty has been Caltrans Director since May 2012, he has been with Caltrans since 1992.

But even more telling are the outrageously poor rankings Caltrans has received over 20 years, according to Anderson’s office research:

* Ranked 50th in overall highway performance and spending efficiency

* Ranked 49th for having urban interstates in poor condition

* Ranked 48th for having rural interstates in poor condition

* Ranked 48th for having rural arteries in poor condition

* Ranked 41st for having rural arteries with narrow lanes

* Ranked 35th for having deficient bridges

* Ranked 34th for having urban interstate congestion

If this is the case, Caltrans management has fallen on their behinds. But does anyone in the Legislature care?

“During his 20 years with Caltrans, Dougherty has served in several high-profile management positions,” the Caltrans website says. “Before being appointed Director, he served as Chief Deputy Director, where he advised and assisted the Director with all aspects of Caltrans’ policies and operations.”

Based on that bio, it sounds to me as if Dougherty is not only the top dog at Caltrans, he has been making management decisions for many years.

However, the one opportunity for oversight during the most recent Senate Rules Committee confirmation hearing, never even brought up the Caltrans performance issues at Dougherty’s confirmation.

The hearing wasn’t televised, as is the normal procedure, however there is supposed to be audio of it. I am still trying to locate this, and will follow up.

Another culture of corruption?

“The Caltrans’ culture is now one of denial and cover-up,” the memo from Anderson’s office said.

The memo also exposes:

* Busted bolts: “At least 30 of the giant bolts that hold together the new, $6.4 billion eastern span of the Bay Bridge have snapped . . . the bridge, which has been under construction for more than a decade, has had a history of trouble and setbacks.” – San Francisco Chronicle, 3/27/13.

* $5.6 million party: “State officials say it’s important to give the public a chance to walk across the dazzling new eastern span of the Bay Bridge when it opens Labor Day weekend, even if it costs taxpayers $5.6 million.” – Oakland Tribune, 2/9/13

* $10 million PR contract: “Taxpayers were nearly taken with a $10 million PR contract – for a new bridge.” – San Gabriel Valley Bulletin, 12/21/12

* “Fiasco of the Decade:” The California Taxpayers Association highlighted the “Caltrans $3.2 billion Bay Bridge fiasco” as part of California’s “decade of waste, fraud and mismanagement” from 2000 to 2010.

* Phony Inspections: Caltrans officials concealed the fact that one of their employees – Duane Wiles – falsified piling inspections on the Bay Bridge until the scandal was exposed by the Sacramento Bee. “Caltrans’ responses to (the Sac Bee reporter) Charles Piller have been especially troubling. Its spokesmen have dodged the issues raised by Wiles’ actions, minimized potential problems, taken no responsibility for failing to act, and refused to release key documents.” – Sacramento Bee, 11/13/11

* Corruption: When forced by the media to admit that Wiles did report phony inspection data, Dougherty and other Caltrans officials arranged a show “firing” of Wiles followed by a quiet “re-hiring” and then a “retirement” by Wiles. – Sacramento Bee, 1/26/12

* Cover-up: The retirement deal Dougherty and Caltrans officials made with Wiles “prevents a public airing of Wiles’ admitted fraud and errors, and removes a public forum for examining whether agency higher-ups responsibly addressed the problem.” – Sacramento Bee, 1/26/12 

But it doesn’t stop there. “Dougherty is a key part of the Caltrans’ culture change from a “can-do” agency to “probably can’t” laughingstock,” the memo said, including:

“Neglect of duty:” On March 28, 2013, the California State Auditor stated that “Caltrans Employees Engaged in Inexcusable neglect of Duty, Received Overpayment for Overtime, Falsified Test Data, and Misappropriated State Property.”

High salaries: According to the Sacramento Bee, the 20,000 employees at Caltrans are paid on average over $100,000 in salary and benefits yearly.

Pay-spiking: The State Auditor also stated that during a four-year period (2005-2009), when the state was experiencing record deficits, “the annual salaries of certain Caltrans employees, including engineers, increased by more than 40 percent.”

There is more in the memo, including:

“Buying booze, drinking & driving on state time: CBS 2 (Los Angeles) has done multiple stories in the last two years on Caltrans supervisors and employees using state vehicles to make booze runs to the store and consuming beer after beer after beer during lunches before heading back to the Caltrans yard.”

Even if only one or two of these blatant violations were true, the coach should be changed. Any bad coach in professional sports is removed and replaced.

There will be an actual hearing on Dougherty’s confirmation, maybe as early as Thursday of this week. I am hoping that some lawmakers under the dome have the gumption and integrity to question Dougherty about some of these issues, and at least ask him what his plan is to change the culture of complacency and corruption at Caltrans.

If the Legislature does not grill Dougherty, and he flies through the hearing without any real questions or answers, we will know without a doubt, that the California State Legislature has abdicated its true oversight role for crony capitalism.

The question then facing all of California, is what will they abdicate next?

(If you are having trouble opening the link to the memo, I’ve also posted it on my facebook page)


Write a comment
  1. Sean Morham
    Sean Morham 3 April, 2013, 12:59

    Looking at all those low rankings, the salary sounds like he is a model California state department head. He and his department are more than overtly corrupt. What is there not to like,admire and reward?

    Reply this comment
  2. Rocco Roberts
    Rocco Roberts 3 April, 2013, 21:17

    I thought Caltrans employees were supposed to be taking some Fridays off to help with the budget, however I have seen them working on Saturdays and Sundays several times doing what appeared to be routine work. What is the deal? Where is the oversight?

    Reply this comment
    • Dinger
      Dinger 9 August, 2017, 18:59

      The ones that work on the HIGHWAY, ARE NOT ALL BAD, SOME OF US WORK, THE Raise is Going to People , That want to SHAKE THE BLANKET. They want to send a 7 man crew, TO FIX WHAT THEY PAID ____________(________. Contractors. To do . I don’t think The Director, Knows what’s going on, It’s beneath him.

      Reply this comment
  3. Willam Tyler
    Willam Tyler 13 May, 2014, 09:29

    I would like to know where to report a project that was to repair Highway 193 in El Dorado County.I had contacted Caltrans with my concerns about the construction methodsand was never contacted back. The highway is failing exactly were they tried to repair it

    Reply this comment
  4. equipment operator
    equipment operator 23 July, 2014, 19:25

    My question is why is there an inequity in wages between Department of Water Resources and Caltrans My Operator II Wages are approximately $4100. top wage DWR starting $5100. We as Hwy workers endure extremely hazardous working condition continuously on any given day does this not warrant compensation what process and procedure to increase are wages to be comparable to are conterparts at Department of Water Resouirces.

    Reply this comment
  5. jay stammerjohan
    jay stammerjohan 15 August, 2015, 08:30

    i am putting in that after since of 2008 caltrans has not or wish to take the deal to re pay for a injurey i had due to a crew as i am now cripped and un able to find a job it is time to temp. close down till they sit and talk

    Reply this comment
  6. Why do u hate women?
    Why do u hate women? 14 October, 2017, 22:01

    CEO Malcolm Daugherty is corrupt as they come. I have years of experience and I’ve been trying to get a job with Caltrans (highway maintenance) for over two years +. They will not hire me because I am an older female. I emailed Daugherty but he would not respond, he had some women email me trying to convince me it was my resume. I told her it’s not my resume and San Jose Caltrans gave me a fake interview. Hope Daugherty gets canned!

    Reply this comment

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Dominy lives

Today’s LA Times carries the obituary of one Floyd Elgin Dominy, who ran the U.S. Bureau of Land Reclamation from

Trump may be reluctant to settle Trump University lawsuit

Will Donald Trump accept a high-profile legal setback so soon after his greatest triumph? That’s the question hanging over the

As I predicted, state revenue up — for now

Jan. 23, 2013 By John Seiler A week ago I wrote on, “Two critical budget dates approaching.” I predicted